LISTEN: 49ers Midseason Mailbag →

There are 214 users in the forums

Jimmy Garoppolo, QB, Los Angeles Rams

Shop 49ers game tickets
Originally posted by TheGore49er:
Originally posted by RackofRibs49:
Originally posted by NC49er:

Personally I will not miss JG if Lance goes 0-17. Trey may not be the answer but JG is not for sure and it's time to try and upgrade the position.

I was mocked for pointing that we have a faction of fans that would rather lose than keep Jimmy.

Upgrading the position is going 0-17...

Try reading that again bc that's not what he said

It reads like he would rather go 0-17 than have JG, so it actually is what he said.
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 61,901
Originally posted by RackofRibs49:
Originally posted by NC49er:

Personally I will not miss JG if Lance goes 0-17. Trey may not be the answer but JG is not for sure and it's time to try and upgrade the position.

I was mocked for pointing that we have a faction of fans that would rather lose than keep Jimmy.

Upgrading the position is going 0-17...

SMFH

Unreal now I've seen/heard it all.
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 61,901
Originally posted by mojave45:
Originally posted by TheGore49er:
Originally posted by RackofRibs49:
Originally posted by NC49er:

Personally I will not miss JG if Lance goes 0-17. Trey may not be the answer but JG is not for sure and it's time to try and upgrade the position.

I was mocked for pointing that we have a faction of fans that would rather lose than keep Jimmy.

Upgrading the position is going 0-17...

Try reading that again bc that's not what he said

It reads like he would rather go 0-17 than have JG, so it actually is what he said.

How is that read differently?? lol
Originally posted by RackofRibs49:
Originally posted by NC49er:

Personally I will not miss JG if Lance goes 0-17. Trey may not be the answer but JG is not for sure and it's time to try and upgrade the position.

I was mocked for pointing that we have a faction of fans that would rather lose than keep Jimmy.

Upgrading the position is going 0-17...

You are mocked because you can't seem to grasp the concept of always looking to upgrade. It's clear Jimmy isn't the answer.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by mojave45:
Originally posted by TheGore49er:
Originally posted by RackofRibs49:
Originally posted by NC49er:

Personally I will not miss JG if Lance goes 0-17. Trey may not be the answer but JG is not for sure and it's time to try and upgrade the position.

I was mocked for pointing that we have a faction of fans that would rather lose than keep Jimmy.

Upgrading the position is going 0-17...

Try reading that again bc that's not what he said

It reads like he would rather go 0-17 than have JG, so it actually is what he said.

How is that read differently?? lol

Jiks replied with bad reading comprehension.

NC did not say that 0-17 = upgrading the QB position. That's how Jiks read it. All he said he would rather go 0-17 than be stuck with Jimmy again.

As far as him saying he rather go 0-17, that's too extreme for me, but I get what he's saying. Mediocrity gets coaches, GMs, and players fired. Rams could've easily stuck with Jeff Fisher and remain a .500 the and make the playoffs here and there. Rams could've stuck with Goff...Chiefs could've stuck with Alex...etc.

And we could've done the same thing and stick with Jimmy. Thankfully this FO is smart enough to realize he's not enough, so they drafted someone they think can be.
[ Edited by TheGore49er on Apr 17, 2022 at 11:27 AM ]
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:
He just throws s**t at the wall hoping something sticks. Sometimes he's right though, and arrogant about it, and that's usually what pisses people off the most. In particular because, when you just throw s**t at the wall, being right is as inevitable as being wrong.

There are 2 types of sports writers. One just praises the local teams and is well liked by all. Problem is the articles are usually boring and predictable. Then you have guys like Cohn, Ira Miller, Ray Rato and others like them. They write a lot of stuff that fan boys don't want to hear and some players can't handle. They're fine with that because people read them and talk about them. That's what they get paid for.

Some of you may not be old enuugh to remember Howard Cosell but when he was on MNF he was loved and hated equally. People tuned in to hear him no matter whether they liked him or not. On Tuesday morning people were talking bout him. That's what ABC paid him for. Writers and commentators don't always believe what they say. Sometimes they just want to create a buzz.

