Originally posted by Dsoto87:
So what's the answer? By your word, Trey is a bust and Jimmy ain't 2012 Alex smith so where do we go?
If Jimmy ain't the answer then why not play Trey with the hopes that he can improve? Jimmy is who is at this point. He's not returning next year and he hasn't improved at all so what good does it do sticking with him especially when sticking with him isn't producing wins?
By my word? Where did I say "Trey is a bust"?
In fact, I did say that we don't have enough intel on Trey yet. And I have posted here in the past - I.E. during the Arizona game - that as bad as Trey Lance looked, he wasn't the problem. The problem goes much deeper than the QB position, whether Jimmy or Trey, although it is very much rooted in the QB position.
The problem has been Kyle and Lynch's obsession with moving away from the 1 QB their regime has had even a sniff of success with, to the point that they have sabotaged the rest of the roster. The secondary has been neglected, the defensive line has nearly been depleted, the wide receiver corp is non-existent outside of one guy, and all of this has been neglected SOLELY BECAUSE THEY ARE SINGLE MINDED FOCUSED ON MOVING ON FROM JIMMY.
I'm not saying Jimmy is irreplaceable, and quite frankly, at this point, whatever the cause of the struggles (which are far more nuanced than "jiMmY sUcKs"), we aren't succeeding *with* him, so yea, if Trey were to be put in at this point, I wouldn't be completely upset.
But the other fact remains that people have been looking at this as a single minded issue - "wE nEeD a nEw qB bEcAuSe jiMmY iS hOLdiNg uS bAcK"
Jimmy isn't the problem. Never was. He is no longer the answer. But replacing Jimmy with Trey - even if Trey develops successfully - is not going to fix the woes of this team. The woes of this team being bad move after back move after bad move being made in roster building, and then throwing the responsibility of all those failures on the QB.
Is it Jimmy's fault that Shanahan and Lynch passed on Deshaun Watson and Patrick Mahomes in favor of Solomon Thomas and the thought of Kirk Cousins?
Is it Jimmy's fault that Reuben Foster was a domestic abuser?
Is it Jimmy's fault that Mike McGlinchey is disappointing as a 1st round OT?
Is it Jimmy's fault that George Kittle is injured almost as much as he is?
Is it Jimmy's fault that Shanahan and Lynch traded away Deforrest Buckner and replaced him with Javon Kinlaw, who is dangerously close to being a bust?
Is it Jimmy's fault that Shanahan has, for whatever reason, decided to completely sabotage his 1st round WR and promising playmaker because reasons?
Is it Jimmy's fault that the secondary is injured just as frequently as he is, and instead of trying to address the issue, Shanahan and Lynch invested FOUR high end draft picks (that could be used to fix the secondary) into his replacement because that has been their single minded focus - move on from Jimmy at all costs?
Is it Jimmy's fault that when Trey Lance has played, Kyle Shanahan has treated him like if it was Mike Alstott was behind center?
Even if Trey Lance develops the way we hope he can, it doesn't fix all of the aforementioned issues. Even if Trey Lance develops the way we hope he can, it doesn't change the fact that we don't have a 1st round pick for 2 more seasons (nor a 3rd round pick for 1 of those seasons), and much needed roster additions won't be able to be made.
Blaming Jimmy for 2020, and for 2021, and beyond, is simple minded. The media hypes that up because in the year 2021, the simplest takes are the easiest to digest. How many clicks can you get in 140 characters...
But when you dig even the slightest bit beyond the surface... you see that Jimmy isn't the issue. Never was. And again, we are now seeing that more many reasons, he is also no longer the answer, so should he continue to start? I mean, at this point, I think the arguments in favor of him starting are far less relevant than they were over the summer, so should he be benched, maybe it's not the worst thing. Maybe it's time to just rip the band-aid off. I'm not calling for him to be benched, but at this point I'm not 100% sure that I'll be upset if he is. Jimmy & SF is non-salvageable. Kyle tried to have it both ways, and it has backfired. A change might actually be best for both parties at this point - SF gets to move forward with the QB they really want, and Jimmy can go someplace that's not actively sabotaging him at every step.
But it's not going to solve the problem. It's not going to solve the problem of 2021, nor will it solve the problems of 2022, 2023, or beyond.
Things don't have to be black and white. Nuance is a thing. Truth can lie in multiple areas, where Jimmy is not the problem, nor is he the answer, and benching him now is not going to fix the real cause of the issues moving forward. Jimmy is the symptom, not the disease. Replacing Jimmy is nothing more than a band-aid. It looks nice for 140 character headlines, and fans can think that the problem is solved. But they'll soon find out that the problem was never Jimmy. He was a symptom of the problem.