Jimmy Garoppolo, QB, Los Angeles Rams

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:

Originally posted by Sickaa:

Originally posted by 9moon:

Originally posted by JoseCortez:

Originally posted by joanieb:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Do we let JG have the Bears game since he has ownage?

If they were smart, which they aren't, they would let JG start. I just rewatched this game ... Jimmy rushed for 2 tds, the Bears have never beaten him and it's his hometown. Lance could beat the Bears, but it's not as sure a thing. Fields had a nice game against the 49ers, and next year he'll be better.

I find it very difficult to believe what I keep hearing, the 49ers are going to trust the season to Trey Lance. That's very risky, rookies start for bad teams ... not good ones like the 49ers. I don't think that Lance will win the close games, I don't think he'll make it to the post season, but at least you won't have Jimmy Garoppolo to kick around anymore.

You are not allowed to have this opinion in here. How dare you.

LOL... did someone just posted MORE negative things about KS10?

OR did someone just tried confirming that The Best Mind In Football wont have anyone else to point to once Grappy's gone... wait wait.. the rest of team still under the HC..

At some point, we need to see what Lance can do. If we fail to reach the playoffs this season with Lance at the helm, it's fair to say Kyle and Lynch messed up big time.

That's ludicrous. Most QBs don't really figure it out until year three or four. It's possible Lance struggles in year 2 and makes All Pro in year six. No reasonable person will get nervous about Trey until year three or four.

I don't buy this. By year 2 you should he seeing something that gives you hope. Yes he will struggle at times, but i want to see steady improvement this year, and by next year we should know for sure. year 3 is where we should really start being concerned if it doesn't click.

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by Sickaa:

Originally posted by 9moon:

Originally posted by JoseCortez:

Originally posted by joanieb:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Do we let JG have the Bears game since he has ownage?

If they were smart, which they aren't, they would let JG start. I just rewatched this game ... Jimmy rushed for 2 tds, the Bears have never beaten him and it's his hometown. Lance could beat the Bears, but it's not as sure a thing. Fields had a nice game against the 49ers, and next year he'll be better.

I find it very difficult to believe what I keep hearing, the 49ers are going to trust the season to Trey Lance. That's very risky, rookies start for bad teams ... not good ones like the 49ers. I don't think that Lance will win the close games, I don't think he'll make it to the post season, but at least you won't have Jimmy Garoppolo to kick around anymore.

You are not allowed to have this opinion in here. How dare you.

LOL... did someone just posted MORE negative things about KS10?

OR did someone just tried confirming that The Best Mind In Football wont have anyone else to point to once Grappy's gone... wait wait.. the rest of team still under the HC..

At some point, we need to see what Lance can do. If we fail to reach the playoffs this season with Lance at the helm, it's fair to say Kyle and Lynch messed up big time.

What part of Trey's performance last season has folks feeling like the glass is half empty? Sure. He missed some reads. Jimmy missed plenty of them last season as well. Trey also showed he can make up for his inexperience by making ad-lib plays. Something Jimmy rarely does. Trey can only become more experienced by playing through and learning from his mistakes. Imo, he has shown enough good that he should be given the opportunity to learn on the job. It also helps having Shanahan as your play caller but maybe thats just me.

I agree though 2 games isn't even a fraction of his career. He did show positive traits but that means nothing until he gets more filmed and game planned against.

Sure. It is an unkown. It will remain an unknown until we take that leap. We used 3 1st round draft picks to select this guy. He showed some ups and downs in his limited playing time. He also showed significant growth from pre season through the Texans game. He is a young QB who is intelligent, hard working and has plenty of talent to be successful.

If this glass is half empty attitude is because you all are affraid of the unknown. I have to say, that is no way to live.

I'm not afraid of the unknown... I want the best QB out there unlike you guys who are terrified of competition. I want Trey because his ceiling is extremely high and I know Jimmy's ceiling but if he can't do what Jimmy has done his healthy seasons and get us deep into the playoffs then stick with Jimmy. You guys would rather it be Trey or lose... Be honest. It's not about football with you guys. It's about the Jimmy being gone... Nothing else. No matter if it hurts the team.

