LISTEN: Looking For The 49ers' New DC With Jason Aponte →

There are 328 users in the forums

Dallas Cowboys QB Trey Lance Thread

Shop 49ers game tickets
Originally posted by SLCNiner:
Originally posted by Bangbang89:
Originally posted by miked1978:
I still don't understand why I keep seeing articles and media keep saying the 49ers failed to give Trey a good chance. They gave him the starting job last year and he was suppose to be the man!!!! He got hurt and someone else came in and played better.

Other than starting him his rookie year there is nothing else they could have done. He wasn't ready his rookie year and everyone was cool with him learning under Jimmy.

now all of a sudden the 49ers didn't give him a fair shot.

It's not a fair shot. But at the same time Brock came in and stole the job. I just think it's really dumb to trade him to a nfc rival. Like really dumb lmao.

All of this is true.

It's surprising but to me it just shows how much they don't believe in Lance. They could of sent him to the AFC and didn't over one round. Lol to me that is just a slap to Lance and what they think of him.

you know John asked kyle what he thought and kyle looked at it as no big deal.
Originally posted by miked1978:
I still don't understand why I keep seeing articles and media keep saying the 49ers failed to give Trey a good chance. They gave him the starting job last year and he was suppose to be the man!!!! He got hurt and someone else came in and played better.

Other than starting him his rookie year there is nothing else they could have done. He wasn't ready his rookie year and everyone was cool with him learning under Jimmy.

now all of a sudden the 49ers didn't give him a fair shot.

He got hurt because he was running between the tackles.
Originally posted by _Goldblooded_:
he is now on the team with the coach who developed Matt Flynn, Brian Brohm, BJ Coleman and Brett Hundley.

Good move for him.

Uh, which coach developed Rogers then?
Originally posted by JTB1974:
Originally posted by tankle104:
This was the guy I wanted and the only player that made any damn sense based on what Kyle was saying he wanted. No f**kin idea how he chose Lance and made this the worst trade/selection in nfl history. Mind blowing

Fields would be where Trey is if he was drafted here. He should thank his lucky stars Kyle passed on him.

Because the Bears are an elite franchise ? Trey is where he is, he couldn't beat out the last pick in the draft even though he had two more years with the playbook. They did Trey wrong, for sure. Overpaid by a mile. Weathered the storm though, and are a top 3 team still. Granted Micah Parsons or Patrick Surtain would have been nice. Screwing up top 5 QBs happens, and it kills franchises like Raiders, Jets, Browns, etc. Didn't kill the 49ers, not by a long shot,
Originally posted by tankle104:
Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Originally posted by Dshearn:
I wanted Mac,

but hindsight is 20/20

Mac jones is an asshat...i would have been ticked with him on the 49ers, i would much rather have taken the gamble with Trey and failed then to have taken Mac in hindsight.

This was the guy I wanted and the only player that made any damn sense based on what Kyle was saying he wanted. No f**kin idea how he chose Lance and made this the worst trade/selection in nfl history. Mind blowing

Yes. I am not sold on him as a passer yet but if he was with us and showed what he has shown so far I would be intrigued and very willing to let it play out. He has shown some plus plus traits. Trey underwhelmed with his athletic ability which was concerning.
Originally posted by riverrunzthruit:
this whole situation was not hard to see if you were paying attention to what ShannaLynch were saying and doing ever since they resigned Jimmy Gesus last year

Agreed… though I didn't think a trade would materialize (at least prior to this week)*

Riverdamus nailed that part. Mandatory unblockings baby… lol
[ Edited by SmokeyJoe on Aug 25, 2023 at 6:31 PM ]
Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Originally posted by miked1978:
I still don't understand why I keep seeing articles and media keep saying the 49ers failed to give Trey a good chance. They gave him the starting job last year and he was suppose to be the man!!!! He got hurt and someone else came in and played better.

Other than starting him his rookie year there is nothing else they could have done. He wasn't ready his rookie year and everyone was cool with him learning under Jimmy.

now all of a sudden the 49ers didn't give him a fair shot.

