Jimmy Garoppolo, QB, Los Angeles Rams

I was hoping comparing him to Garcia would get this stupid conversation moving.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by SkyZer0:
it was accurate enough to hit the receivers hands and be caught.

/topic

It was high and behind on a slant…you don't throw the ball behind someone who's running the opposite way. Totally catchable but again not a accurate ball.

Different view shows it

Deebo should've caught this but man, you just cannot throw this high and behind when he is wide ass open. pic.twitter.com/Ck31YG7f7z

— Rich (@richjmadrid) November 2, 2021

already looked at this view. and another view. and another. and 15+ pages of discussions about it. and film breakdown from fans about it.

accurate enough, lol.

Originally posted by TreyDeyEeyDey:

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:

Originally posted by TreyDeyEeyDey:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by TreyDeyEeyDey:

This is what I'm talking about…you can't be an adult and admit the throw was high and behind. You've shown you can't be objective and you're bias as s**t. We all know it…it just makes any future debates you have in here less meaningful.

It's okay to say Jimmy isn't perfect, I'm sure he doesn't read anything anyone writes in here do your safe.

It's literally the dumbest argument I have ever had. I'm sorry. The ball hit him center mass right above the helmet not behind him. It was a good throw. Explain to me why a throw that hits a receiver right in the hands is being talked about? The announcer even says "he dropped it". It happens.

Jimmy is far from perfect. The other day when I was looking at past stats he would be similar to Jeff Garcia in most real stats if he played the same tenure with 9ers as Garcia did which he won't. He's Jeff Garcia to me. Good, sometimes fantastic, and sometimes pretty f**king meh. Like Garcia though I support him, you simply don't. If we want to talk real, then be honest. You do not support him. You never do. Since I started here all you did was s**t all over him. Never anything positive. If so it feels forced and bitter. I understand who he is. You hate him for who he is. And I've said this before but hate as in terms of sports hatred not like you actually hate the guy. I've even had the audacity to admit his leash is getting shorter with me. As random pointed out at one point I was ready to move on but I came back down to earth. If he can put together a few good games and we get healthy than hell yeah. If we lose one or two more and need a boost, I'm ready for Trey.

It's nice to support both guys and the team.

Now one day... Just to make a point I am going to do this to Trey. Remember this and remember I'm making a point not being a hater. I'm going to bring up pages, tweets, of him hitting a receiver in the hands and making a stupid argument about nothing really. Not every pass is perfect. That was still a good catchable ball.

Deebo is literally contorting his body to catch that pass and you claim it's a "good throw?" Come on dude. CATCHABLE, sure. Should have been caught, sure. NOT a good throw.

Ball should have been thrown somewhere around the yellow mark here:

Nice play of frame. It was center mass, right between the eyes. Not perfect but good.

Originally posted by TreyDeyEeyDey:
I was hoping comparing him to Garcia would get this stupid conversation moving.

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:

Originally posted by TreyDeyEeyDey:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by TreyDeyEeyDey:
Whatever. If you want to be this insanely petty over absolutely nothing that's on you. The ball hit him in stride in both hands with him looking directly at it. How amazingly stupid that this is how low you guys are willing to go? New low.

This is dumb though lol. I've already spent too much time. This might be the dumbest argument I've ever had and I apologize that I took any part in it and even made that video. My bad thread.

The ball was high and behind. EZ view shows it. It's not the end of the world but you are so stubborn that you can't even admit it wasn't a great placed ball on a slant. Everyone said Deebo should catch the ball regardless.

it just proves how ridiculous you and a couple posters are about Jimmy…ya'll are incapable of saying anything negative about him/criticizing, even something as dumb as this. It just backs up whatever every already knows about you and a couple others in here regarding this topic.

Yeah the discussion isn't about Jimmy. It's about the insane cognitive dissonance some people have regarding him. The end zone view CLEARLY shows poor ball placement, but even then, ALL agree Deebo should have caught it. That is NOT why it's being brought up. It's being brought up as yet more evidence that some posters here are such huge fans of one particular player (as opposed to 49er fans) that it is impossible for him to do anything wrong.

It honestly has the feel of LeBron James fans. They'll root for whatever team he is on. The end zone view clearly shows bad ball placement, but it was only posted because we KNOW that this group will bend over backwards to try to deny that the pass had poor placement. And it's not deliberate deception. This is self-deception on a subconscious level.