My glass is I want to win no matter who
Your glass is hatred towards a player. Nothing more

So what you are afraid of is losing the regular season instead of losing another NFCCG or SB? Jimmy has not proven that he can win a SB. So where does this extreme confidence come from?

Yes. Thanks for not denying that you only care about Jimmy being gone nothing more. Respect.

My confidence is his only two healthy seasons he's gotten us to the NFCC or SB. My confidence is his third leading winning %. My confidence is his undeniable record to help the team win.

Now what leads you to believe he can't do it again? Fairy tales...

What? Lose another SB or NFCCG?

Yeah...

At least you hypocritically finally admitted QBs win and lose games. That was like pulling teeth. Too bad you hypocritically only give him credit for the losses.

And you only give him credit for the wins.

Nope I've blamed him for the SB loss and NFCC. I'm not a hypocrite.

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by Sickaa:

Originally posted by 9moon:

Originally posted by JoseCortez:

Originally posted by joanieb:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Do we let JG have the Bears game since he has ownage?

If they were smart, which they aren't, they would let JG start. I just rewatched this game ... Jimmy rushed for 2 tds, the Bears have never beaten him and it's his hometown. Lance could beat the Bears, but it's not as sure a thing. Fields had a nice game against the 49ers, and next year he'll be better.

I find it very difficult to believe what I keep hearing, the 49ers are going to trust the season to Trey Lance. That's very risky, rookies start for bad teams ... not good ones like the 49ers. I don't think that Lance will win the close games, I don't think he'll make it to the post season, but at least you won't have Jimmy Garoppolo to kick around anymore.

You are not allowed to have this opinion in here. How dare you.

LOL... did someone just posted MORE negative things about KS10?

OR did someone just tried confirming that The Best Mind In Football wont have anyone else to point to once Grappy's gone... wait wait.. the rest of team still under the HC..

At some point, we need to see what Lance can do. If we fail to reach the playoffs this season with Lance at the helm, it's fair to say Kyle and Lynch messed up big time.

What part of Trey's performance last season has folks feeling like the glass is half empty? Sure. He missed some reads. Jimmy missed plenty of them last season as well. Trey also showed he can make up for his inexperience by making ad-lib plays. Something Jimmy rarely does. Trey can only become more experienced by playing through and learning from his mistakes. Imo, he has shown enough good that he should be given the opportunity to learn on the job. It also helps having Shanahan as your play caller but maybe thats just me.

I agree though 2 games isn't even a fraction of his career. He did show positive traits but that means nothing until he gets more filmed and game planned against.

Sure. It is an unkown. It will remain an unknown until we take that leap. We used 3 1st round draft picks to select this guy. He showed some ups and downs in his limited playing time. He also showed significant growth from pre season through the Texans game. He is a young QB who is intelligent, hard working and has plenty of talent to be successful.

If this glass is half empty attitude is because you all are affraid of the unknown. I have to say, that is no way to live.

I'm not afraid of the unknown... I want the best QB out there unlike you guys who are terrified of competition. I want Trey because his ceiling is extremely high and I know Jimmy's ceiling but if he can't do what Jimmy has done his healthy seasons and get us deep into the playoffs then stick with Jimmy. You guys would rather it be Trey or lose... Be honest. It's not about football with you guys. It's about the Jimmy being gone... Nothing else. No matter if it hurts the team.

My glass is I want to win no matter who
Your glass is hatred towards a player. Nothing more

So what you are afraid of is losing the regular season instead of losing another NFCCG or SB? Jimmy has not proven that he can win a SB. So where does this extreme confidence come from?

Yes. Thanks for not denying that you only care about Jimmy being gone nothing more. Respect.

