There are 143 users in the forums
Originally posted by TheGore49er:
I guess it depends on how hurt that finger actually is. Jimmy with injuries is not good at all, we've seen him several times now try to play injured and he's not ready.
He definitely would give us the best chance to win against the Rams if he was healthy though. This is gonna be a very tough decision for Kyle.
Originally posted by Jubwub88:
You don't bench a guy who is 5-0 against a team. And I was open to trey taking this job from jimmy. He proved he is serviceable against lesser teams.
jimmy has won against the rams 5x NO GB, pretty much every team in these playoffs. Can't fast track that
Originally posted by Ensatsu:
If they start an injured thumb Garappolo and we miss the playoffs, who will get the blame? Shanahan? Or probably Jimmy since he put us in this mess to begin with
Originally posted by Ensatsu:
If they start an injured thumb Garappolo and we miss the playoffs, who will get the blame? Shanahan? Or probably Jimmy since he put us in this mess to begin with
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
If his thumb is going to need surgery I don't see how it will be that much better in one week. I know that the Niners have beaten the Rams the last few times but it wasn't just because of Jimmy. He averaged 246 yards and 1.6 TDs in those 5 games. Decent numbers but not great. In 2 of them the defense held the Rams to 10 points or less. One of thos ewins was that final game of 2017 when the Rams were resting players since they already had a playoff spot clinched.
If the Niners beat the Rams again this week it will probably be because the D line puts a lot of pressure on Stafford and the running game controls the ball. Jimmy isn't going to be a difference maker. I would be concerned about him turning the ball over either via a fumble or INT since he's not going to be able to hold the ball as tight.
Originally posted by NotAFinga42:
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
If his thumb is going to need surgery I don't see how it will be that much better in one week. I know that the Niners have beaten the Rams the last few times but it wasn't just because of Jimmy. He averaged 246 yards and 1.6 TDs in those 5 games. Decent numbers but not great. In 2 of them the defense held the Rams to 10 points or less. One of thos ewins was that final game of 2017 when the Rams were resting players since they already had a playoff spot clinched.
If the Niners beat the Rams again this week it will probably be because the D line puts a lot of pressure on Stafford and the running game controls the ball. Jimmy isn't going to be a difference maker. I would be concerned about him turning the ball over either via a fumble or INT since he's not going to be able to hold the ball as tight.
This has been what I've wondered. There is no way his thumb will be better after just 1 week if it indeed needs surgery. If the thing got better each week, he wouldn't need surgery. I have a hard time believing that the last week off was enough to make it feel like he could go next week. We should know by their next practice.
Originally posted by NotAFinga42:
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
If his thumb is going to need surgery I don't see how it will be that much better in one week. I know that the Niners have beaten the Rams the last few times but it wasn't just because of Jimmy. He averaged 246 yards and 1.6 TDs in those 5 games. Decent numbers but not great. In 2 of them the defense held the Rams to 10 points or less. One of thos ewins was that final game of 2017 when the Rams were resting players since they already had a playoff spot clinched.
If the Niners beat the Rams again this week it will probably be because the D line puts a lot of pressure on Stafford and the running game controls the ball. Jimmy isn't going to be a difference maker. I would be concerned about him turning the ball over either via a fumble or INT since he's not going to be able to hold the ball as tight.
This has been what I've wondered. There is no way his thumb will be better after just 1 week if it indeed needs surgery. If the thing got better each week, he wouldn't need surgery. I have a hard time believing that the last week off was enough to make it feel like he could go next week. We should know by their next practice.
Originally posted by JustinNiner:
Just having the illusion of a healthy JimmyG out there will do alot. Rams wont stack the box and we can pound their defense with our run game. If we have Eman and Azeez/Greenlaw back too, our defense will be the strongest its been all season. Norman will be completely benched and a tandem of Thomas&Moseley will make a world of difference.
Originally posted by miked1978:
I htink Jimmy gives us the best chance to win if he's healthy. Lance is holding on to the ball too long and if he's playing a team with a decent pass rush they will eat him alive.
Nothing against Lance. Very happy with what i saw yesterday.