There are 202 users in the forums

Jimmy Garoppolo, QB, Los Angeles Rams

Shop 49ers game tickets
Originally posted by NYniner85:

The way things are worded make it easy to deny after the fact. When I first read that comment I immediately realized he never said that there was a formal offer. Easy way to plant an idea and then deny it afterward.
Originally posted by NYniner85:

So there was an informal discussion between some people who were associated in some capacity with each organization? That sounds rather flimsy. I'm thinking that eventually it'll be revealed that Seth's source for this trade offer was a 9moon post. Though if that were the case it'd be reported that we asked NE for a 1st in exchange for Deebo and Jimmy.
  • thl408
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 33,058
Originally posted by 49ersRing:
Originally posted by NYniner85:

So there was an informal discussion between some people who were associated in some capacity with each organization? That sounds rather flimsy. I'm thinking that eventually it'll be revealed that Seth's source for this trade offer was a 9moon post. Though if that were the case it'd be reported that we asked NE for a 1st in exchange for Deebo and Jimmy.

He overheard the cafeteria chef discuss it with the waterboy. Boom, inside source.
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Originally posted by NYniner85:

The way things are worded make it easy to deny after the fact. When I first read that comment I immediately realized he never said that there was a formal offer. Easy way to plant an idea and then deny it afterward.

This is also why everyone thinks Shanahan wanted Jones and no one else.
Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Franchise408:
Originally posted by NYniner85:


At least he has the guts to clarify and sort of back track.
Originally posted by D0PEMAN:
Originally posted by LottDMontanaO:

But I'm moving on to this Sunday vs. the Bears. Here's where I'm at: I want to see Jimmy come back strong and do his part in providing very good QB play from start to finish like we've seen from him many times in the past when he plays the entire game (doesn't come out due to injury). The motivation should be there to come back from that performance vs. the Colts...also, in coming back to his home state in front of family and friends...coming back to the place he had his first Niners' start and played very well all things considered/being so new to the scheme & playbook. And beyond all that, motivation for himself to start playing better this game & moving forward if he really wants to be looked at by coaches around the league (let alone the Niners this season re: QB1) as a good-to-very good QB again that could be considered a fit for their teams down the road. Potential future starting QB motivation & maximizing future earnings motivation for Jimmy.

I like the optimism but it doesn't hold much water. The truth is that Jimmy isn't the ONLY problem, so even if he tried to play his best it won't matter because the entire offense sucks, and we're going to keep losing games until Kyle fixes it. The only way Jimmy could maximize his future contract is if somehow he miraculously turns into Tom Brady 2.0 and takes us to at least the playoffs this year, which let's just be honest, is a pipe dream.

That said I actually think it's in Jimmy's best interest to NOT start anymore games for the 49ers. This team is currently a mess and needs fixing way beyond the QB position.
I wouldn't be surprised if Jimmy pulls another calf muscle on Sunday.

Kyle can't fix players that are not executing. He can do a better job sequencing plays and game management but he can't go out and block and catch and tackle.

The problem with the offense currently is at RG. Brunskill is a tackle with excellent agility but does not have the lead in his butt to hold off bigger, stronger DTs, and it is showing. I'm sure everyone in the building hopes Banks would develop and win that job and allow DB to return to the swing tackle slot. Banks didn't and now we have to hop for the best.

McGlinchey has caught a lot of flack, some deserved but most not. His run and pass blocking are almost equal and overall he has moved up to the 24th ranked tackle overall. Not what we hoped for his draft position but he is right in there with 10-12 other OTs that all are considered above average in the league. He is not the reason the offense is not working.

Right now, Jimmy is totally lacking confidence and all this talk about Lance is not helping. To make matters worse, everyone knows Lance is not ready. The comparison with Fields this week will be interesting. Does anyone really want to see Lance having the same issues? He will.

Greg Cosell said this morning that this team is still a Super Bowl roster if it can get a win this weekend and turn things around. Winning cures everything.
wrong thread
[ Edited by TheGore49er on Oct 28, 2021 at 1:36 PM ]
Originally posted by Snitch:
LOL at this Brady news. Brady showed his age last year and had no arm strength or accuracy. Guy needs to retire. I'm fine with Jimmy G.

Oof.
Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:
Originally posted by Franchise408:
Originally posted by NYniner85:


At least he has the guts to clarify and sort of back track.

Has the guts? If he had guts he'd admit that he put made up BS in his book to sell it. I love when media guys get caught red handed lying about stuff for sensationalism. To back pedal and say "well I didn't actually say this" is BS. He knew exactly what he was saying. People need to stop believing everything the media says.
Originally posted by 49ersRing:
Originally posted by Snitch:
LOL at this Brady news. Brady showed his age last year and had no arm strength or accuracy. Guy needs to retire. I'm fine with Jimmy G.

Oof.

Lol I saw that too with that bump of an old post. That's some all timer ice cold take
Originally posted by 49ersRing:
Originally posted by Snitch:
LOL at this Brady news. Brady showed his age last year and had no arm strength or accuracy. Guy needs to retire. I'm fine with Jimmy G.

Oof.

At the time, this was the correct line of thinking. Brady looked done, and Garoppolo had just been to the SB. But thanks Captain Hindsight for pointing this out now. 🙄
Originally posted by NYniner85:

FWIW, Pats fans were s**tting all over this "report" and called it BS from the start.

But tbf Pats fans absolutely loathe Wickersham.
Originally posted by Niners99:
Originally posted by 49ersRing:
Originally posted by Snitch:
LOL at this Brady news. Brady showed his age last year and had no arm strength or accuracy. Guy needs to retire. I'm fine with Jimmy G.

Oof.

At the time, this was the correct line of thinking. Brady looked done, and Garoppolo had just been to the SB. But thanks Captain Hindsight for pointing this out now. 🙄

A lot of us wanted to move on from Jimmy after the SB. I know I sure did.
Originally posted by Niners99:
Originally posted by 49ersRing:
Originally posted by Snitch:
LOL at this Brady news. Brady showed his age last year and had no arm strength or accuracy. Guy needs to retire. I'm fine with Jimmy G.

Oof.

At the time, this was the correct line of thinking. Brady looked done, and Garoppolo had just been to the SB. But thanks Captain Hindsight for pointing this out now. 🙄

That was the surface level analysis at the time, but Brady's receivers that year consisted of an old, broken down Julian Edelmann and nobody else. I don't know if Shanahan or Lynch watched any of his film that year before declining to replace Jimmy.
Share 49ersWebzone