My confidence is his only two healthy seasons he's gotten us to the NFCC or SB. My confidence is his third leading winning %. My confidence is his undeniable record to help the team win.

Now what leads you to believe he can't do it again? Fairy tales...

What? Lose another SB or NFCCG?

Yeah...

At least you hypocritically finally admitted QBs win and lose games. That was like pulling teeth. Too bad you hypocritically only give him credit for the losses.

And you only give him credit for the wins.

I don't get this mindset. Kyle hasn't won a superbowl in 5 years. Should we toss him because that means he can't win the big one? So why jimmy?

Originally posted by JoseCortez:
I don't buy this. By year 2 you should he seeing something that gives you hope. Yes he will struggle at times, but i want to see steady improvement this year, and by next year we should know for sure. year 3 is where we should really start being concerned if it doesn't click.

Agreed. Year two Is when you should see the most Improvement. If Lance struggles this year, that would be a bad sign Imo. I'm expecting to see Lance take the league by storm though.

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by Sickaa:

Originally posted by 9moon:

Originally posted by JoseCortez:

Originally posted by joanieb:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Do we let JG have the Bears game since he has ownage?

If they were smart, which they aren't, they would let JG start. I just rewatched this game ... Jimmy rushed for 2 tds, the Bears have never beaten him and it's his hometown. Lance could beat the Bears, but it's not as sure a thing. Fields had a nice game against the 49ers, and next year he'll be better.

I find it very difficult to believe what I keep hearing, the 49ers are going to trust the season to Trey Lance. That's very risky, rookies start for bad teams ... not good ones like the 49ers. I don't think that Lance will win the close games, I don't think he'll make it to the post season, but at least you won't have Jimmy Garoppolo to kick around anymore.

You are not allowed to have this opinion in here. How dare you.

LOL... did someone just posted MORE negative things about KS10?

OR did someone just tried confirming that The Best Mind In Football wont have anyone else to point to once Grappy's gone... wait wait.. the rest of team still under the HC..

At some point, we need to see what Lance can do. If we fail to reach the playoffs this season with Lance at the helm, it's fair to say Kyle and Lynch messed up big time.

What part of Trey's performance last season has folks feeling like the glass is half empty? Sure. He missed some reads. Jimmy missed plenty of them last season as well. Trey also showed he can make up for his inexperience by making ad-lib plays. Something Jimmy rarely does. Trey can only become more experienced by playing through and learning from his mistakes. Imo, he has shown enough good that he should be given the opportunity to learn on the job. It also helps having Shanahan as your play caller but maybe thats just me.

I agree though 2 games isn't even a fraction of his career. He did show positive traits but that means nothing until he gets more filmed and game planned against.

Sure. It is an unkown. It will remain an unknown until we take that leap. We used 3 1st round draft picks to select this guy. He showed some ups and downs in his limited playing time. He also showed significant growth from pre season through the Texans game. He is a young QB who is intelligent, hard working and has plenty of talent to be successful.

If this glass is half empty attitude is because you all are affraid of the unknown. I have to say, that is no way to live.

I'm not afraid of the unknown... I want the best QB out there unlike you guys who are terrified of competition. I want Trey because his ceiling is extremely high and I know Jimmy's ceiling but if he can't do what Jimmy has done his healthy seasons and get us deep into the playoffs then stick with Jimmy. You guys would rather it be Trey or lose... Be honest. It's not about football with you guys. It's about the Jimmy being gone... Nothing else. No matter if it hurts the team.

My glass is I want to win no matter who
Your glass is hatred towards a player. Nothing more

So what you are afraid of is losing the regular season instead of losing another NFCCG or SB? Jimmy has not proven that he can win a SB. So where does this extreme confidence come from?

Yes. Thanks for not denying that you only care about Jimmy being gone nothing more. Respect.

My confidence is his only two healthy seasons he's gotten us to the NFCC or SB. My confidence is his third leading winning %. My confidence is his undeniable record to help the team win.

Now what leads you to believe he can't do it again? Fairy tales...

