Jimmy Garoppolo, QB, Los Angeles Rams

Originally posted by dmax:

Originally posted by Jubwub88:
You don't bench a guy who is 5-0 against a team. And I was open to trey taking this job from jimmy. He proved he is serviceable against lesser teams.

jimmy has won against the rams 5x NO GB, pretty much every team in these playoffs. Can't fast track that

If he's hurt YOU CERTAINLY do

CATCH 22... It's one of those whichever QB we play.. win or lose.. it will be TOLD YOU SO !!!

Jimmy G would do good with either Pitt or the Browns. Good D and Good Run game on both.

Jimmy should just settle as a 49ers back up. Pretty ideal spot if you ask me!

Originally posted by Jubwub88:
I wish trey could learn jimmys release. Love him or hate him that little pop he does has made him very clutch at times.

so many times they almost get there and poof the balls out. Somtimes to the other team but it's gone

i think trey will tweak his throwing mechanics in the following years

Originally posted by ziggy_gonna_rock:
Jimmy G would do good with either Pitt or the Browns. Good D and Good Run game on both.

trade him to miami, pitt, or denver

Good luck to flat foot Jimmy - hope he lands on a good team that he likes.

"you don't bench a guy who's 5-0 against a team" lolol, dumbest s**t I've heard so far.

Originally posted by D0PEMAN:
"you don't bench a guy who's 5-0 against a team" lolol, dumbest s**t I've heard so far.

you do if he's hurt

Originally posted by DonnieDarko:

Originally posted by D0PEMAN:
"you don't bench a guy who's 5-0 against a team" lolol, dumbest s**t I've heard so far.

you do if he's hurt

Exactly, you don't start him if he can't throw straight.

Originally posted by 9moon:
CATCH 22... It's one of those whichever QB we play.. win or lose.. it will be TOLD YOU SO !!!

Truth

Originally posted by ziggy_gonna_rock:
Jimmy G would do good with either Pitt or the Browns. Good D and Good Run game on both.

I heard the Oline for Pitt is not very good, so that might not be the best for JG.

let's see which Jimmy shows up, good jimmy or bad jimmy.
he's the reason we're in this situation.

If bad jimmy shows up we're just screwed.

Originally posted by maximusdecimus:
let's see which Jimmy shows up, good jimmy or bad jimmy.
he's the reason we're in this situation.

If bad jimmy shows up we're just screwed.

i would argue Jimmy has actually been good to very good when healthy. When hes injured its a different story he isnt the type of QB who can play injured,

He is injured a lot though

Originally posted by DonnieDarko:

Originally posted by ziggy_gonna_rock:
Jimmy G would do good with either Pitt or the Browns. Good D and Good Run game on both.

trade him to miami, pitt, or denver

Total pipe dream but it would be the greatest thing ever to trade him to Miami for a first.

Originally posted by ritz126:
i would argue Jimmy has actually been good to very good when healthy. When hes injured its a different story he isnt the type of QB who can play injured,

He is injured a lot though

This is accurate.

Jimmy healthy = really good QB
Jimmy playing through injury = really bad QB
Jimmy injury frequency = hard to count on Jimmy being consistently really good QB

I've felt playing Jimmy was the right thing to do all year. For this game, I'm hesitant with either choice. I don't think Trey is ready for putting the pressure of an entire season on his shoulders for one game. I also don't trust throwing Jimmy out there to play through injury.

At the end of the day, I might be leaning more towards Trey for this game. I like Jimmy, but not when he's trying to play through an injury.