Jimmy Garoppolo, QB, Los Angeles Rams

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by Sanfran_chrisco:
I just can't wrap my head around it as I read,

with Jimmy, oh, "He can avoid that"

with Roach, "He could have done a bit better maybe"

like... what?

how is it Jimmy can totally avoid taking a shot to the knee but the defender taking the shot himself MAYBE can do better? no dude, you have it backward. the defender CAN make the decision to avoid taking that shot, and Jimmy MAYBE can do better in getting the ball out sooner giving the defender a more realistic chance to ease up.

My point was JG can do better and so can the defender which seems like your final sentence. Maybe we agree here

One example I saw a play where he get contacted while throwing eyes were closed thanks to the contact and the ball is clanging off a helmet straight up for anyone to grab.. not a good play. Solution is accelerate the clock internally get it out quicker he should have been doing that all game.. my 2 cents.

or, the offensive line can protect their quarterback better.

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Originally posted by Goatie:
He will be back. The organization love him, as does the locker room and he is delivering more than Young and Montana

What does this mean?

JG has won more games as a 49er then both Young and Montana and has a better win/loss ratio.

Originally posted by Goatie:

Originally posted by ChillninDaBay:

Originally posted by Wubbie:
Yeah, it makes some sense to do it, but the logistics of HOW are the problem.
After pulling the trigger on CMC, they committed more so to a "Win NOW" mentality. I really do believe Trey Lance has a future in this league, but his development was set back by a year when he got injured. Trying to roll with Trey next year might hurt the window that we have with this roster.

But yeah... My prediction is that Jimmy's going to finish this season strong. We're moving toward a pass-first offense, he's playing well, and the offense is presumably going to get better over the last six games. He'll have strong statistical numbers numbers and hopefully should have a solid playoff run. That's a good situation for us this year, but it really muddies up our decision-making in the offseason at the QB position.

If Jimmy does well in the rest of the regular season and playoffs, he's going to have suitors. He's going to have the opportunity to get paid well, guaranteed money, on a multi-year contract. Even if Jimmy was okay with coming back and having Trey breathing down his neck (I doubt that), we're not going to commit to him and give him guaranteed money if we view Trey Lance as the QB of the Future.

I just don't see it happening if they have Trey Lance on the roster. To re-sign Jimmy, they'd have to make a tough call.

There is a reason Jimmy is on a backup deal for just this season... he won't be back, but at least "they" or "we" are finally getting "their" or "our" money's worth kind of 🤣
Definitely find out at the end of the season but at least he was only pay backup money for this year, like I have already said, genius move really 🤣

He will be back. The organization love him, as does the locker room and he is delivering more than Young and Montana

HOF for sure 😉 got to love it 🤣

Originally posted by Goatie:

Originally posted by ChillninDaBay:

Originally posted by Wubbie:
Yeah, it makes some sense to do it, but the logistics of HOW are the problem.
After pulling the trigger on CMC, they committed more so to a "Win NOW" mentality. I really do believe Trey Lance has a future in this league, but his development was set back by a year when he got injured. Trying to roll with Trey next year might hurt the window that we have with this roster.

But yeah... My prediction is that Jimmy's going to finish this season strong. We're moving toward a pass-first offense, he's playing well, and the offense is presumably going to get better over the last six games. He'll have strong statistical numbers numbers and hopefully should have a solid playoff run. That's a good situation for us this year, but it really muddies up our decision-making in the offseason at the QB position.

If Jimmy does well in the rest of the regular season and playoffs, he's going to have suitors. He's going to have the opportunity to get paid well, guaranteed money, on a multi-year contract. Even if Jimmy was okay with coming back and having Trey breathing down his neck (I doubt that), we're not going to commit to him and give him guaranteed money if we view Trey Lance as the QB of the Future.

I just don't see it happening if they have Trey Lance on the roster. To re-sign Jimmy, they'd have to make a tough call.

There is a reason Jimmy is on a backup deal for just this season... he won't be back, but at least "they" or "we" are finally getting "their" or "our" money's worth kind of 🤣
Definitely find out at the end of the season but at least he was only pay backup money for this year, like I have already said, genius move really 🤣

He will be back. The organization love him, as does the locker room and he is delivering more than Young and Montana

I cant believe you typed this on a 49er forum and no one says a word. This is why the JG Fan club lack any creditability. Ridiculous.

Originally posted by TD49ers:

Originally posted by Goatie:

Originally posted by ChillninDaBay:

Originally posted by Wubbie:
Yeah, it makes some sense to do it, but the logistics of HOW are the problem.
After pulling the trigger on CMC, they committed more so to a "Win NOW" mentality. I really do believe Trey Lance has a future in this league, but his development was set back by a year when he got injured. Trying to roll with Trey next year might hurt the window that we have with this roster.

