Top 10 NFL Players of All Time: Who you got?

Manning/Brady
Barry/Walter
Rice big drop to Moss
Gonzalez/Gronk
Munoz/Allen/Hannah/Pace

Deion/Lott/Reed/Woodson
Lewis
White/Taylor
D Thomas

Can't even top 10 right

Originally posted by Deebo:
If your list doesn't have Walter Payton on it, you just might be a retard.

If you post like this you might just be out of here. These are opinions.

Originally posted by BamaNiner:
Manning/Brady
Barry/Walter
Rice big drop to Moss
Gonzalez/Gronk
Munoz/Allen/Hannah/Pace

Deion/Lott/Reed/Woodson
Lewis
White/Taylor
D Thomas

Ken Stabler
Mac Jones
Derrick Henry
Nick Saban
Joe Namath
Shaun Alexander
Julio Jones
Minkah Fitzpatrick
Mark Ingran
Derrick Thomas

That's the REAL top 10 NFL players ever. Not even questionable, IMO.

Originally posted by DaBeegDeek:

Originally posted by BamaNiner:
Manning/Brady
Barry/Walter
Rice big drop to Moss
Gonzalez/Gronk
Munoz/Allen/Hannah/Pace

Deion/Lott/Reed/Woodson
Lewis
White/Taylor
D Thomas

Ken Stabler
Mac Jones
Derrick Henry
Nick Saban
Joe Namath
Shaun Alexander
Julio Jones
Minkah Fitzpatrick
Mark Ingran
Derrick Thomas

That's the REAL top 10 NFL players ever. Not even questionable, IMO.

All Bama took me a while to get it

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by DaBeegDeek:

Originally posted by BamaNiner:
Manning/Brady
Barry/Walter
Rice big drop to Moss
Gonzalez/Gronk
Munoz/Allen/Hannah/Pace

Deion/Lott/Reed/Woodson
Lewis
White/Taylor
D Thomas

Ken Stabler
Mac Jones
Derrick Henry
Nick Saban
Joe Namath
Shaun Alexander
Julio Jones
Minkah Fitzpatrick
Mark Ingran
Derrick Thomas

That's the REAL top 10 NFL players ever. Not even questionable, IMO.

All Bama took me a while to get it

You're missing John Hannah and Don Hutson for sure. Then you hit guys like Bart Starr, Dwight Stephenson and Ozzie Newsome who you could make an argument for as well.

This may be off topic but related NFL MVP is the dumbest award in history. QB is the most important position flat out and the award turns into a QB award each season. For example in the last 20 years 18 MVPs have been QBs. It's been either a QB or a RB since 1986.

No receiver has ever won the award yet a kicker has.

In 1987 people were dumb as rocks and gave MVP to Elway who had 3100 yards 19 TDs 12 INTs. Jerry Rice had 23 TDs in a strike shortened 12 game season and did not win MVP in 87. Apparently in 87 Montana split a lot of the Rice vote by garnering a lot of MVP votes himself.

The solution is to have a QB of the year award separate from NFL MVP which only considers position players. It would be like MLB with Cy Young and MVP split.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
This may be off topic but related NFL MVP is the dumbest award in history. QB is the most important position flat out and the award turns into a QB award each season. For example in the last 20 years 18 MVPs have been QBs. It's been either a QB or a RB since 1986.

No receiver has ever won the award yet a kicker has.

In 1987 people were dumb as rocks and gave MVP to Elway who had 3100 yards 19 TDs 12 INTs. Jerry Rice had 23 TDs in a strike shortened 12 game season and did not win MVP in 87. Apparently in 87 Montana split a lot of the Rice vote by garnering a lot of MVP votes himself.

The solution is to have a QB of the year award separate from NFL MVP which only considers position players. It would be like MLB with Cy Young and MVP split.

Ya but you can win the cy young award and MVP.

I hear you though. There should somehow separate QB MVP and League MVP. It's too easy to win MVP as QB for the reasons you stated.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
This may be off topic but related NFL MVP is the dumbest award in history. QB is the most important position flat out and the award turns into a QB award each season. For example in the last 20 years 18 MVPs have been QBs. It's been either a QB or a RB since 1986.

No receiver has ever won the award yet a kicker has.

In 1987 people were dumb as rocks and gave MVP to Elway who had 3100 yards 19 TDs 12 INTs. Jerry Rice had 23 TDs in a strike shortened 12 game season and did not win MVP in 87. Apparently in 87 Montana split a lot of the Rice vote by garnering a lot of MVP votes himself.

The solution is to have a QB of the year award separate from NFL MVP which only considers position players. It would be like MLB with Cy Young and MVP split.

I didn't think it was exactly 'dumb' to give the award to Elway that year. It's how you actually interpret Most Valuable Player.....do you go with the guy with simply the best numbers, or the guy who was most instrumental in their teams' success? Elway did shoulder a lot of the load for those Broncos, and without him they'd be a 4 win type team.

I think Rice was the true MVP that year.....he was so far and away the most dominant player. If it wasn't for the strike, he was on his way to around 30 TD's. In 1987 when passing wasn't the joke that it is today. He was just f**king rididculous that year.

Originally posted by DaBeegDeek:

Originally posted by BamaNiner:
Manning/Brady
Barry/Walter
Rice big drop to Moss
Gonzalez/Gronk
Munoz/Allen/Hannah/Pace

Deion/Lott/Reed/Woodson
Lewis
White/Taylor
D Thomas

Ken Stabler
Mac Jones
Derrick Henry
Nick Saban
Joe Namath
Shaun Alexander
Julio Jones
Minkah Fitzpatrick
Mark Ingran
Derrick Thomas

That's the REAL top 10 NFL players ever. Not even questionable, IMO.

Great list minus Fitzpatrick that dudes barely average

1. Jerry Rice
2. Jim Brown
3. Lawrence Taylor
4. Barry Sanders
5. Aaron Rodgers
6. Peyton Manning
7. Ronnie Lott
8. Reggie White
9. Tom Brady
10. Joe Montana

Originally posted by English:
If you post like this you might just be out of here. These are opinions.

It's a Jeff Foxworthy reference.

guess I should have identified it as such .