For me, is not that the 49ers didnt give him a chance. He got one, and got hurt.

My point is and has always been that 4 games isnt enough of a chance to make definitive conclusions on a player's future. I get that Brock came in and took the job. I am pumped for Brock. But at the same time, I refuse to say Trey Lance sucks or will never be good because he wasnt good in the 4 starts he had. Both things can be true.

Can it be that he hasnt been good in practice/TC/film room also that has made it clear to them that he isnt good?
Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
For me, is not that the 49ers didnt give him a chance. He got one, and got hurt.

My point is and has always been that 4 games isnt enough of a chance to make definitive conclusions on a player's future. I get that Brock came in and took the job. I am pumped for Brock. But at the same time, I refuse to say Trey Lance sucks or will never be good because he wasnt good in the 4 starts he had. Both things can be true.

Come on SWH, then tell it to Kyle.. he made a definitive conclusion, we can also.. you don't have to, sure but some of the arrogance of "there is no logic" in your position, which you have replied to me. I mean I laid out all the trade logic a few weeks ago.. clearly there was some logic!
  • Antix
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 9,842
Its really frustrating bc I thought Fields was the obvious pick. Fields needs to develop a lot as a passer but he's a way better runner than Lance and whatever offense was planned for Lance woulda been much better with Fields. They out thought themselves or something.

I've been pretty pro this regime, but their performance in the first round needs to be seriously evaluated.
He gone. Time to move this thread out of Niner talk.
Originally posted by Antix:
Its really frustrating bc I thought Fields was the obvious pick. Fields needs to develop a lot as a passer but he's a way better runner than Lance and whatever offense was planned for Lance woulda been much better with Fields. They out thought themselves or something.

I've been pretty pro this regime, but their performance in the first round needs to be seriously evaluated.

I think on the plus side their mitigation of this pick shows they're capable of adjusting and learning. That's a good thing. Plenty of coaches would have just jammed this through until the wheels fell off. Obviously a ton of our fans would have too
Originally posted by riverrunzthruit:
this whole situation was not hard to see if you were paying attention to what ShannaLynch were saying and doing ever since they resigned Jimmy Gesus last year

Dude. No. 90% of your b******t is wrong. This is what happened: Trey Lance got hurt. Jimmy G got hurt. And Brock Purdy had the 5th best Total QBR in the entire NFL and lead the league in passing touchdown percentage. At this very moment right here, and not a SECOND before it, Trey Lance's fate was sealed:

https://www.49ers.com/video/quarterback-brock-purdy-tight-end-george-kittle-pass-dolphins-week-13-nfl

Anything that happened before or after that is irrelevant. That was the moment Brock became the 49ers QB.
Originally posted by tankle104:
Originally posted by SLCNiner:
Originally posted by Bangbang89:
Originally posted by miked1978:
I still don't understand why I keep seeing articles and media keep saying the 49ers failed to give Trey a good chance. They gave him the starting job last year and he was suppose to be the man!!!! He got hurt and someone else came in and played better.

Other than starting him his rookie year there is nothing else they could have done. He wasn't ready his rookie year and everyone was cool with him learning under Jimmy.

now all of a sudden the 49ers didn't give him a fair shot.

It's not a fair shot. But at the same time Brock came in and stole the job. I just think it's really dumb to trade him to a nfc rival. Like really dumb lmao.

All of this is true.

It's surprising but to me it just shows how much they don't believe in Lance. They could of sent him to the AFC and didn't over one round. Lol to me that is just a slap to Lance and what they think of him.

you know John asked kyle what he thought and kyle looked at it as no big deal.

He'd never have had any chance at all at unseating Allen. Again, feel like they did what was best for him. Disagree it had anything to do with them thinking poorly of him.
Welp, looks like its all Allen for the second half tonight
Originally posted by picklejuice:

i dont like him now that he's a cowboy

Long-term COVID victim.
Search Share 49ersWebzone