There are 213 users in the forums

Jimmy Garoppolo, QB, Los Angeles Rams

Shop 49ers game tickets
Originally posted by thl408:
Originally posted by jonnydel:
Originally posted by thl408:
+ Show all quotes
Great defense, STs touchdown, clutch last minute drive.
My point with the question I asked, which you failed to answer, is that did Goff suddenly forget how to be a winning QB?

It would be absurd to say that a qb winning is all because of the qb. Joe Montana played with HOF guys on both sides of the ball, same with Steve.

Dan Marino was unbelievable and never had a great team around him. Trent Dilfer was a backup quality qb on an unbelievable team.

The thing is, though, Dilfer never had a winning % anywhere close to Jimmy. Marino never had a team like Jimmy has.

But for people to act like he's the problem, not part of a solution(which we're still winning, so we've got a solution right now) is weird.

Doesn't make sense, at this point.

You'd have to believe that Kyle and John are the greatest HC and GM duo that has ever existed in the history of football to win like they have with Jimmy, to do it in spite of him.

I have criticized Jimmy for being a limited QB in terms of ability, but I won't doubt his ability to sack up and play well in high pressure situations. He is a part of the winning recipe that the 49ers have, but he is not the main ingredient. I don't think anyone is saying he is, just putting my opinion out there.

For me, and this is the point Slay and Sherman have made. Is Jimmy Mahomes? No. Is he winning like Mahomes? No.

But we won 3 straight road games in win or go home situations. So why in the world are people complaining so incredibly loudly?

Would you really rather be a Bills fan right now? Great qb play and watching other teams play to go to the SB?

I don't get what we're complaining about. Thought the point was to win.
Originally posted by dmax:
jimmy g hasn't thrown a single td in the playoffs..LET THAT SINK IN

Why are you so mad? Are we not playing to go the super bowl?
  • Sickaa
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 10,169
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Originally posted by Sickaa:
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Why did the 49ers win on Saturday and why did the 49ers win.

Their last two drives are a big reason.

Are we seriously giving Jimmy credit for the win against the Packers?

Yes, that fantastic drive and thoroughly outplaying Rodgers in the elements when it mattered most deserves praise.

I don't think he outplayed Rodgers. I think we we're fortunate the special teams showed up for once and made some crucial plays that put us In a position to win the game at the end.

I agree with the last drive though, he does deserve credit for that part.
Originally posted by random49er:
Originally posted by Sanfran_chrisco:
Originally posted by Overkill:
+ Show all quotes
https://i.ibb.co/Bt2mdM6/236569-A3-108-E-4-BAF-9-CF7-43-CA12817566.jpg

^^ That's the full url

Not sure what your doing wrong, but be sure right click on the image itself and hit "Copy Image Address"

I literally just showed that in my last post above haha

but anyways, yeah,
right click on pic
left click "Copy image address"

paste and click Ok

Originally posted by rtj03:
That's the url. See if you can do it. It's not letting me

https://imgbb.com/bP5xq9v

Can you just youtube it in a new thread?

no but you can
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Originally posted by random49er:
You didn't provide any evidence in your post. You just named others and suggested that others should submit to them. Nothing was presented.

It's the "herd mentality" thing some like me always tend to reject. There's nothing wrong with making a point and citing those that agree with it (if they do).

Their opinions are more informed than others.

They're more biased than others as well. Two mostly true points that in the end moved the needle nowhere. 1 + 1 will never = 3.
Lets go Jimmy!!!!!!!!!!! we got your back!!!!!!!!!!!!
Originally posted by random49er:
Originally posted by jonnydel:
Originally posted by random49er:
+ Show all quotes
You didn't provide any evidence in your post. You just named others and suggested that others should submit to them. Nothing was presented.

It's the "herd mentality" thing some like me always tend to reject. There's nothing wrong with making a point and citing those that agree with it (if they do).

Are we really saying that after 7200 pages and over 100k posts that there's been, "no evidence"?