So to those people I would say, get help. Although perhaps not. As a wise man once said:

so many music and movie references now

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Sickaa:
Yep. It most definitely was off the mark.

Which isn't a massive deal. Happens and should have been caught. But people can't even admit that, which is the whole point.

.

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:

Originally posted by TreyDeyEeyDey:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Yeah it was 15+ pages with screenshots and video breakdowns. That slant needs it's own thread lol.

Just say it was behind and high and people will move on…everyone else said Deebo should have caught it all the same.

It really wasn't though... Maybe ever so slightly behind but it was not high. Maybe I'm wrong but that's where you want a pass while in motion. It was a good throw. Great? No but by god... Non Jimmy's mocked others for saying Trey threw too hard. This is equally, if not far more petty. This is worse than making up a stat that in the end is equal to total yards with a possibility of something possibly happening though it didn't.

Do the same thing with the end zone angle.

no we've had enough

Originally posted by SkyZer0:

k

Originally posted by BamaNiner:
I make a sweet post in here and then the thread turns to slop. Geez

what did you post?

Originally posted by TreyDeyEeyDey:
I was hoping comparing him to Garcia would get this stupid conversation moving.

Another problem is you (and others) are using subjective terms. What defines a good pass for you, others may not agree with. People have said it should have been in front of DS, and slightly lower (I agree). That seems pretty obvious, but after twenty pages, I guess not. Regardless, it seems like you concede the throw could be better. As for whether the pass was good, it's probably best not to address that, and simply say the ball was not put in the ideal position to maximize YAC.

The center of mass thing does not make sense, though. Deebo has to extend his hands up. The ball will appear CoM at that moment because...anatomy. Further, if I extend the yellow line ten feet higher, the ball would still be CoM (at that moment), but it's not a good throw. In fact, it would be a massive overthrow, probably going out of the end zone.

* Also, CoM is a really strange way of describing the position of the ball. Maybe it's a military thing lol, but that's not CoM to me.

Originally posted by TreyDeyEeyDey:
I was hoping comparing him to Garcia would get this stupid conversation moving.

Originally posted by SkyZer0:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by SkyZer0:
it was accurate enough to hit the receivers hands and be caught.

/topic

It was high and behind on a slant…you don't throw the ball behind someone who's running the opposite way. Totally catchable but again not a accurate ball.

Different view shows it

Deebo should've caught this but man, you just cannot throw this high and behind when he is wide ass open. pic.twitter.com/Ck31YG7f7z

— Rich (@richjmadrid) November 2, 2021

already looked at this view. and another view. and another. and 15+ pages of discussions about it. and film breakdown from fans about it.

accurate enough, lol.

Alot of unnecessary angles you wasted time checking out.

Originally posted by Polkadots:

Originally posted by TreyDeyEeyDey:
I was hoping comparing him to Garcia would get this stupid conversation moving.

Another problem is you (and others) are using subjective terms. What defines a good pass for you, others may not agree with. People have said it should have been in front of DS, and slightly lower (I agree). That seems pretty obvious, but after twenty pages, I guess not. Regardless, it seems like you concede the throw could be better. As for whether the pass was good, it's probably best not to address that, and simply say the ball was not put in the ideal position to maximize YAC.

The center of mass thing does not make sense, though. Deebo has to extend his hands up. The ball will appear CoM at that moment because...anatomy. Further, if I extend the yellow line ten feet higher, the ball would still be CoM (at that moment), but it's not a good throw. In fact, it would be a massive overthrow, probably going out of the end zone.

fair, well said

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by SkyZer0:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by SkyZer0:
it was accurate enough to hit the receivers hands and be caught.

/topic

It was high and behind on a slant…you don't throw the ball behind someone who's running the opposite way. Totally catchable but again not a accurate ball.

Different view shows it

Deebo should've caught this but man, you just cannot throw this high and behind when he is wide ass open. pic.twitter.com/Ck31YG7f7z

— Rich (@richjmadrid) November 2, 2021

already looked at this view. and another view. and another. and 15+ pages of discussions about it. and film breakdown from fans about it.

accurate enough, lol.

Alot of unnecessary angles you wasted time checking out.

nothing for me to go and check out when they're brought right here to this very thread

Originally posted by TreyDeyEeyDey:

Originally posted by SkyZer0:

k

ty