Alex Smith and the Washington Redskins

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

The context he provided was spun in a pro-Alex way. You know it. He knows it. I know it.

I think you and I have skewed perceptions about smith due to us having over 10,000 posts in here about smith for the past five years. Not everyone takes him personal like you and I. Therefore, a very factual post about the organizations that drafted smith and Garoppolo is not viewed as "pro-Alex" by almost every human on earth except for about 15 webzoners. SoCold has been on this site since the early 90s and rarely posts about smith, therefore, I think he was just providing some obvious context. And yes, the original question is impossible to answer and I will be irate if jimmy is not WAY, WAY better than smith when all said and done

It is unfair to compare that 1st 11 games lol. One sat behind Brady for 5 years the other was a 21 year old rook on a franchise team.

Originally posted by sacniner:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

The context he provided was spun in a pro-Alex way. You know it. He knows it. I know it.

I think you and I have skewed perceptions about smith due to us having over 10,000 posts in here about smith for the past five years. Not everyone takes him personal like you and I. Therefore, a very factual post about the organizations that drafted smith and Garoppolo is not viewed as "pro-Alex" by almost every human on earth except for about 15 webzoners. SoCold has been on this site since the early 90s and rarely posts about smith, therefore, I think he was just providing some obvious context. And yes, the original question is impossible to answer and I will be irate if jimmy is not WAY, WAY better than smith when all said and done

Lol early 90s? Was internet even invented yet? Webzone came up around the early 2000s.

Originally posted by sacniner:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
The context he provided was spun in a pro-Alex way. You know it. He knows it. I know it.

I think you and I have skewed perceptions about smith due to us having over 10,000 posts in here about smith for the past five years. Not everyone takes him personal like you and I. Therefore, a very factual post about the organizations that drafted smith and Garoppolo is not viewed as "pro-Alex" by almost every human on earth except for about 15 webzoners. SoCold has been on this site since the early 90s and rarely posts about smith, therefore, I think he was just providing some obvious context. And yes, the original question is impossible to answer and I will be irate if jimmy is not WAY, WAY better than smith when all said and done

We can all debate about how great, or not so great, Alex Smith was, whether he is in the Top 10 or not, but here is the Top 10 in this little dance:

SteveWallacesHelmet - 404
sacniner - 404
SkyZer0 - 348
NineFourNiner - 347
dj43 - 278
dtg_9er - 197
CharlieSheen - 183
Furlow - 169
Jakemall - 169
tjd808 - 185

It's a tie!!!

/thread.

Originally posted by dj43:

Originally posted by sacniner:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

The context he provided was spun in a pro-Alex way. You know it. He knows it. I know it.

I think you and I have skewed perceptions about smith due to us having over 10,000 posts in here about smith for the past five years. Not everyone takes him personal like you and I. Therefore, a very factual post about the organizations that drafted smith and Garoppolo is not viewed as "pro-Alex" by almost every human on earth except for about 15 webzoners. SoCold has been on this site since the early 90s and rarely posts about smith, therefore, I think he was just providing some obvious context. And yes, the original question is impossible to answer and I will be irate if jimmy is not WAY, WAY better than smith when all said and done

We can all debate about how great, or not so great, Alex Smith was, whether he is in the Top 10 or not, but here is the Top 10 in this little dance:

SteveWallacesHelmet - 404
sacniner - 404
SkyZer0 - 348
NineFourNiner - 347
dj43 - 278
dtg_9er - 197
CharlieSheen - 183
Furlow - 169
Jakemall - 169
tjd808 - 185

Wall of shame.

Originally posted by NineFourNiner:
It's a tie!!!

/thread.

wow. thought you were ignoring us because you were working 7 days a week. turns out you've been hiding in here holding Smith's tiny hands. smdh

Y'all still putting this guy on a pedestal? Man!!! 🤣

Most overrated 49er of all time

Originally posted by SoCold:

Originally posted by NineFourNiner:
It's a tie!!!

/thread.

wow. thought you were ignoring us because you were working 7 days a week. turns out you've been hiding in here holding Smith's tiny hands. smdh

Nah. Rarely post in here anymore. Every argument has been made, no opinions have been or will be changed, and Smith is currently not on the field. I do still giggle at the ridiculous posts and positions taken, though.

Thread needs title change. We can change it back when Alex becomes OC or QB coach.

Not top 10

Originally posted by dj43:

We can all debate about how great, or not so great, Alex Smith was, whether he is in the Top 10 or not, but here is the Top 10 in this little dance:

SteveWallacesHelmet - 404
sacniner - 404
SkyZer0 - 348
NineFourNiner - 347
dj43 - 278
dtg_9er - 197
CharlieSheen - 183
Furlow - 169
Jakemall - 169
tjd808 - 185

Is SkyZer0 a name change? I don't think I've seen a post from him.

Originally posted by tjd808185:

Originally posted by dj43:

We can all debate about how great, or not so great, Alex Smith was, whether he is in the Top 10 or not, but here is the Top 10 in this little dance:

SteveWallacesHelmet - 404
sacniner - 404
SkyZer0 - 348
NineFourNiner - 347
dj43 - 278
dtg_9er - 197
CharlieSheen - 183
Furlow - 169
Jakemall - 169
tjd808 - 185

Is SkyZer0 a name change? I don't think I've seen a post from him.

Was gonna say the same thing.

DefenderDX?

Originally posted by NineFourNiner:

DefenderDX?

I guess the name is an upgrade...