What? Lose another SB or NFCCG?

Yeah...

At least you hypocritically finally admitted QBs win and lose games. That was like pulling teeth. Too bad you hypocritically only give him credit for the losses.

And you only give him credit for the wins.

Nope I've blamed him for the SB loss and NFCC. I'm not a hypocrite.

So then you admit that his performances in the biggest games has left a lot to be desired?

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by Sickaa:

Originally posted by 9moon:

Originally posted by JoseCortez:

Originally posted by joanieb:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Do we let JG have the Bears game since he has ownage?

If they were smart, which they aren't, they would let JG start. I just rewatched this game ... Jimmy rushed for 2 tds, the Bears have never beaten him and it's his hometown. Lance could beat the Bears, but it's not as sure a thing. Fields had a nice game against the 49ers, and next year he'll be better.

I find it very difficult to believe what I keep hearing, the 49ers are going to trust the season to Trey Lance. That's very risky, rookies start for bad teams ... not good ones like the 49ers. I don't think that Lance will win the close games, I don't think he'll make it to the post season, but at least you won't have Jimmy Garoppolo to kick around anymore.

You are not allowed to have this opinion in here. How dare you.

LOL... did someone just posted MORE negative things about KS10?

OR did someone just tried confirming that The Best Mind In Football wont have anyone else to point to once Grappy's gone... wait wait.. the rest of team still under the HC..

At some point, we need to see what Lance can do. If we fail to reach the playoffs this season with Lance at the helm, it's fair to say Kyle and Lynch messed up big time.

What part of Trey's performance last season has folks feeling like the glass is half empty? Sure. He missed some reads. Jimmy missed plenty of them last season as well. Trey also showed he can make up for his inexperience by making ad-lib plays. Something Jimmy rarely does. Trey can only become more experienced by playing through and learning from his mistakes. Imo, he has shown enough good that he should be given the opportunity to learn on the job. It also helps having Shanahan as your play caller but maybe thats just me.

I agree though 2 games isn't even a fraction of his career. He did show positive traits but that means nothing until he gets more filmed and game planned against.

Sure. It is an unkown. It will remain an unknown until we take that leap. We used 3 1st round draft picks to select this guy. He showed some ups and downs in his limited playing time. He also showed significant growth from pre season through the Texans game. He is a young QB who is intelligent, hard working and has plenty of talent to be successful.

If this glass is half empty attitude is because you all are affraid of the unknown. I have to say, that is no way to live.

I'm not afraid of the unknown... I want the best QB out there unlike you guys who are terrified of competition. I want Trey because his ceiling is extremely high and I know Jimmy's ceiling but if he can't do what Jimmy has done his healthy seasons and get us deep into the playoffs then stick with Jimmy. You guys would rather it be Trey or lose... Be honest. It's not about football with you guys. It's about the Jimmy being gone... Nothing else. No matter if it hurts the team.

My glass is I want to win no matter who
Your glass is hatred towards a player. Nothing more

So what you are afraid of is losing the regular season instead of losing another NFCCG or SB? Jimmy has not proven that he can win a SB. So where does this extreme confidence come from?

Yes. Thanks for not denying that you only care about Jimmy being gone nothing more. Respect.

My confidence is his only two healthy seasons he's gotten us to the NFCC or SB. My confidence is his third leading winning %. My confidence is his undeniable record to help the team win.

Now what leads you to believe he can't do it again? Fairy tales...

What? Lose another SB or NFCCG?

Yeah...

At least you hypocritically finally admitted QBs win and lose games. That was like pulling teeth. Too bad you hypocritically only give him credit for the losses.

And you only give him credit for the wins.

Nope I've blamed him for the SB loss and NFCC. I'm not a hypocrite.

So then you admit that his performances in the biggest games has left a lot to be desired?

Not all but those two yeah.

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by Sickaa:

Originally posted by 9moon:

Originally posted by JoseCortez:

Originally posted by joanieb:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Do we let JG have the Bears game since he has ownage?

