Dallas Cowboys QB Trey Lance Thread

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by LifelongNiner:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
This is a massive disaster for the franchise, no way around it. Jimmy likely won't be back next year regardless of how he plays and Lance is losing a critical year of development. Lance isn't going to develop at all this year with a broken ankle.

I don't think you understand what disaster is. It's not a great situation, but disaster? There are at least 20 fanbases that would trade places with us.

We lost our franchise QB for the season in week 2. It's a disaster.

And we are replacing him with a guy that has won 70% of his starts and been to two of the last three NFCCG. Oh the sky is falling. I repeat, you don't know what disaster is.

Best wishes for Lance. Hoping for a fast recovery

Originally posted by BigTim:
so much being made of Lance's running ability but he got injured on a play where he was running upright its not like he had elusive speed and pin point accuracy the kid is raw has some talent but looked not ready for prime time in both of the starts this season bummer about the ankle but now we can move on from the trying to get a 2nd year player up to speed and win some games and get into the playoffs

That play has absolutely nothing to do with his running ability. It was a zone read and a muddy hole. He looked more than fine before getting hurt.

The amount of now we can move on is f**king pathetic. Young kid broke him ankle trying to help the team you root for win.

Originally posted by ninersrule4:
Injury wise I don't think this is really all that bad for Trey. I don't think he's going to lose any speed or athletic ability from this. I'm sure he will heal perfectly fine. It's time to get behind JG again and hope he can actually do something in the post season for once ( if we make it )

But that's not the main worry, injuries heal players come back and having a positive out look on the injury it's not knee ligament/nerve damage career altering. It's the lost time on the field and the same questions arising this whole off season leading to the season can Trey play blah blah. He just loses reps and time to get better that's the main issue.

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by LifelongNiner:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
This is a massive disaster for the franchise, no way around it. Jimmy likely won't be back next year regardless of how he plays and Lance is losing a critical year of development. Lance isn't going to develop at all this year with a broken ankle.

I don't think you understand what disaster is. It's not a great situation, but disaster? There are at least 20 fanbases that would trade places with us.

We lost our franchise QB for the season in week 2. It's a disaster.

No a disaster would be having Nick Mullen's and CJ Beathard having to take over. Having Jimmy G who probably at present time is the better QB taking over is manageable.

That's thinking in the short term. This team is not going to win the SB with Jimmy and we're losing a year of valuable development for Trey, who will have to pick up where he left off this year next season.

Originally posted by Hysterikal:
No a disaster would be having Nick Mullen's and CJ Beathard having to take over. Having Jimmy G who probably at present time is the better QB taking over is manageable.

This. Disaster would be having to run with Brock Purdy and whatever practice squad QB they may have picked up with no first round pick to look ahead to. Garoppolo softens the blow considerably.

I'm pretty sure this is the dude that landed on Trey's ankle and snapped it.

Originally posted by 9moon:

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
and you dont hold the play call accountable? stop being a homer and let shanny take responsibility like he should

For calling a zone read, something literally every young QB in the NFL is running regularly?

"Bad Kyle, bad bad bad!"

the fact is, your boy LANCE is hurt and because of your HC's play calling.

WAKE UP homie !!

What a fan you are. Divvying up players and coaches like they play for someone else. This is a team, child. A team.

stop trying to shine s**t people. the poster who said this is an absolute disaster is absolutely right. call it like it is.

Originally posted by LifelongNiner:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by LifelongNiner:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
This is a massive disaster for the franchise, no way around it. Jimmy likely won't be back next year regardless of how he plays and Lance is losing a critical year of development. Lance isn't going to develop at all this year with a broken ankle.

I don't think you understand what disaster is. It's not a great situation, but disaster? There are at least 20 fanbases that would trade places with us.

We lost our franchise QB for the season in week 2. It's a disaster.

And we are replacing him with a guy that has won 70% of his starts and been to two of the last three NFCCG. Oh the sky is falling. I repeat, you don't know what disaster is.