Why are there no reporters who just accurately report and don't pick sides?

Did Cohn's dad fit that bill? He seems pretty reserved right now, but I suspect he would ask the needling questions as well, to get a rise.
Originally posted by picklejuice:


The haters will do their advanced calculations and say next year:

QB Superbowl MVP wins are not a QB stat.

Originally posted by picklejuice:
I know Garoppolo is a good QB. You're all going to witness some of his greatness soon and miss him. I'll be the first one posting his highlights.
Everyone here knows he's a good QB. He just isn't great.

And if he somehow fixes the things holding him back and become great for the Panthers (or whoever), more power to him. He'll still cost almost 30 million though, and we'll have a guy for less than half who will also likely end up great.
  • cciowa
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 60,541
Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:
Originally posted by picklejuice:
I know Garoppolo is a good QB. You're all going to witness some of his greatness soon and miss him. I'll be the first one posting his highlights.
Everyone here knows he's a good QB. He just isn't great.

And if he somehow fixes the things holding him back and become great for the Panthers (or whoever), more power to him. He'll still cost almost 30 million though, and we'll have a guy for less than half who will also likely end up great.

We have seen enough of jimmy to know what he can do and how far he can go. we deserve something more that could get us over the hump but at least make games easier to win. to often and last year in the playoffs. we have to win games in spite of jimmy. if being competitive is your game. jimmy is your guy. i think we are looking for a little bit more
As William Muny once said, "Deserves got nothing to do with it"
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by RackofRibs49:
Originally posted by NC49er:

Personally I will not miss JG if Lance goes 0-17. Trey may not be the answer but JG is not for sure and it's time to try and upgrade the position.

I was mocked for pointing that we have a faction of fans that would rather lose than keep Jimmy.

Upgrading the position is going 0-17...

SMFH

Unreal now I've seen/heard it all.

Yeah, not a good look
Too bad you can buy draft picks in the nfl like basketball.

Otherwise buy a second rounder then cut Jimmy G in July. We would still end up cheaper than holding onto him and paying him for the 2022 season.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by RackofRibs49:
Originally posted by NC49er:

Personally I will not miss JG if Lance goes 0-17. Trey may not be the answer but JG is not for sure and it's time to try and upgrade the position.

I was mocked for pointing that we have a faction of fans that would rather lose than keep Jimmy.

Upgrading the position is going 0-17...

SMFH

Unreal now I've seen/heard it all.

Fairly unbelievable "fan would rather take 0-17, but player hate runs deep apparently when you would rather see your team not win a single game...smfh.
[ Edited by mojave45 on Apr 17, 2022 at 5:52 PM ]
Originally posted by RackofRibs49:
Originally posted by NC49er:

Personally I will not miss JG if Lance goes 0-17. Trey may not be the answer but JG is not for sure and it's time to try and upgrade the position.

I was mocked for pointing that we have a faction of fans that would rather lose than keep Jimmy.

Upgrading the position is going 0-17...

Any rookie QB has to learn and they will make some bonehead interceptions, JG does it often and he's not a rookie.

With all the talented QB's around the league today Jimmy G ain't winning ya a SB. If Lance is not progressing year after year and is mediocre after year 4-5, 6 at the most, then it's time to try another QB @ the helm as well.
Originally posted by RackofRibs49:
Originally posted by NC49er:

Personally I will not miss JG if Lance goes 0-17. Trey may not be the answer but JG is not for sure and it's time to try and upgrade the position.

I was mocked for pointing that we have a faction of fans that would rather lose than keep Jimmy.

Upgrading the position is going 0-17...
That's it TG49er. Obviously, Trey's not going to go 0-17 (and I was being extreme to emphasize the point) but JG has given us a large enough sample size for many of us to know he is NOT going to get it done and ever help us win another SB.

So I'm prepared for Lance to make mistakes and loose some close ones, get blown out, all the things that go with starting a rookie QB but at least the FO is trying to improve the position to get the team over the hump that JG never will.
[ Edited by NC49er on Apr 17, 2022 at 2:44 PM ]
Share 49ersWebzone