If they were smart, which they aren't, they would let JG start. I just rewatched this game ... Jimmy rushed for 2 tds, the Bears have never beaten him and it's his hometown. Lance could beat the Bears, but it's not as sure a thing. Fields had a nice game against the 49ers, and next year he'll be better.

I find it very difficult to believe what I keep hearing, the 49ers are going to trust the season to Trey Lance. That's very risky, rookies start for bad teams ... not good ones like the 49ers. I don't think that Lance will win the close games, I don't think he'll make it to the post season, but at least you won't have Jimmy Garoppolo to kick around anymore.

You are not allowed to have this opinion in here. How dare you.

LOL... did someone just posted MORE negative things about KS10?

OR did someone just tried confirming that The Best Mind In Football wont have anyone else to point to once Grappy's gone... wait wait.. the rest of team still under the HC..

At some point, we need to see what Lance can do. If we fail to reach the playoffs this season with Lance at the helm, it's fair to say Kyle and Lynch messed up big time.

What part of Trey's performance last season has folks feeling like the glass is half empty? Sure. He missed some reads. Jimmy missed plenty of them last season as well. Trey also showed he can make up for his inexperience by making ad-lib plays. Something Jimmy rarely does. Trey can only become more experienced by playing through and learning from his mistakes. Imo, he has shown enough good that he should be given the opportunity to learn on the job. It also helps having Shanahan as your play caller but maybe thats just me.

I agree though 2 games isn't even a fraction of his career. He did show positive traits but that means nothing until he gets more filmed and game planned against.

Sure. It is an unkown. It will remain an unknown until we take that leap. We used 3 1st round draft picks to select this guy. He showed some ups and downs in his limited playing time. He also showed significant growth from pre season through the Texans game. He is a young QB who is intelligent, hard working and has plenty of talent to be successful.

If this glass is half empty attitude is because you all are affraid of the unknown. I have to say, that is no way to live.

I'm not afraid of the unknown... I want the best QB out there unlike you guys who are terrified of competition. I want Trey because his ceiling is extremely high and I know Jimmy's ceiling but if he can't do what Jimmy has done his healthy seasons and get us deep into the playoffs then stick with Jimmy. You guys would rather it be Trey or lose... Be honest. It's not about football with you guys. It's about the Jimmy being gone... Nothing else. No matter if it hurts the team.

My glass is I want to win no matter who
Your glass is hatred towards a player. Nothing more

So what you are afraid of is losing the regular season instead of losing another NFCCG or SB? Jimmy has not proven that he can win a SB. So where does this extreme confidence come from?

Yes. Thanks for not denying that you only care about Jimmy being gone nothing more. Respect.

My confidence is his only two healthy seasons he's gotten us to the NFCC or SB. My confidence is his third leading winning %. My confidence is his undeniable record to help the team win.

Now what leads you to believe he can't do it again? Fairy tales...

What? Lose another SB or NFCCG?

Yeah...

At least you hypocritically finally admitted QBs win and lose games. That was like pulling teeth. Too bad you hypocritically only give him credit for the losses.

And you only give him credit for the wins.

Nope I've blamed him for the SB loss and NFCC. I'm not a hypocrite.

So then you admit that his performances in the biggest games has left a lot to be desired?

Not all but those two yeah.

So can you admit that both playoff runs that we've had under shanahan were games mostly won inspite of Jimmy?

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:

Originally posted by Aj_hwd954:
"Zero chance he's on the roster in 2022"

That was before Jimmy went and sabotaged his own trade value by first saying no surgery and then getting it late. Don't be disingenuous. It's not a good look.

Nah bro, they were saying it even after the surgery. Either way Trey is the starter, but having Jimmy G as a back up isn't the worst thing in the world

Originally posted by JoseCortez:
I don't get this mindset. Kyle hasn't won a superbowl in 5 years. Should we toss him because that means he can't win the big one? So why jimmy?