Again, we lost our franchise QB for the season you dips**t. Just because you wanted it to happen doesn't mean it's not a disaster.

He wasn't ready anyway guys. Not by a long shot. This is a much better and more functional team with Jimmy G. Just watch game 1 and 2. I hate to see anybody get hurt and I hope he will be OK. But for this year it will help force the hand. Jimmy is the better QB for this year. He will go further. There is simply no doubt about it.

Originally posted by 9moon:
the fact is, your boy LANCE is hurt and because of your HC's play calling.

WAKE UP homie !!

Grrr how dare he calls a zone read, no one ever does that in the NFL! He should be all out "boy" because he was the starter. Shouldn't be any deeper than saying prayers for a speedy recovery and go Jimmy the rest of the year. Not everything bad has to have someone to blame.

Originally posted by bmvanthiel:

Originally posted by Rascal:

Originally posted by IrishCrnjo:
Most QBs don't amount to much. Of the ones that do, you can usually see their talent straight away. So when you have someone that doesn't look good, it just makes the chances of him becoming a franchise cornerstone all the more unlikely. It's like opening up an old pack of baseball cards. The pack is more expensive before opened because you don't know what's inside.

Pretty much. Not everyone is Josh Allen who can come through in Year 3 after stinking up the joint for 2 years. Not that I am a gambling man, but if I had to bet my house on it, I doubt I would have the guts to put my money on Trey Lance after watching him from last year when he did play to the preseason and the Bears game. He just hasn't shown us anything and to my eyes he still doesn't look ready. I even went back to watch his college highlights that I must admit I liked a lot at the time, unfortunately it simply just hasn't translated to the NFL thus far.

I just don't see much actual flashes of talent from Trey.

I wish we could see some more from the games but with what we have seen(preseason included) and all training camp reports, there doesn't seem to be much there but some serious red flags.

what exactly does Trey have other than a strong arm and supposedly a likable guy?

There is a reason why those Trey Lance's rumors keep coming from the 9ers about the organization not feeling confident about the guy and about him not performing in camp, etc. If Lance was really killing it, it would have leaked like the Mahomes rumors based on his performance during practices before he took over the Chiefs from Alex Smith.

Seriously, I just haven't seen anything. He threw a long TD in the preseason? But, that's about it. And then, all the hype about his running ability, all I have been seeing is the guy runs downhill as if he was a short yardage back or linebacker. Kap at the time ran away from the opposing defenders and moved the chains. I just haven't been impressed at all and true enough soon or later he was always going to get injured. No QB can pound the ball like that.

If this is the way that Kyle plans to use him, I just don't see the point of having him. Another wasted season for Trey, you gotta feel for the guy. Next year he will not have played significant snaps since 2019. I just don't see how he will be successful definitely since he will just be at risk for another injury with the way Kyle plays

Good luck Trey. I'm honestly not sure that you will play another snap with the 49ers. My prediction is that they barely make the playoffs. Extend Jimmy and trade or bench Trey and the 49ers stay in QB purgatory for the next 5 years. Not good enough to win and not bad enough to find a QB the team wants to play as a QB.

I think they missed their chance at finding a franchise QB. Drafted a guy at 3 that you treat like a power running back.

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by LifelongNiner:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
This is a massive disaster for the franchise, no way around it. Jimmy likely won't be back next year regardless of how he plays and Lance is losing a critical year of development. Lance isn't going to develop at all this year with a broken ankle.

I don't think you understand what disaster is. It's not a great situation, but disaster? There are at least 20 fanbases that would trade places with us.

We lost our franchise QB for the season in week 2. It's a disaster.

No a disaster would be having Nick Mullen's and CJ Beathard having to take over. Having Jimmy G who probably at present time is the better QB taking over is manageable.

That's thinking in the short term. This team is not going to win the SB with Jimmy and we're losing a year of valuable development for Trey, who will have to pick up where he left off this year next season.

Well we've come close to winning the super bowl with Jimmy G. I personally don't think any NFC team is winning the super bowl this year.