Originally posted by Heroism:
I think Mac can beat out Jimmy right now. Crazy, I know, but dude is so surgical with execution that he'd beat Jimmy by virtue of being able to run the offense better.
Nothing has changed for me. I like the other guys(love Zach Wilson), but I don't see Shanahan passing on this dude at 12 if they resign Trent Williams. It'll be like the Deebo pick in 2019 where everyone saw it coming. I'm not a big fan of taking him at 12, but he's not going to be available much longer after that. And ultimately, if he is who we think he is, it won't matter because the dude will ball out in this offense.
I highly doubt that he beats him as a rookie, we have all seen even very good and experienced QB's struggle in the 1st year of a Shanahan offense.
Also this guy had complete command of his college offense having sat for 3 years, he won't have that.
He processes really well, but it's a lot easier when half the time you're just checking to see if they've bracketed Devonta Smith.
I think he's the most pro ready QB in the class, but it's so hard to come in and play we'll as a rookie. Year 2 and 3, I think he'd be very good for us.
However I also think that Lance and Fields would about as good by Year 2 and then better by Year 3.