There are 94 users in the forums
Originally posted by Kolohe:
How's it going, anyone still my friend even though I'm not fan of Trey Lance!!!
Go 9ers!!
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
How's it going, anyone still my friend even though I'm not fan of Trey Lance!!!
Go 9ers!!
takes guts to go against the herd mentality or to voice an unpopular opinion
there are two sides to every situation
I see the reason for optimism and feel he can do it here with his arm and another offseason of putting in work, I understand the frustration also it's been a bumpy ride on the TL express so far.
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
I did think of the injury angle you're presenting here, but unless it's a serious injury I don't think you're prioritizing Brock again if Trey has played well enough to keep the job. Trey would start again as soon as he's healthy. If it is a serious injury, I don't think Trey's value goes up because he's now a QB who has suffered two major injuries in his two years starting.
This scenario again, seems to only affect a trade of Brock.
Originally posted by Waterbear:
I see your point but I disagree.
If Trey had a 5 game run like Purdy had where he's lighting it up and winning, a team will trade for him 100%.
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
How's it going, anyone still my friend even though I'm not fan of Trey Lance!!!
Go 9ers!!
You're good. Doubt = / = hate, and advocating a trade (as unrealistic as it is given the dead money) is about gaining assets to help elsewhere.
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by Waterbear:
I see your point but I disagree.
If Trey had a 5 game run like Purdy had where he's lighting it up and winning, a team will trade for him 100%.
But we're not trading him if that happens. That's the point. If he has a 5 game run like Purdy, he's our QB1.
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by Waterbear:
I see your point but I disagree.
If Trey had a 5 game run like Purdy had where he's lighting it up and winning, a team will trade for him 100%.
But we're not trading him if that happens. That's the point. If he has a 5 game run like Purdy, he's our QB1.
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by Waterbear:
I see your point but I disagree.
If Trey had a 5 game run like Purdy had where he's lighting it up and winning, a team will trade for him 100%.
But we're not trading him if that happens. That's the point. If he has a 5 game run like Purdy, he's our QB1.
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
It seems funny that some of the people that were Jimmy fans and accused anyone that criticized him of being a hater, are already calling Lance a bust after 4 starts. At least most of Jimmy's detractors waited a couple seasons before they started wanting someone else.
Originally posted by Waterbear:
Not necessarily, if Purdy returns after Trey has to sit... and he plays at the same level and wins it all. We're keeping Purdy.
I do agree with your earlier statement. A solid performance from Trey this season affects the probability of trading Purdy more so than Trey.
But I don't think its impossible to have a scenario where we go back to Purdy due to injury and Trey increased his trade value.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
It seems funny that some of the people that were Jimmy fans and accused anyone that criticized him of being a hater, are already calling Lance a bust after 4 starts. At least most of Jimmy's detractors waited a couple seasons before they started wanting someone else.
That's 99% of the posters.
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
I did think of the injury angle you're presenting here, but unless it's a serious injury I don't think you're prioritizing Brock again if Trey has played well enough to keep the job. Trey would start again as soon as he's healthy. If it is a serious injury, I don't think Trey's value goes up because he's now a QB who has suffered two major injuries in his two years starting.
This scenario again, seems to only affect a trade of Brock.
If Trey is playing like Jimmy but Brock plays like he did I absolutely think they'd stay with Brock. They would've stayed with Brock had Jimmy got healthy this year.
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
How's it going, anyone still my friend even though I'm not fan of Trey Lance!!!
Go 9ers!!
You're good. Doubt = / = hate, and advocating a trade (as unrealistic as it is given the dead money) is about gaining assets to help elsewhere.