But yeah... My prediction is that Jimmy's going to finish this season strong. We're moving toward a pass-first offense, he's playing well, and the offense is presumably going to get better over the last six games. He'll have strong statistical numbers numbers and hopefully should have a solid playoff run. That's a good situation for us this year, but it really muddies up our decision-making in the offseason at the QB position.

If Jimmy does well in the rest of the regular season and playoffs, he's going to have suitors. He's going to have the opportunity to get paid well, guaranteed money, on a multi-year contract. Even if Jimmy was okay with coming back and having Trey breathing down his neck (I doubt that), we're not going to commit to him and give him guaranteed money if we view Trey Lance as the QB of the Future.

I just don't see it happening if they have Trey Lance on the roster. To re-sign Jimmy, they'd have to make a tough call.

There is a reason Jimmy is on a backup deal for just this season... he won't be back, but at least "they" or "we" are finally getting "their" or "our" money's worth kind of 🤣
Definitely find out at the end of the season but at least he was only pay backup money for this year, like I have already said, genius move really 🤣

He will be back. The organization love him, as does the locker room and he is delivering more than Young and Montana

I cant believe you typed this on a 49er forum and no one says a word. This is why the JG Fan club lack any creditability. Ridiculous.

Until Jimmy puts together some winning football performances in the playoffs and brings us home atleast 1 SB. He doesn't deserve to even be put in the same conversation as Montana and Young. That was just a flat out dumb take.

Originally posted by Goatie:

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Originally posted by Goatie:
He will be back. The organization love him, as does the locker room and he is delivering more than Young and Montana

What does this mean?

JG has won more games as a 49er then both Young and Montana and has a better win/loss ratio.

Stick to cricket and rugby.

Originally posted by TD49ers:

Originally posted by Goatie:

Originally posted by ChillninDaBay:

Originally posted by Wubbie:
Yeah, it makes some sense to do it, but the logistics of HOW are the problem.
After pulling the trigger on CMC, they committed more so to a "Win NOW" mentality. I really do believe Trey Lance has a future in this league, but his development was set back by a year when he got injured. Trying to roll with Trey next year might hurt the window that we have with this roster.

But yeah... My prediction is that Jimmy's going to finish this season strong. We're moving toward a pass-first offense, he's playing well, and the offense is presumably going to get better over the last six games. He'll have strong statistical numbers numbers and hopefully should have a solid playoff run. That's a good situation for us this year, but it really muddies up our decision-making in the offseason at the QB position.

If Jimmy does well in the rest of the regular season and playoffs, he's going to have suitors. He's going to have the opportunity to get paid well, guaranteed money, on a multi-year contract. Even if Jimmy was okay with coming back and having Trey breathing down his neck (I doubt that), we're not going to commit to him and give him guaranteed money if we view Trey Lance as the QB of the Future.

I just don't see it happening if they have Trey Lance on the roster. To re-sign Jimmy, they'd have to make a tough call.

There is a reason Jimmy is on a backup deal for just this season... he won't be back, but at least "they" or "we" are finally getting "their" or "our" money's worth kind of 🤣
Definitely find out at the end of the season but at least he was only pay backup money for this year, like I have already said, genius move really 🤣

He will be back. The organization love him, as does the locker room and he is delivering more than Young and Montana

I cant believe you typed this on a 49er forum and no one says a word. This is why the JG Fan club lack any creditability. Ridiculous.

Backup going to backup (he's better than some QB1 or other backups but he's not elite that's always been the problem and truth), at least he didn't throw an int or he almost did for a pick 6 🤣 and the D was good enough to pitch a shut out vs a 4-7 team, let's wait and see what happens when the team plays better competition like this week and in the playoffs like previous seasons 😉 (at least we got him on a backup deal this year and we're definitely getting our money's worth this time 👏 👏 👏 👏 sort of given the improved roster, we'll know for sure at the conclusion of this season 😉)

Originally posted by Sanfran_chrisco:
I just can't wrap my head around it as I read,

with Jimmy, oh, "He can avoid that"

with Roach, "He could have done a bit better maybe"

like... what?

how is it Jimmy can totally avoid taking a shot to the knee but the defender taking the shot himself MAYBE can do better? no dude, you have it backward. the defender CAN make the decision to avoid taking that shot, and Jimmy MAYBE can do better in getting the ball out sooner giving the defender a more realistic chance to ease up.

I posted the NFL rules a few pages back,....and also heard the announcer say the shot wasn't really illegal.

Can you give the rule interpretation as to how this hit is against the rules if he's outside of the tackle box?

