Originally posted by krizay:
Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:
Now look at the Super Bowl winning QBs since 1992:
Franchise QBs:
Stafford
Brady
Mahomes
Brady
Brady
Brady
Wilson
Manning
Rodgers
Brees
Rapelisberger
Manning
Manning
Rapelisberger
Brady
Brady
Brady
Warner
Elway
Elway
Favre
Aikman
Young
Aikman
Aikman
Non-Franchise QBs:
Foles
Manning (at the time)
Flacco
Johnson
Dilfer
.
.
26-5. So you have to ask yourself, do you want a winning record, or do you want a ring? If you want a ring, my money would be on teams with a Franchise QB.
What makes most of those guys Franchise QBs? The fact that they won SBs? The fact that their team wins with them? What is the definition of Franchise QB?
if ELI didn't win 2 SBs would he be a Franchise QB?
If Aikman didn't have a Great OL would he still be considered a Franchise QB? If DangerRuss didn't have legion of Boom and looked like he has since, would he still be a Franchise QB?
Why didn't you list the losing QBs? Because they lost SBs are they not Franchise QBs?
Because "[w]e don't raise division championship banners, we don't raise NFC Championship banners. We raise Super Bowl banners." /JedYork
The goal is not to lose a Super Bowl. The goal is to WIN the Super Bowl.
Side note: I'm obviously using the term "Franchise QB" not to just mean long term starter, but guys who are elite or just on the border of elite. And yeah, Eli Manning delivering in the crunchiest of crunch time—TWICE—elevates him above the McNabbs of the league. And yes, Aikman probably would still have been a great QB as he was INSANELY accurate at all three levels, and Wilson's numbers are quite absurd, along with NINE Pro Bowl selections, so yeah. Dude has a career 3.36 to 1 TD to INT ratio (by comparison, Brady is 3.07, Jimmy is 1.87, Steve is 2.17, and Joe is 1.96). So yeah, Wilson is still a Franchise QB without the Legion of s**t to help him.
But since you asked:
Franchise QBs that lost:
Burrow
Mahomes
Brady
Ryan
Newton
Wilson
Manning
Brady
Rapelisberger
Manning
Warner
Brady
Warner
Favre
Kelly
Kelly
Non-Franchise QBs that lost:
Garoppolo
Goff
Kap
Grossman
Hasselbeck
McNabb (you can argue the other side, but zero 4000 passing seasons, no All Pros, no Super Bowl wins, I say he was a very good starter, not a "Franchise QB.")
Delhomme
Gannon (yeah, he won the MVP, but the guy never even had 30 TDs and only one 4000 yard season, and in the only game that matters, he choked like a Houston hooker)
Collins
McNair (3 Pro Bowls does not a Franchise QB make; not without the stats to back it up. Dude never even had more than 24 touchdown passes)
Chandler
Bledsoe (look at his numbers; overrated af. No 30 TD seasons, his season with his most yards had 27 INTs, RIDICULOUS 3.1 INT%)
O'Donnell (Dollar Store knock off Jim Harbaugh)
Humphries
16-14. Barely better than 50-50. Even if you take the four guys who might have a good argument to be "Franchise QBs," (McNabb, Gannon, McNair and Bledsoe, although I disagree, since these guys were all good but not great), it's only a 2 to 1 ratio. As far as WINNERS go, it's a FIVE to one ratio.