There's so much nuance missing in comments like these

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:
Yes. Thanks for not denying that you only care about Jimmy being gone nothing more. Respect.

My confidence is his only two healthy seasons he's gotten us to the NFCC or SB. My confidence is his third leading winning %. My confidence is his undeniable record to help the team win.

Now what leads you to believe he can't do it again? Fairy tales...

Once they moved up for a QB in the draft, Jimmy was playing on borrowed time. One of the greatest assets in having a starting QB on a rookie contract is the money you can invest around him….they've already wasted a yr of that contract and here you are trying to burn another yr AND pay an avg QB $27M in FGTD cash lol.

You think Jimmy is gonna win us a super bowl? Honestly? He's been dreadful in the playoffs and has had his chances….if SF can find a trade partner he's gone and that's a fact. The league played musical chairs with starting QBs this off season and we couldn't even get a sniff for him….The only reason he's still on the team is because they can't move him right now. Period.

Originally posted by JoseCortez:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by Sickaa:

Originally posted by 9moon:

Originally posted by JoseCortez:

Originally posted by joanieb:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Do we let JG have the Bears game since he has ownage?

If they were smart, which they aren't, they would let JG start. I just rewatched this game ... Jimmy rushed for 2 tds, the Bears have never beaten him and it's his hometown. Lance could beat the Bears, but it's not as sure a thing. Fields had a nice game against the 49ers, and next year he'll be better.

I find it very difficult to believe what I keep hearing, the 49ers are going to trust the season to Trey Lance. That's very risky, rookies start for bad teams ... not good ones like the 49ers. I don't think that Lance will win the close games, I don't think he'll make it to the post season, but at least you won't have Jimmy Garoppolo to kick around anymore.

You are not allowed to have this opinion in here. How dare you.

LOL... did someone just posted MORE negative things about KS10?

OR did someone just tried confirming that The Best Mind In Football wont have anyone else to point to once Grappy's gone... wait wait.. the rest of team still under the HC..

At some point, we need to see what Lance can do. If we fail to reach the playoffs this season with Lance at the helm, it's fair to say Kyle and Lynch messed up big time.

What part of Trey's performance last season has folks feeling like the glass is half empty? Sure. He missed some reads. Jimmy missed plenty of them last season as well. Trey also showed he can make up for his inexperience by making ad-lib plays. Something Jimmy rarely does. Trey can only become more experienced by playing through and learning from his mistakes. Imo, he has shown enough good that he should be given the opportunity to learn on the job. It also helps having Shanahan as your play caller but maybe thats just me.

I agree though 2 games isn't even a fraction of his career. He did show positive traits but that means nothing until he gets more filmed and game planned against.

Sure. It is an unkown. It will remain an unknown until we take that leap. We used 3 1st round draft picks to select this guy. He showed some ups and downs in his limited playing time. He also showed significant growth from pre season through the Texans game. He is a young QB who is intelligent, hard working and has plenty of talent to be successful.

If this glass is half empty attitude is because you all are affraid of the unknown. I have to say, that is no way to live.

I'm not afraid of the unknown... I want the best QB out there unlike you guys who are terrified of competition. I want Trey because his ceiling is extremely high and I know Jimmy's ceiling but if he can't do what Jimmy has done his healthy seasons and get us deep into the playoffs then stick with Jimmy. You guys would rather it be Trey or lose... Be honest. It's not about football with you guys. It's about the Jimmy being gone... Nothing else. No matter if it hurts the team.

My glass is I want to win no matter who
Your glass is hatred towards a player. Nothing more

So what you are afraid of is losing the regular season instead of losing another NFCCG or SB? Jimmy has not proven that he can win a SB. So where does this extreme confidence come from?

Yes. Thanks for not denying that you only care about Jimmy being gone nothing more. Respect.

My confidence is his only two healthy seasons he's gotten us to the NFCC or SB. My confidence is his third leading winning %. My confidence is his undeniable record to help the team win.