Originally posted by ChillninDaBay:

Originally posted by TD49ers:

Originally posted by Goatie:

Originally posted by ChillninDaBay:

Originally posted by Wubbie:
Yeah, it makes some sense to do it, but the logistics of HOW are the problem.
After pulling the trigger on CMC, they committed more so to a "Win NOW" mentality. I really do believe Trey Lance has a future in this league, but his development was set back by a year when he got injured. Trying to roll with Trey next year might hurt the window that we have with this roster.

But yeah... My prediction is that Jimmy's going to finish this season strong. We're moving toward a pass-first offense, he's playing well, and the offense is presumably going to get better over the last six games. He'll have strong statistical numbers numbers and hopefully should have a solid playoff run. That's a good situation for us this year, but it really muddies up our decision-making in the offseason at the QB position.

If Jimmy does well in the rest of the regular season and playoffs, he's going to have suitors. He's going to have the opportunity to get paid well, guaranteed money, on a multi-year contract. Even if Jimmy was okay with coming back and having Trey breathing down his neck (I doubt that), we're not going to commit to him and give him guaranteed money if we view Trey Lance as the QB of the Future.

I just don't see it happening if they have Trey Lance on the roster. To re-sign Jimmy, they'd have to make a tough call.

There is a reason Jimmy is on a backup deal for just this season... he won't be back, but at least "they" or "we" are finally getting "their" or "our" money's worth kind of 🤣
Definitely find out at the end of the season but at least he was only pay backup money for this year, like I have already said, genius move really 🤣

He will be back. The organization love him, as does the locker room and he is delivering more than Young and Montana

I cant believe you typed this on a 49er forum and no one says a word. This is why the JG Fan club lack any creditability. Ridiculous.

Backup going to backup (he's better than some QB1 or other backups but he's not elite that's always been the problem and truth), at least he didn't throw an int or he almost did for a pick 6 🤣 and the D was good enough to pitch a shut out vs a 4-7 team, let's wait and see what happens when the team plays better competition like this week and in the playoffs like previous seasons 😉

Do you mean the almost pick six that was caused by the illegal contact in which nullified it? That almost pick six?

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
I thought the refs were bad but hard to say they were against us. That Olave catch overturn was a joke.

They were horrible on both sides

Originally posted by Goatie:
He will be back. The organization love him, as does the locker room and he is delivering more than Young and Montana

Lol he needs to win a ring to even be mentioned next to Steve but Jimmy is easily one of the best besides those two regardless of how much he's ignorantly scrutinized.

Originally posted by Goatie:

Originally posted by ChillninDaBay:

Originally posted by Wubbie:
Yeah, it makes some sense to do it, but the logistics of HOW are the problem.
After pulling the trigger on CMC, they committed more so to a "Win NOW" mentality. I really do believe Trey Lance has a future in this league, but his development was set back by a year when he got injured. Trying to roll with Trey next year might hurt the window that we have with this roster.

But yeah... My prediction is that Jimmy's going to finish this season strong. We're moving toward a pass-first offense, he's playing well, and the offense is presumably going to get better over the last six games. He'll have strong statistical numbers numbers and hopefully should have a solid playoff run. That's a good situation for us this year, but it really muddies up our decision-making in the offseason at the QB position.

If Jimmy does well in the rest of the regular season and playoffs, he's going to have suitors. He's going to have the opportunity to get paid well, guaranteed money, on a multi-year contract. Even if Jimmy was okay with coming back and having Trey breathing down his neck (I doubt that), we're not going to commit to him and give him guaranteed money if we view Trey Lance as the QB of the Future.

I just don't see it happening if they have Trey Lance on the roster. To re-sign Jimmy, they'd have to make a tough call.

There is a reason Jimmy is on a backup deal for just this season... he won't be back, but at least "they" or "we" are finally getting "their" or "our" money's worth kind of 🤣
Definitely find out at the end of the season but at least he was only pay backup money for this year, like I have already said, genius move really 🤣

He will be back. The organization love him, as does the locker room and he is delivering more than Young and Montana

I'm one of Jimmy's biggest supporters, but this is a bit much.

Originally posted by YACBros85:
Until Jimmy puts together some winning football performances in the playoffs and brings us home atleast 1 SB. He doesn't deserve to even be put in the same conversation as Montana and Young. That was just a flat out dumb take.

Even if he does win a ring....he simply has not been the type of player those 2 were.

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by YACBros85:
Until Jimmy puts together some winning football performances in the playoffs and brings us home atleast 1 SB. He doesn't deserve to even be put in the same conversation as Montana and Young. That was just a flat out dumb take.

Even if he does win a ring....he simply has not been the type of player those 2 were.

But at least than there could be an argument for him. Not saying that the argument would hold up. But right now that take is completely dumb.