Jimmy Garoppolo, QB, Los Angeles Rams

You can be joyful that the 49ers won and also be critical of how Jimmy performed at the same time. Those are not mutually exclusive. You can even appreciate Jimmy for his leadership qualities and also lament his poor decision making and inaccurate deep ball at the same time.

For me it is clear that the 49ers have a lot of room for improvement at this position, regardless of how far they go in the playoffs, and it's important they perform their due diligence.

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Isn't good enough for what?

Not good enough to come back against the Rams to make the playoffs?

Not good enough to lead the team to a win on the Road against Dallas?

Not good enough to beat Rodgers and the Packers on the road in freezing temperatures?

He has been good enough for this legendary run to the NFCC Game. You have been wrong about what he is good wnough to do.

I asked you if he was clutch or if he choked vs. Dallas? (Just going by the definition you set for the word the previous week)

Been asking you to commit on this one for a week now and still no answer.

He won against Dallas. He didn't choke.
The previous week, Jimmy was clutch at the end of the Rams game and Stafford choked.

I am not sure why you are still triggered by these opinions, especially during this legendary run to the NFCC. If you disagree with my assessments,just spell out what you disagree with.

I am enjoying these wins.

They're just upset that Jimmy isn't one of the top tier Qbs that are/were still left playing. Brady, Mahomes, Rodgers, Allen, Burrow, Stafford, and they for whatever reason feel the need to constantly, every day, let everyone and their momma know that Jimmy isn't a member of this group.

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Originally posted by TD49ers:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
4 - 1 Playoffs record all time.

Big time winner in the regular season.

2nd NFC Championship appearance in 3 seasons.

1 prior Super Bowl appearance.

WZ still complaining.

Do you really think those accomplishments are because of JG. Yes has played a role but he has not been a focal point of this offense nor has he regularly put this team on his back. If anything its been the opposite, The team has has put JG on their backs more often than vice versa.

49ers record with Jimmy G.

49ers record without Jimmy G.

Proves you wrong.

Yep!! The same fan base that will complained about jimmy this season and turn around and complain about Lance next season and say that jimmy would have won that game lol

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Originally posted by TD49ers:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
4 - 1 Playoffs record all time.

Big time winner in the regular season.

2nd NFC Championship appearance in 3 seasons.

1 prior Super Bowl appearance.

WZ still complaining.

Do you really think those accomplishments are because of JG. Yes has played a role but he has not been a focal point of this offense nor has he regularly put this team on his back. If anything its been the opposite, The team has has put JG on their backs more often than vice versa.

49ers record with Jimmy G.

49ers record without Jimmy G.

Proves you wrong.

No it does not. It says JG is better than Beathard and Mullens who are 3 rd stringers.

Though some reasonable perpective would be nice.

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:
He won against Dallas. He didn't choke.
The previous week, Jimmy was clutch at the end of the Rams game and Stafford choked.

So if you make horrid mistakes as a game ends but your team wins, it doesn't count as choking?

Yes

Why does this bother you and do you have a counter argument?

You seem to be upset by my opinion that Jimmy was clutch at the end of the Rams game and didn't choke away the Dallas game.

You are never going to satisfy a Jimmy G. HATER. Ever. They will never give him the credit he deserves. Ever.

Believe it or not, there are people who felt the same way about Joe Montana. They wanted him gone after two Super Bowl Championships. They claimed he could never win another one.

You will never convince some people. Ever.

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:
He won against Dallas. He didn't choke.
The previous week, Jimmy was clutch at the end of the Rams game and Stafford choked.

So if you make horrid mistakes as a game ends but your team wins, it doesn't count as choking?

Yes

Why does this bother you and do you have a counter argument?

Haha the flip flopping I enjoy. Doesn't bother me at all and I already told you so.

Narrowing down these definitions for what is and what isin't clutch is pretty damn entertaining, but not as much as your avoidance of it for a full week.

I never knew that choking required losing. If your teammates bail you out of bad play I've always seen people still label them as having choked.



New standards every week.

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by YACBros85:
Your argument is that you have seen this too many times from Jimmy. Ignoring the fact that these types of plays are league wide and that It happens every game to every QB. You are also ignoring how the elements were a factor in this game and were probably a factor on the throw and catch. Why aren't you in the Kittle thread harping about Kittle dropping that easy catch?

If you are an average QB, you need to bring more consistency. If you are a good to great QB, then you can live with "these types of plays" happening on a higher occurrence. I've said this from the getgo w/people comparing his performances to Mahomes and other former MVPs.

Heck,...I even said it about Kittle when I said he made up for short arming this pass that was behind him on the very next play with an unbelievable grab he really shouldn'tve caught.

My point is very clear and I've addressed the fact other QBs are not always perfect either, and what's sorely lacking in our case. He's not playing good enough individually to overcome mistakes, but week after week we're seeing that the rest of our team is good enough to overcome his mistakes.

Please don't suggest I'm disregarding what you're saying because again, I've clearly addressed it (even before you brought it up) and said what I think about it that's problematic. Essentially it is what it i, and no validation is needed.

I simply replied to a video suggestion that the pass was perfect. It wasn't. Other drops were perfect passes though.

I'll give you what you want even though I shouldn't. Here boy, here's a treat. Who's a good boy? You're such a good boy.

You are so right and the rest of us are so wrong.

