Mike McGlinchey-OT-Denver Broncos

Originally posted by NinerBuff:
Hard to wrap our head around the idea that PFF said he played well above average. I saw numerous plays where he was being beat in pass pro and run blocking. I try to give PFF some benefit of the doubt, but that's seems patently wrong.

McGlinchey appears to be our weakest starter, along with Lenoir.

PFF to agents who know their grades effect paydays

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Right tackle Mike McGlinchey just missed the top five offensive 49ers players. His 75.3 overall grade was his second-highest of the season (81.2 - Week 6).

https://www.49erswebzone.com/articles/163338-pffs-highest-lowest-graded-49ers-players-chargers-plus-counts/

Well done McG. He's been a consistent cornerstone of one of the best o-lines in the league.

You laugh but Ring is correct

I'm laughing at PFFs grades. McGlinchey is f**king trash but you get your rocks off on being the contrarian

He gets shoved around got shoved into JG and had a holding which was an incomplete pass anyway and declined.

He allowed no sacks to Khalil Mack. How is that not a win for McG and the team?

PFF grades are only stupid when they disagree with ppls preconceived notions I have noticed

I don't look at PFF grades. They are no better, or worse, imo, than grades offered by reporters who cover the game.

He's not as bad as claimed. He had some good blocking yesterday with some bad mixed in too. But he makes good blocks sometimes. He's nowhere near as bad as the claims on here. He's a bulldozer run blocker. An inconsistent pass blocker. Who is actually good at times. He will get burned too. But people here over play that a little. Like he gets beat on every play. He actually doesn't.

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
He's not as bad as claimed. He had some good blocking yesterday with some bad mixed in too. But he makes good blocks sometimes. He's nowhere near as bad as the claims on here. He's a bulldozer run blocker. An inconsistent pass blocker. Who is actually good at times. He will get burned too. But people here over play that a little. Like he gets beat on every play. He actually doesn't.

Bulldozer

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
He's not as bad as claimed. He had some good blocking yesterday with some bad mixed in too. But he makes good blocks sometimes. He's nowhere near as bad as the claims on here. He's a bulldozer run blocker. An inconsistent pass blocker. Who is actually good at times. He will get burned too. But people here over play that a little. Like he gets beat on every play. He actually doesn't.

Bulldozer

Mike McGlinchey with the game on the line pic.twitter.com/qQexHzgXLF

— John Chapman (@JL_Chapman) November 14, 2022

Lol that is EXACTLY the Mcglinchey I have been seeing every game this year. But PFF says he is playing great.

Originally posted by NinerBuff:
Hard to wrap our head around the idea that PFF said he played well above average. I saw numerous plays where he was being beat in pass pro and run blocking. I try to give PFF some benefit of the doubt, but that's seems patently wrong.

McGlinchey appears to be our weakest starter, along with Lenoir.

Being pushed back is not a "lose" situation unless it impacts the play. Such was not the case yesterday.

McGlinchey's biggest problem is that he has picked some very bad times to have a PP breakdown. That shows up in his PFF rating. His 64 rating (slightly below average) is the same as Burford's. Williams is 85. Brendel is 72. Banks is 70. Overall, that is slightly above average.

The fact that McGlinchey is playing next to a rookie who is struggling more than Mc has a negative impact on both of them. As the season progresses, I am going to be watching to see them both bring up their level of PP play.

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
He's not as bad as claimed. He had some good blocking yesterday with some bad mixed in too. But he makes good blocks sometimes. He's nowhere near as bad as the claims on here. He's a bulldozer run blocker. An inconsistent pass blocker. Who is actually good at times. He will get burned too. But people here over play that a little. Like he gets beat on every play. He actually doesn't.

Bulldozer

Mike McGlinchey with the game on the line pic.twitter.com/qQexHzgXLF

— John Chapman (@JL_Chapman) November 14, 2022

You can't cherry pick 1 play. Looks like he blocked the wrong guy.

