Originally posted by strickac:Originally posted by 49erBigMac:Well Saleh has said that you want your best pass rusher there, so you have some names to agree on, the thing you've missed on big time is the infrequency he's had any of those guys play there on 1st & 2nd downs, to play on those you have to be able to "set an aggressive edge" and maintain your gap.
That rules out Allen, Burns and Polite (at least early in their career) and Ximenes maybe ever, and they would all be passing down only.
This is further evidenced by when we play a nickel package with heavy personnel (Snickel) Thomas and/or AA stay as edge defenders.
I'm sure we'll accept additional pass rushers even if they don't see the field a lot, but guys like Bosa, Ferrell, maybe Ferguson and god forbid Rashan Gary will get big bonus points for being able to play every down.
If he truly views edge rushers primarily as run defenders, then he should be fired on the spot. At big end, I understand that on early downs; otherwise, we would've stuck with Blair over AA and he might've seen around 10 sacks. AA is the better run defender though.
Having a guy like Polite on the roster would give Saleh a boost to the pass rush and we'd see him on passing downs. We're going to see a rotation regardless. Adding Ferrell may be more adequate for early downs, but offers little boost to the pass rush, which is precisely what Lynch and Kyle have been talking about upgrading.
They considered bringing in Dante Fowler. He is a pass rusher and offers very little against the run. He's actually a liability in run defense. It doesn't matter though. They want guys that can get after the QB and that desire outweighs that player's ability to set the edge. Like you said, many of these guys might be situational rushers early on, but that shouldn't eliminate them from our board.
Obviously we aren't primarily looking for run defenders, but I do think if pass rush grades are similar it will be taken into account, for example I think Ferrell and Burns have similar pass rush grades so Ferrell gets the edge due to his superior run defense.
I think all NFL teams think this way, fans and draft analysts don't, it's the same with pass protection for an RB or run support for a Corner.