Alex Smith

Originally posted by TheGore49er:

Originally posted by dj43:

Originally posted by sacniner:

Well, I'm glad the masses have settled on consensus: Alex>>>Cousins. Only someone who is being irrational would think otherwise, or someone with an extreme dislike of old #11, which would just be weird

And if the Santa Clara HoF is for greats, Alex Smith fits the bill

My dude Aiyuk may have to give up #11

I agree Alex will win you more games than Cousins...but your other point...

how many times do you need to keep asking him to stop? didn't you say the same thing last week?

Originally posted by sacniner:

Originally posted by TheGore49er:

Originally posted by dj43:

Originally posted by sacniner:
Well, I'm glad the masses have settled on consensus: Alex>>>Cousins. Only someone who is being irrational would think otherwise, or someone with an extreme dislike of old #11, which would just be weird

And if the Santa Clara HoF is for greats, Alex Smith fits the bill

My dude Aiyuk may have to give up #11

I agree Alex will win you more games than Cousins...but your other point...

how many times do you need to keep asking him to stop? didn't you say the same thing last week?

Stop what? BBQ'ing in the park? What are you upset about? SWH, DJ and I are talking smith in the smith thread. Are you trolling?

Originally posted by sacniner:
Alex is about equal to San Jose State's finest. Both gave us a great playoff memory. Let's get Alex enshrined in Santa Clara, get his number retired at Levi's and then discuss Canton.

JT and P Willy should get in also. Point me to their thread and I'll advocate in there

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by sacniner:

Alex is about equal to San Jose State's finest. Both gave us a great playoff memory. Let's get Alex enshrined in Santa Clara, get his number retired at Levi's and then discuss Canton.

JT and P Willy should get in also. Point me to their thread and I'll advocate in there

Jeff Garcia:
3x Pro Bowler
1 playoff win

Alex Smith
0x Pro Bowler
1 playoff win

Sorry, they are absolutely not equal.

Originally posted by TheGore49er:

Originally posted by sacniner:

Originally posted by TheGore49er:

Originally posted by dj43:

Originally posted by sacniner:

Well, I'm glad the masses have settled on consensus: Alex>>>Cousins. Only someone who is being irrational would think otherwise, or someone with an extreme dislike of old #11, which would just be weird

And if the Santa Clara HoF is for greats, Alex Smith fits the bill

My dude Aiyuk may have to give up #11

I agree Alex will win you more games than Cousins...but your other point...

how many times do you need to keep asking him to stop? didn't you say the same thing last week?

Stop what? BBQ'ing in the park? What are you upset about? SWH, DJ and I are talking smith in the smith thread. Are you trolling?

hot takes stop being popular like 10 years ago. give it a rest with the bait posts. you know what youre doing

Originally posted by TheGore49er:

Originally posted by sacniner:

Originally posted by TheGore49er:

Originally posted by dj43:

Originally posted by sacniner:

Well, I'm glad the masses have settled on consensus: Alex>>>Cousins. Only someone who is being irrational would think otherwise, or someone with an extreme dislike of old #11, which would just be weird

And if the Santa Clara HoF is for greats, Alex Smith fits the bill

My dude Aiyuk may have to give up #11

I agree Alex will win you more games than Cousins...but your other point...

how many times do you need to keep asking him to stop? didn't you say the same thing last week?

Stop what? BBQ'ing in the park? What are you upset about? SWH, DJ and I are talking smith in the smith thread. Are you trolling?

hot takes stop being popular like 10 years ago. give it a rest with the bait posts. you know what youre doing

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Jeff Garcia:
3x Pro Bowler
1 playoff win

Alex Smith
0x Pro Bowler
1 playoff win

Sorry, they are absolutely not equal.

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

He did play in 3 pro bowls. I know he didn't technically make the pro bowl, but they count it if you replace the guys that did make it but don't want to participate.

And 1 playoff win? You forgetting the Hoyer game?

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Jeff Garcia:
3x Pro Bowler
1 playoff win

Alex Smith
0x Pro Bowler
1 playoff win

Sorry, they are absolutely not equal.

He did play in 3 pro bowls. I know he didn't technically make the pro bowl, but they count it if you replace the guys that did make it but don't want to participate.

And 1 playoff win? You forgetting the Hoyer game?

Originally posted by sacniner:

Cousins in his ninth year in the NFL and is leading a team with super bowl aspirations and a good roster to 0-3. His ninth year. Alex led a bottom three roster to first place last year before the horrific injury. 0-3 and letting your team down? Couldn't be Alex

Alex>>Cousins

Retire #11, Jed. Put Alex in the Niner hall of fame. What a QB and a legend

Originally posted by tjd808185:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

He did play in 3 pro bowls. I know he didn't technically make the pro bowl, but they count it if you replace the guys that did make it but don't want to participate.

And 1 playoff win? You forgetting the Hoyer game?

I think he's just talking 49er days

Originally posted by sacniner:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by sacniner:
Alex is about equal to San Jose State's finest. Both gave us a great playoff memory. Let's get Alex enshrined in Santa Clara, get his number retired at Levi's and then discuss Canton.

JT and P Willy should get in also. Point me to their thread and I'll advocate in there

Jeff Garcia:
3x Pro Bowler
1 playoff win

Alex Smith
0x Pro Bowler
1 playoff win

Sorry, they are absolutely not equal.

I hate stats when they don't fit my narrative

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
He did play in 3 pro bowls. I know he didn't technically make the pro bowl, but they count it if you replace the guys that did make it but don't want to participate.

And 1 playoff win? You forgetting the Hoyer game?

Originally posted by sacniner:

Those stats don't tell the entire story. Most Niner fans prefer 2012 Smith. Dude was arguably an all pro and that earned him an invite into Santa Clara HoF. That'll happen for sure

Originally posted by TheGore49er:

My bad about complaining earlier, sac. Didn't know this will be such an original discussion. Thankfully this hasn't been discussed 1000 times already. Thanks for starting this much debate.