Does your giant ego feel better now? lol

Originally posted by JDTical:
You can be joyful that the 49ers won and also be critical of how Jimmy performed at the same time. Those are not mutually exclusive. You can even appreciate Jimmy for his leadership qualities and also lament his poor decision making and inaccurate deep ball at the same time.

For me it is clear that the 49ers have a lot of room for improvement at this position, regardless of how far they go in the playoffs, and it's important they perform their due diligence.

One can say that Lance must be pretty bad to not get ANY time at QB. Lol

Originally posted by JDTical:
You can be joyful that the 49ers won and also be critical of how Jimmy performed at the same time. Those are not mutually exclusive. You can even appreciate Jimmy for his leadership qualities and also lament his poor decision making and inaccurate deep ball at the same time.

For me it is clear that the 49ers have a lot of room for improvement at this position, regardless of how far they go in the playoffs, and it's important they perform their due diligence.

Sure as long as it can also be acknowledged that we are winning because of him as well

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by maximusdecimus:
Fan boys will fanboy. They will follow jimmy to his new team, like the alex'exuals followed him to Washington.

Wow you guys complain about being called haters, but continue to call people who support Jimmy homers or fanboys. lol

I really don't get you guys who simply don't like Jimmy. The 49ers won and all you guys bring up is crap about Jimmy, who the f**k cares what Jimmy did or didn't do.......THE 49ERS MUTHA FU<KIN WON!!!!

Doesn't it feel great to wake up after a win like this!

Tough one next week, gotta long flight back to CA And if we play Tampa that's a long flight over to Florida.

Kurt Warner just said it on NFL game day morning that the key to winning these dog fights are you have to weather the storm, keep your emotions in check during the highs and lows & just stay calm, and that's what it seems Jimmy does, which I believe helps the whole team stay calm.

When you're looking defeated like AAAaron Rodgers looks on the sidelines at times, I guarantee you his team feeds off that.

Also, shout out to the Refs who I thought called a damn good even game.
(I didn't like Eli's penalty lol)

Originally posted by Jeepzilla:
Doesn't it feel great to wake up after a win like this!

Tough one next week, gotta long flight back to CA And if we play Tampa that's a long flight over to Florida.

Kurt Warner just said it on NFL game day morning that the key to winning these dog fights are you have to weather the storm, keep your emotions in check during the highs and lows & just stay calm, and that's what it seems Jimmy does, which I believe helps the whole team stay calm.

When you're looking defeated like AAAaron Rodgers looks on the sidelines at times, I guarantee you his team feeds off that.

Also, shout out to the Refs who I thought called a damn good even game.
(I didn't like Eli's penalty lol)

If it's in Tampa I'll be there.

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by random49er:
Like the image says/reads,...perspective really is everything. When your jubilation from the win calms down in several days or so, I suggest you come back and rewatch the video and see if you then agree with my comments on it. But yes, micromanaging is exactly what I'm doing regarding the pass.

This statement right here, particularly the bolded, is proof that you're not even enjoying these wins. Moments after the game you come straight to the Jimmy G thread to criticize every mistake, and we won the game. Seems like a total waste of energy.

Uhmmm....my comment right after the game ended though suggests otherwise....

Originally posted by random49er:
Ugly game for JG but we won!! Wow!

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by fan49:
I'm so amazed at people they can say Jimmy is just a winner because he did not win that game the defense in special teams did bottom line. We won in spite of him

We did but everything is icing on the cake @ this point. Speaks to how solid this team is.

What's actually happening here after games vs. what you're saying doesn't match. I enjoy the games so you can relax on that front.

"Ugly game for JG but we won." Yeah you were really happy lol. Let it go, dude.

Originally posted by Tman:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by random49er:
Like the image says/reads,...perspective really is everything. When your jubilation from the win calms down in several days or so, I suggest you come back and rewatch the video and see if you then agree with my comments on it. But yes, micromanaging is exactly what I'm doing regarding the pass.

This statement right here, particularly the bolded, is proof that you're not even enjoying these wins. Moments after the game you come straight to the Jimmy G thread to criticize every mistake, and we won the game. Seems like a total waste of energy.

If you're waking up this morning and b***hing or complaining about any aspect of how Jimmy Garoppolo played football last night you've got issues. Can't imagine feeling anything but joy after last night. Be happy for 24 hours at the very least lmao

— Evan Sowards (@Burner_Sowards) January 23, 2022

Lol seriously. 24 hours minimum!

His performance throughout the playoffs so far hasn't been up to par. The Interception he tossed up for grabs was an awful decision Tbh. I'm still hopeful we'll see "Good Jimmy" at some point. We'll need him If we have to play the Bucs In the NFC championship game.

Originally posted by Jeepzilla:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by TreyDeyEeyDey:

You expect your Pro Bowl level TE to make this catch but let's look @ this one a little closer:



Notice how the ball hits him as he's running full speed on the trailing shoulder pad. It's not @ least in the middle or towards the front. He reacted to the ball a little late handwise, and kinda had to curl them up in a fetal position to attempt a hand grab.

Move that pass to the center of his chest, the front shoulder pad, or in front of him as we'd want,....and it's a solid big play. One of the frustrating things about our QB play are too many plays like this. They add up.

Kittle comes back and makes a play he shouldn'tve made on his very next catch. So for him, it evens out. Our QB isin't good enough to do the same.

LMFAO

He can't be taken seriously after arguing that this pass to Kittle is off the mark in ANY way.