Adam Peters - Commanders GM Thread

Originally posted by Dirtydonedirtcheap69:

Originally posted by picklejuice:
Kyle is doing ok because of CMC and studying what McDaniel schemes up..whereas I think Denver really fell off the map when Lynch+Peters left...what happened to whats his name john elway? I don't want John Lynch to become the next John Elway.

Two posts in a row of total inane nonsense. Thank you ignore!

That pickle juice or beetlejuice?

Originally posted by the_dynasty:

Originally posted by steiber:
Maybe I missed something, but how do we know these were his selections and not a collaboration with everyone else?

We don't. It's all pure guesswork.

sometimes the beatwriters like matt maiocca or what not tell us stuff since they have more insider access share things...

i forgot which ones were adam peter picks. i know amby thomas was an adam peters pick and a lot of the lower rounds were reported as him pushing for those picks

Originally posted by picklejuice:
sometimes the beatwriters like matt maiocca or what not tell us stuff since they have more insider access share things...

i forgot which ones were adam peter picks. i know amby thomas was an adam peters pick and a lot of the lower rounds were reported as him pushing for those picks

ambry is the only pick that was confirmed.

Originally posted by Hoovtrain:

Originally posted by Ensatsu:
List of Day 3 hits under Adam Peters:

George Kittle 5th
DJ Reed 5th
Dre Greenlaw 5th
Deommodore Lenoir 5th
Talanoa Hufanga 5th
DJ Jones 6th
Jauan Jennings 7th
Brock Purdy 7th

Will be very interesting to see how they do in Day 3 moving forward. My guess is, they will not be getting a lot of hits like they used to.

Why are they attributed to Peters?

Because it fits a narrative.

Originally posted by Hoovtrain:
Anything to denigrate lynch. Sad thing is they really believe it and push it

Like starting a thread praising another GM strategies that ends up crashing and burning? That wouldn't happen.

Originally posted by Pillbusta:
He ain't got that type
of pedigree

Gotcha.

The only thing Johnson lacks is pedigree.

Originally posted by ScoutingBall:
Not too worried about losing Peters. Good luck in that hell hole that is Washington. This new guy seems like a total cuck that owns them now. This must mean that Lynch is staying around for good and that's exactly what I want. No more testing the announcing waters. It gives us another familiar GM as a trading partner for the draft/pro prospects. Wonder who they will be looking to hire as a HC? I would guess Peters goes with an offensive mind like Ben Johnson or Bobby Slowik.

how is this not censored...but s**t sh1t is? .... strange language filter system

Originally posted by Pillbusta:

Originally posted by Monsterniner:
If Peters is smart he'll get Ben Johnson because that dude is gonna be the next Shanahan.

He ain't got that type
of pedigree

Agree, but its hard for an OC to get that kind of track record. One of the things that I like about Kyle is that he had really good offenses at multiple stops, with different types of players. Matt Schaub, RG3, and Matt Ryan all fliourished. I don't fault Johnson however. There is so much turnover, that guys normally don't get the opportunity to get extensive experience as a play caller. Even for the defensive guys, sometimes they aren't around an offensive coach long enough to develop a sustainable system if/when their OC and/or QB coach gets hired away. I honestly didn't think Zac Taylor had enough experience, but the good thing for him is that 1- he was on a great staff under Sean McVay (this aspect helps A LOT), and 2- he got his franchise QB in year 2.

Kyle is really an anomaly in that he went 5 1/2 years without having his franchise QB. I think you can cover for that when you have called plays with various QBs with completely different skillsets, yet still field good offenses. You have the experience to adapt. Similar to Bill Walsh switching from Greg Cook to Virgil Carter to Ken Anderson.

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by Patton:
That's a pretty good hit list. His loss will be felt imo

You can write up the same exact list for Shanahan, Lynch and several others.

True.

Trey Lance
Javon Kinlaw
Reuben Foster
Joe Williams
Jalen Hurd...wait...wrong list.

We could just instead look at this whole roster, arguably the best in the league, instead of cherry-picking the negatives. This staff and FO has built a powerhouse.

Isn't that what the OP just did? I was bringing the balance. 7 years. No doubt this is the deepest roster in football.

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by Kolohe:
Vish is a f**kin moron. He says the loss will be so overblown yet he doesn't know what Peters contributions were. What a f**kin idiot AND a moron!!!

well.. isn't it being overblown here with no knowledge of what happened ?

Not really, we do know that Peters has had decent input on the draft. And with that being said we fans did hope he would stick around to be the next in line. It's not like we fans are completely clueless on here and are saying it is being overblown, no we know he's a top executive case in point he got a GM job.

