Jimmy Garoppolo, QB, Los Angeles Rams

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by 49erF90:
I give the injury the benefit of the doubt. Maybe that throw to Juice would have been made if Jimmy didn't hurt his thumb….it was so open a high school quarterback wouldn't have missed it. Now, if he's really hurt, let's do the right thing by not playing him. I'd rather lose the game with a healthy Lance playing. Let Shanahan back his words up- Lance has been having his best practice for a month now.

I believe the injury happened after that throw

Kyle said it happened in the 2Q.

Fixed

Originally posted by mattster03:

Originally posted by Jcool:

Originally posted by mattster03:

Originally posted by Jcool:

Originally posted by mattster03:

Originally posted by Jcool:
49ers fans: Shanahan is making up this injury to bench Jimmy

It's happened twice now. No mention of injury during a Jimmy stinker game, then at halftime (or a few days later)... JIMMY IS INJURED!!!

So Kyle wants Jimmy benched so he makes up an injury. Even though Juice has already said Jimmy told him about it during the game... But now he needs Jimmy to lie about it and other teammates and front office. You think that is what is happening?

Just like the last time I brought up the suspicious injury of Jimmy, I think there is a legitimate injury, but it's small and simply being dramatized for an excuse to get Trey in.

Kyle just gets everyone to lie for him? He must be a master manipulator. I wish he could use that during games.

As pointed out above, everyone wins in this scenario, no manipulation required.

lol how does everyone win? And dont even try with the "jimmy wants to protect his value"

It's a Wally Pip if I ever seen one.

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by 49erF90:
I give the injury the benefit of the doubt. Maybe that throw to Juice would have been made if Jimmy didn't hurt his thumb….it was so open a high school quarterback wouldn't have missed it. Now, if he's really hurt, let's do the right thing by not playing him. I'd rather lose the game with a healthy Lance playing. Let Shanahan back his words up- Lance has been having his best practice for a month now.

No.

It wouldn't matter. He never hits Juice on those.

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by Jcool:

Originally posted by mattster03:

Originally posted by Jcool:
49ers fans: Shanahan is making up this injury to bench Jimmy

It's happened twice now. No mention of injury during a Jimmy stinker game, then at halftime (or a few days later)... JIMMY IS INJURED!!!

So Kyle wants Jimmy benched so he makes up an injury. Even though Juice has already said Jimmy told him about it during the game... But now he needs Jimmy to lie about it and other teammates and front office. You think that is what is happening?

We've got some interesting fans in here.

Say the injury is true, do you giys still blame Jimmy for that game???

…..OF COURSE YOU GUYS DO!!!

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by 49erF90:
I give the injury the benefit of the doubt. Maybe that throw to Juice would have been made if Jimmy didn't hurt his thumb….it was so open a high school quarterback wouldn't have missed it. Now, if he's really hurt, let's do the right thing by not playing him. I'd rather lose the game with a healthy Lance playing. Let Shanahan back his words up- Lance has been having his best practice for a month now.

I believe the injury happened after that throw

Kyle said it happened in the 2Q.

Fixed

TY! I'm rewatching now.

Originally posted by Jcool:

Originally posted by mattster03:

Originally posted by Jcool:

Originally posted by mattster03:

Originally posted by Jcool:

Originally posted by mattster03:

Originally posted by Jcool:
49ers fans: Shanahan is making up this injury to bench Jimmy

It's happened twice now. No mention of injury during a Jimmy stinker game, then at halftime (or a few days later)... JIMMY IS INJURED!!!

So Kyle wants Jimmy benched so he makes up an injury. Even though Juice has already said Jimmy told him about it during the game... But now he needs Jimmy to lie about it and other teammates and front office. You think that is what is happening?

Just like the last time I brought up the suspicious injury of Jimmy, I think there is a legitimate injury, but it's small and simply being dramatized for an excuse to get Trey in.

Kyle just gets everyone to lie for him? He must be a master manipulator. I wish he could use that during games.

As pointed out above, everyone wins in this scenario, no manipulation required.

lol how does everyone win? And dont even try with the "jimmy wants to protect his value"

"Benchitis can strike at any moment. This is called gamesmanship. See the Rams doing it last year with Goff/Wolford. We spend the whole week with JG "questionable" so HOU doesn't know who to prep for. We also again have him questionable leading into the Rams so they don't know who to prep for. It saves face for JG. It saves undo controversy for KS. Every party has incentive to go this route.

There may have been some innocent comment in-game about he knocked his thumb or whatever. You really think some thumb injury which he stayed in the game for on Thurs night will keep him out 10 days later?"

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Coach speak is a thing.

Truth.

The best Coach Speak comment I ever heard was when Steve Kerr was questioned about a media comment he made that turned out to be the opposite of what he did. Kerr's response to the questioner was, "I lied." Nothing further. The implication was obvious. He said what he said to conceal what he actually planned to do.

Originally posted by Jcool:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by Jcool:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by Jcool:
49ers fans: Shanahan is making up this injury to bench Jimmy

Also 49ers fans: Shanahan said Lance had his best month of practice!

None of us are taking the 2nd one as gospel though. Coach speak is a thing.

It's weird how Maiocco reported that Lance was playing really well in practice and at the same time Fred Warner said it unprompted while talking to reporters, then Lynch in an interview says it, and now Kyle is saying it as well. All of this happening in a span of 9 days.

Its weird for a team to talk about a 1st round QB? Uh okay.

It's weird that they all said the exact same thing at around the same time. Especially Fred Warner who brought up Trey unprompted right after the Falcons win.

Its only weird because you think it is. Not because it actually is.

It is weird. There's no reason for them to all bring up Trey within a few days of each other after not really talking about his progress for weeks. I'm not sure what your contention is with that.

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by Jcool:

Originally posted by mattster03:

Originally posted by Jcool:
49ers fans: Shanahan is making up this injury to bench Jimmy

It's happened twice now. No mention of injury during a Jimmy stinker game, then at halftime (or a few days later)... JIMMY IS INJURED!!!

So Kyle wants Jimmy benched so he makes up an injury. Even though Juice has already said Jimmy told him about it during the game... But now he needs Jimmy to lie about it and other teammates and front office. You think that is what is happening?

We've got some interesting fans in here.

Say the injury is true, do you giys still blame Jimmy for that game???

…..OF COURSE YOU GUYS DO!!!

agreed, he had no bad plays at all until after the end of the 2nd quarter.

Originally posted by Kolohe:
Say the injury is true, do you giys still blame Jimmy for that game???

…..OF COURSE YOU GUYS DO!!!

But it gives better context.

1. It wasn't just Jimmy having a down game in an up and down year

2. Kyle probably should of benched him if he knew about it.

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by 49erF90:
I give the injury the benefit of the doubt. Maybe that throw to Juice would have been made if Jimmy didn't hurt his thumb….it was so open a high school quarterback wouldn't have missed it. Now, if he's really hurt, let's do the right thing by not playing him. I'd rather lose the game with a healthy Lance playing. Let Shanahan back his words up- Lance has been having his best practice for a month now.

No.

It wouldn't matter. He never hits Juice on those.

No one hits a wide open Juice.

Jimmy, Mullens, Trey. (Preseason was it?)

Hopefully Trey breaks the curse.

Lol I never understood this boards infatuation with saying injuries are fake. These are grown men. I would actually see it worse if they had to protect Jimmys ego which Im sure is not what's happening.

Perfect situation for Trey - at home, against an inferior foe.

Originally posted by mayo49:
Perfect situation for Trey - at home, against an inferior foe.

maybe no more ducks for you mayo