Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by JoseCortez:
Because there are two different Treys.
1. What most fans "see": The 3rd pick of the draft, Shannys handpicked qb who has a cannon of an arm, intelligent, and extremely mobile. The complete package. The dream. It's how some view him.
2. Then theres what some of us have actually seen, albeit only 2.5 regular season games. Not accurate, no touch, not a dynamic runner, can't hit those short passes, running around confused, unable to break tackles, not elusive. It may be different in practice, but that's what I've seen in actual gameplay..
We still don't know who he is. It's unfair to judge because it can go either way. Also, being pumped sets you up for even more heartbreak if he does bust. So we can be excited, with tempered expectations, but let's not like like we know anything, because we don't. We can only hope and watch.
Overall your second point isn't accurate. He has passes with touch, he has runs where he was dynamic, he hit short passes. He had passes that were accurate…the issue is it wasn't consistent and no one should expect that right out the gate given his lack of reps… Forming a opinion on him either way is silly (not saying you are).
NY let's be clear here. You have said the same thing a bazillion times. Over and over. Although your correct just know that allot of people on here will disagree just to do it.
Making a boom or bust Evaluation of Trey at this point is idiotic. People are either too impatient or just want that instant gratification from two games. Give me a break. We will know by then end of this year which way Trey is trending provided we don't play Jimmy all year.
People don't remember the first couple years of manning or Troy Aikman. They want the Flacco or Ryan nearly instant great qb story.