Originally posted by Hoovtrain:

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by Patton:
That's a pretty good hit list. His loss will be felt imo

You can write up the same exact list for Shanahan, Lynch and several others.

True.

Trey Lance
Javon Kinlaw
Reuben Foster
Joe Williams
Jalen Hurd...wait...wrong list.

We could just instead look at this whole roster, arguably the best in the league, instead of cherry-picking the negatives. This staff and FO has built a powerhouse.

Anything to denigrate lynch. Sad thing is they really believe it and push it

Yep, I love NC and all, but it's as if he thinks we're the only team that misses on early round picks. I don't get it, cause if you look at other teams, ppl call Belichick a genius, yet he failed on so many 1st-3rd rd picks, yet somehow gets a pass cause he's Bill Belichick. Lynch, & Shanahan, along with Peters, Carthon, Mayhew helped build this team to be a juggernaut.

Also on the draft thing, ppl don't realize it but the majority of picks don't see it pass year 3 of their rookie deals, the draft is a huge crapshoot.

Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Yep, I love NC and all, but it's as if he thinks we're the only team that misses on early round picks. I don't get it, cause if you look at other teams, ppl call Belichick a genius, yet he failed on so many 1st-3rd rd picks, yet somehow gets a pass cause he's Bill Belichick. Lynch, & Shanahan, along with Peters, Carthon, Mayhew helped build this team to be a juggernaut.

Also on the draft thing, ppl don't realize it but the majority of picks don't see it pass year 3 of their rookie deals, the draft is a huge crapshoot.

He thinks Ryan Pace was better. Devoted a whole thread to the concept.

What other team has drafted an all pro level guy in every draft from 2017-2022. But we need balance focusing on the misses? GTFOH.

Lynch has so many connections. He can replace Peter with someone of the same pedigree if not better. Also, majority of the works in the draft system is done by the scouts so as long as Lynch and Shanahan keep their best scouts out there and do their diligence in filtering and vetting their draft picks, we'll be a'ight. Wait, why don't we get that guy Cunningham as Peter's replacement, if no one picks him up.

Originally posted by AB81Rules:

Originally posted by Hoovtrain:

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by Patton:
That's a pretty good hit list. His loss will be felt imo

You can write up the same exact list for Shanahan, Lynch and several others.

True.

Trey Lance
Javon Kinlaw
Reuben Foster
Joe Williams
Jalen Hurd...wait...wrong list.

We could just instead look at this whole roster, arguably the best in the league, instead of cherry-picking the negatives. This staff and FO has built a powerhouse.

Anything to denigrate lynch. Sad thing is they really believe it and push it

Yep, I love NC and all, but it's as if he thinks we're the only team that misses on early round picks. I don't get it, cause if you look at other teams, ppl call Belichick a genius, yet he failed on so many 1st-3rd rd picks, yet somehow gets a pass cause he's Bill Belichick. Lynch, & Shanahan, along with Peters, Carthon, Mayhew helped build this team to be a juggernaut.

Also on the draft thing, ppl don't realize it but the majority of picks don't see it pass year 3 of their rookie deals, the draft is a huge crapshoot.

You can fail as much as we have in the 1st-3rd rounds in 7 years when you hit homeruns in the 5th-UDFA's. That's the literal point of discussing Adam Peters loss as most fans believe he was instrumental in putting the system together for identifying those gems. Lynch himself said he has AP and others put in their wish list at the end of day 2, for day 3 picks and many of those guys got picked. So it's reasonable to infer from that, AP is a big part of that process as it's been wildly consistent esp. compared to the first few rounds which have been boom or massive bust and those picks can easily be tied to Kyle and John b/c of their GM (power) roles and philosophy for their systems (Trey Lance, Javon Kinlaw, Reuben Foster, Joe Williams, Jalen Hurd, etc.). We need to be more objective in here and tow the company line less. Like you said, this isn't unique to just SF so no need for a insta-defense.

Originally posted by 49erF90:
Lynch has so many connections. He can replace Peter with someone of the same pedigree if not better. Also, majority of the works in the draft system is done by the scouts so as long as Lynch and Shanahan keep their best scouts out there and do their diligence in filtering and vetting their draft picks, we'll be a'ight. Wait, why don't we get that guy Cunningham as Peter's replacement, if no one picks him up.

AP leads all the scouts, schedules, analytics, etc. year round in building up the draft board.

I wonder if to retain that seamless in-house system, we'll promote within or go outside and like Wilks, ask that hire to adapt to what's already in place. Or if Lynch will now lead all of that and the day-to-day operations left behind by AP.

I'm looking forward to finding out.

Any predictions?