If that wasnt clear, maybe I just hit you in the shoulder pad with the post.

Cant technically count as a drop if it only hits his trailing shoulder pad. I always learned that you drop things with your hands.

Get more of those balls in front of him or we're just gonna have ta say "eff it" and draft a young kid for the position.

But just helping you on how logic works so maybe we can get rid of that poisonous "stop thinking and listen" preaching we get here from time to time. Waterbear is correct,...it's logically flawed.

New subject time.

If a guy never puts his hands up, he'll never have any drops WZ logic.
Originally posted by Sanfran_chrisco:
Originally posted by random49er:
Originally posted by Sanfran_chrisco:
+ Show all quotes
I literally just showed that in my last post above haha

but anyways, yeah,
right click on pic
left click "Copy image address"

paste and click Ok

+ Show all quotes

Can you just youtube it in a new thread?

no but you can

You all need to reach out to geturembedder.
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Aren't nearly all stats team stats?

Yes. Yet Fred Warner got criticized all year even during wins. Isn't Freddy a winner?

Look Jimmy is playing a part in the wins and a part in the losses. It's never all one thing. To argue a QB is great solely based on wins is insane. It's equally insane to grade down Stafford solely because of the losses. Same with coaches. There is so much context there.
Originally posted by Sanfran_chrisco:
Originally posted by random49er:
Originally posted by Sanfran_chrisco:
+ Show all quotes
I literally just showed that in my last post above haha

but anyways, yeah,
right click on pic
left click "Copy image address"

paste and click Ok

+ Show all quotes

Can you just youtube it in a new thread?

no but you can

Wouldn't steal the limelight from you like that Chrisco. My favorite cooking grease, btw.
Originally posted by random49er:
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Originally posted by random49er:
You didn't provide any evidence in your post. You just named others and suggested that others should submit to them. Nothing was presented.

It's the "herd mentality" thing some like me always tend to reject. There's nothing wrong with making a point and citing those that agree with it (if they do).

Their opinions are more informed than others.

They're more biased than others as well. Two mostly true points that in the end moved the needle nowhere. 1 + 1 will never = 3.

Yes, Darius Slay who plays for the Eagles is surely biased in our favor.
Originally posted by thl408:
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Did Joe Montana win 4 Super Bowls?

I think so but many here are arguing that he did not.

This thread just got stupider.

It started with the Goff question.

I think giving qbs credit for wins is fair.
  • Furlow
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 23,501
Originally posted by dmax:
jimmy g hasn't thrown a single td in the playoffs..LET THAT SINK IN

Jimmy and the 49ers are in their 2nd NFCCG in the last 3 years. And you're mad. LET THAT SINK IN.
  • Furlow
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 23,501
Originally posted by jonnydel:
Originally posted by random49er:
Originally posted by jonnydel:
+ Show all quotes
Are we really saying that after 7200 pages and over 100k posts that there's been, "no evidence"?

If that wasnt clear, maybe I just hit you in the shoulder pad with the post.

Cant technically count as a drop if it only hits his trailing shoulder pad. I always learned that you drop things with your hands.

Get more of those balls in front of him or we're just gonna have ta say "eff it" and draft a young kid for the position.

But just helping you on how logic works so maybe we can get rid of that poisonous "stop thinking and listen" preaching we get here from time to time. Waterbear is correct,...it's logically flawed.

New subject time.

If a guy never puts his hands up, he'll never have any drops WZ logic.

I have to pretend that random didn't actually just make that argument. Because if I continue on living knowing that someone believes that, I may give up on life and commit suicide.
  • dmax
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 22,900
Originally posted by jonnydel:
Why are you so mad? Are we not playing to go the super bowl?

JESUS CHRIST.....the most important player on the field is the qb
thats why i'm mad. HE MUST MAKE PLAYS SUNDAY. He's the most fustrating player on the field
He has more ints than tds
Theme: Auto • LightDark
Search Share 49ersWebzone