49ers snowed under by Bills in ugly 35-10 rout →

There are 381 users in the forums

Jimmy Garoppolo, QB, Los Angeles Rams

Shop 49ers game tickets
Originally posted by blizzuntz:

Do one with 10 point games.
  • q0c0p
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,146
Originally posted by Franchise408:
I agree that benching Trey will be a disaster. And idk if he and the team bounce back from that.

Unfortunately, I also think it is well within the realm of possibility. While today isn't the day to start having the conversation, I also think it is well within the realm of possibility that Trey's inexperience necessitates the conversation.

I'm not predicting it will or won't happen. Just saying it's a very realistic possibility.

People are acting like Trey succeeding and becoming the next Josh Allen is a given. It's far, far from that.

Correct. And Josh Allen only became respectable on year 3. And he became top 5 just last year to now. This team doesnt have that time
Dak might have a busted hand now.
Originally posted by q0c0p:
Correct. And Josh Allen only became respectable on year 3. And he became top 5 just last year to now. This team doesnt have that time

I agree with your baseline point (we don't have time) but your Josh Allen history is off.

He became 'respectable' in his second season. He played great in the 2nd half of the year. In his 3rd year, 2020, he finished 2nd in MVP voting and was pretty obviously one of the best players in football.

If you're a person (not you individually) who thinks Josh Allen and Trey Lance are similar prospects... you're high.
If Dak broke his hand or thumb I'm not giving them Jimmy on their terms it's our terms. Freaking Sam Bradford brought back a 1st to Philly from Minnesota years ago, let's see how desperate Jerry is with a team he swears it's SB or bust lmao
Originally posted by NotAFinga42:
This entire thread is a farce now. The only way Jimmy ever sees any action in a Niners uni again is if there is a catastrophic injury to Trey before the trade deadline.

Fading things you predict could make a person rich, lol.
Originally posted by FredFlintstone:
If Dak broke his hand or thumb I'm not giving them Jimmy on their terms it's our terms. Freaking Sam Bradford brought back a 1st to Philly from Minnesota years ago, let's see how desperate Jerry is with a team he swears it's SB or bust lmao

Noway I am giving 1 of the top teams in the NFC a QB for anything less a 1st.... even then idk
Originally posted by Brucey72:
Noway I am giving 1 of the top teams in the NFC a QB for anything less a 1st.... even then idk

I'm not sure if Jimmy wants to waive his NTC to Dallas, but if he would be, and Jerry offers a first, it'll be telling a whole lot if they don't take it.
Originally posted by Brucey72:
Originally posted by FredFlintstone:
If Dak broke his hand or thumb I'm not giving them Jimmy on their terms it's our terms. Freaking Sam Bradford brought back a 1st to Philly from Minnesota years ago, let's see how desperate Jerry is with a team he swears it's SB or bust lmao

Noway I am giving 1 of the top teams in the NFC a QB for anything less a 1st.... even then idk

Same, when the losses pile up they'll cave especially for a franchise like Dallas. Like I said Minnesota felt they had a team capable for a deep playoff run and they gave up a 1st for Bradford

Still not sure I would trade them Jimmy if he is out for the season, even for a 1st. I would rather them just fall and have one less competitor in the NFC. Plus with our oline and Treys running style we will probably need Jimmy at some point
[ Edited by Brucey72 on Sep 11, 2022 at 8:36 PM ]
Originally posted by Brucey72:

Still not sure I would trade them Jimmy if he is out for the season, even for a 1st. I would rather them just fall and have one less competitor in the NFC. Plus with our oline and Treys running style we will probably need Jimmy at some point

Grappy and Armstead for their 2nd rounder that can be a 1st rounder..
Originally posted by NotAFinga42:
This entire thread is a farce now. The only way Jimmy ever sees any action in a Niners uni again is if there is a catastrophic injury to Trey before the trade deadline.

You are delusional
Originally posted by 9moon:
Originally posted by Brucey72:

Still not sure I would trade them Jimmy if he is out for the season, even for a 1st. I would rather them just fall and have one less competitor in the NFC. Plus with our oline and Treys running style we will probably need Jimmy at some point

Grappy and Armstead for their 2nd rounder that can be a 1st rounder..

🤣🤣🤣and there's the beyond dumb fantasy trade proposal we get every season from this guy. But I'll trade Jimmy to Dallas for a 1st, Dallas isn't even as good as they were last year and they better focus on Philly more than making noise in the playoffs. Their oline is banged up and they're already missing Cooper badly and they don't have that slot wr whose skipping my mind who went to Miami.
Originally posted by FredFlintstone:
Originally posted by 9moon:
Originally posted by Brucey72:

Still not sure I would trade them Jimmy if he is out for the season, even for a 1st. I would rather them just fall and have one less competitor in the NFC. Plus with our oline and Treys running style we will probably need Jimmy at some point

Grappy and Armstead for their 2nd rounder that can be a 1st rounder..

🤣🤣🤣and there's the beyond dumb fantasy trade proposal we get every season from this guy. But I'll trade Jimmy to Dallas for a 1st, Dallas isn't even as good as they were last year and they better focus on Philly more than making noise in the playoffs. Their oline is banged up and they're already missing Cooper badly and they don't have that slot wr whose skipping my mind who went to Miami.

Cedric Wilson? I know the cowboys aren't that good but we might be fighting for a WC bc of our division so the less competition the better. Maybe I just enjoy the Cowboys losing hahahaha

While we are making dumb trade proposals. Jimmy for Parsons straight up
[ Edited by Brucey72 on Sep 11, 2022 at 8:44 PM ]
6-8 weeks(if it's that long, I don't know) Jimmy can keep them relevant and in the playoff hunt. Me personally I'd give a 2nd.
Share 49ersWebzone