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
He's not as bad as claimed. He had some good blocking yesterday with some bad mixed in too. But he makes good blocks sometimes. He's nowhere near as bad as the claims on here. He's a bulldozer run blocker. An inconsistent pass blocker. Who is actually good at times. He will get burned too. But people here over play that a little. Like he gets beat on every play. He actually doesn't.

Bulldozer

Mike McGlinchey with the game on the line pic.twitter.com/qQexHzgXLF

— John Chapman (@JL_Chapman) November 14, 2022

You can't cherry pick 1 play. Looks like he blocked the wrong guy.

They showed this same type of play multiple times last night tho SanDiego

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
He's not as bad as claimed. He had some good blocking yesterday with some bad mixed in too. But he makes good blocks sometimes. He's nowhere near as bad as the claims on here. He's a bulldozer run blocker. An inconsistent pass blocker. Who is actually good at times. He will get burned too. But people here over play that a little. Like he gets beat on every play. He actually doesn't.

Bulldozer

Mike McGlinchey with the game on the line pic.twitter.com/qQexHzgXLF

— John Chapman (@JL_Chapman) November 14, 2022

The fact that McGlinchey's first step is with his left foot moving inside to his left, suggests that the blocking call was to ignore the defender and help collapse the inside.

If you look at Mitchell, he kills the timing of the play by taking a hard step to his right and then goes left. Had he hit the left side hard, the defender would not have caught him. As it was, Mitchell never regained his balance after the misstep with the result being a loss.

Originally posted by dj43:

Originally posted by NinerBuff:
Hard to wrap our head around the idea that PFF said he played well above average. I saw numerous plays where he was being beat in pass pro and run blocking. I try to give PFF some benefit of the doubt, but that's seems patently wrong.

McGlinchey appears to be our weakest starter, along with Lenoir.

Being pushed back is not a "lose" situation unless it impacts the play. Such was not the case yesterday.

McGlinchey's biggest problem is that he has picked some very bad times to have a PP breakdown. That shows up in his PFF rating. His 64 rating (slightly below average) is the same as Burford's. Williams is 85. Brendel is 72. Banks is 70. Overall, that is slightly above average.

The fact that McGlinchey is playing next to a rookie who is struggling more than Mc has a negative impact on both of them. As the season progresses, I am going to be watching to see them both bring up their level of PP play.

I appreciate well balanced takes in here. Refreshing change of pace from the 'he's bleeping trash what a bleeper' takes which is 90% of the volume of this thread.

McGlinchey has problems when he has to pass block against a defender with a really quick first step. (He's not alone) He doesn't have really quick feet so when he gets beat with that first step he has a tendency to grab an arm and gets called for holding. Overall I agree that he's not terrible.

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
McGlinchey has problems when he has to pass block against a defender with a really quick first step. (He's not alone) He doesn't have really quick feet so when he gets beat with that first step he has a tendency to grab an arm and gets called for holding. Overall I agree that he's not terrible.

Not directed at you but it's amazing how we have completely different standards for OL, Kyle and Jimmy.

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
McGlinchey has problems when he has to pass block against a defender with a really quick first step. (He's not alone) He doesn't have really quick feet so when he gets beat with that first step he has a tendency to grab an arm and gets called for holding. Overall I agree that he's not terrible.

Not directed at you but it's amazing how we have completely different standards for OL, Kyle and Jimmy.

Well in fairness, this works the opposite way too.

How many times in this thread have we seen this posted?: "We won the game and that's all that is important."

I would put the over/under at 0.5 and bet on the under.

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Well in fairness, this works the opposite way too.

How many times in this thread have we seen this posted?: "We won the game and that's all that is important."

I would put the over/under at 0.5 and bet on the under.

You just said it and therefore you have beaten yourself at your own game

Bottom line is after seeing what brunskill pulled yesterday and watching mglinctchey all year, there's no way he should be in the rotation and brunskill on the bench.

I don't care how the line has to shuffle get mglinctchey out and brunskill in somewhere.

It will never happen but we can always dream.