Now what leads you to believe he can't do it again? Fairy tales...

What? Lose another SB or NFCCG?

Yeah...

At least you hypocritically finally admitted QBs win and lose games. That was like pulling teeth. Too bad you hypocritically only give him credit for the losses.

And you only give him credit for the wins.

I don't get this mindset. Kyle hasn't won a superbowl in 5 years. Should we toss him because that means he can't win the big one? So why jimmy?

Shanahan/Lynch chose Trey to replace Jimmy. Who is going to replace Shanahan?

Originally posted by YACBros85:
Shanahan/Lynch chose Trey to replace Jimmy. Who is going to replace Shanahan?

Harbs and Tomlin haven't won a SB in a decade, same with Sean Payton (with better QBs)…they should all be fired

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by YACBros85:
Shanahan/Lynch chose Trey to replace Jimmy. Who is going to replace Shanahan?

Harbs and Tomlin haven't won a SB in a decade, same with Sean Payton (with better QBs)…they should all be fired

Starting Trey over Jimmy even though Jimmy might give us a better chance to win right now has nothing to do with hating Jimmy. They've invested a lot in Trey and they know if he doesn't pan out they are automatically in the hot seat. So for Shanny, John the 49ers and Trey the faster you figure out what you have the better.

As soon as you pull the trigger and trade for Trey you are saying Jimmy is leaving soon. I just don't see how Jimmy's heart can be in it for the 49ers after that. He's not Aaron Rodgers who's gonna dominate the league, win consecutive MVPs, and show the team why they should've used the draft pick elsewhere. He's slightly above average at QB and just cant do what most of the 10-15 guys above him can do. And the guys above him that he can match in physical talent are just more consistent.

IMO. Jimmy is successful. He's busted his ass to help us win, a lot. He has contributed to us making the Superbowl and then the NFC Championship. He deserves respect for what he has done for our team. He is a good man and a good quarterback. He is also done on this roster.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by RackofRibs49:
Yes. Thanks for not denying that you only care about Jimmy being gone nothing more. Respect.

My confidence is his only two healthy seasons he's gotten us to the NFCC or SB. My confidence is his third leading winning %. My confidence is his undeniable record to help the team win.

Now what leads you to believe he can't do it again? Fairy tales...

Once they moved up for a QB in the draft, Jimmy was playing on borrowed time. One of the greatest assets in having a starting QB on a rookie contract is the money you can invest around him….they've already wasted a yr of that contract and here you are trying to burn another yr AND pay an avg QB $27M in FGTD cash lol.

You think Jimmy is gonna win us a super bowl? Honestly? He's been dreadful in the playoffs and has had his chances….if SF can find a trade partner he's gone and that's a fact. The league played musical chairs with starting QBs this off season and we couldn't even get a sniff for him….The only reason he's still on the team is because they can't move him right now. Period.

He is the heir apparent to Jimmy Garoppolo, who remains atop the team's depth chart. And York said he is fine if Garoppolo remains as coach Kyle Shanahan's starter for a year — or even two.

"We've talked about this internally," York said on 49ers Talk. "If we're in a situation where Jimmy goes out and takes us to a Super Bowl again and has an MVP-caliber season, and does it again, there are worse dilemmas to be in. And Jimmy certainly has the ability to do that."

"If he doesn't play until he's 23, but he's got a 15-plus year career …" York said of Lance. "There were rumors about a guy, and obviously Kyle talked about trading for Aaron. How long did Aaron sit? Two or three years before he played? And, again, I want to make sure that we do everything we can to make sure that position is the best it can possibly be in the NFL."

link

The FO has been more than ready to let him sit for 2 seasons. Sure he didn't have the best season last year but he was one or two plays away from the SB. Yes I think we can win a SB with Jimmy but I understand he has some deficiencies that a better QB could mask. Is a 22 year old Trey that? Maybe but not many 22 years old go out and catch the NFL on fire.