Tom Brady, QB retires again

Hinting at a comeback for a SuperBowl contender ? I think we're set for the near future with Brock Purdy, but Brady might be Shanahan's guaranteed ticket to overcome his own deficiencies and win a Super Bowl to get over that proverbial "hump".

With a loaded roster for one more season (realistically), is it worth the risk to pass on Brady for a 3rd (maybe 4th) time and risk losing another chance for a ring ? Is Brady an upgrade over Brock at this age (IMO yes).

I'd take the risk just so we can get that one ring then let Brock take over next year when a lot of changes could be coming to the team….

Originally posted by DrEll:
Hinting at a comeback for a SuperBowl contender ? I think we're set for the near future with Brock Purdy, but Brady might be Shanahan's guaranteed ticket to overcome his own deficiencies and win a Super Bowl to get over that proverbial "hump".

With a loaded roster for one more season (realistically), is it worth the risk to pass on Brady for a 3rd (maybe 4th) time and risk losing another chance for a ring ? Is Brady an upgrade over Brock at this age (IMO yes).

I'd take the risk just so we can get that one ring then let Brock take over next year when a lot of changes could be coming to the team….

lol

Originally posted by DrEll:
Hinting at a comeback for a SuperBowl contender ? I think we're set for the near future with Brock Purdy, but Brady might be Shanahan's guaranteed ticket to overcome his own deficiencies and win a Super Bowl to get over that proverbial "hump".

With a loaded roster for one more season (realistically), is it worth the risk to pass on Brady for a 3rd (maybe 4th) time and risk losing another chance for a ring ? Is Brady an upgrade over Brock at this age (IMO yes).

I'd take the risk just so we can get that one ring then let Brock take over next year when a lot of changes could be coming to the team….

I would take Brady in an instant

Originally posted by GLT49ers:
I would take Brady in an instant

Zero chance Brady in 2024 is better than Purdy in 2024.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Zero chance Brady in 2024 is better than Purdy in 2024.

This

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by GLT49ers:
I would take Brady in an instant

Zero chance Brady in 2024 is better than Purdy in 2024.

Exactly what Shanny thought back in 2020 when comparing him to Jimmy. Oops….

Originally posted by DrEll:

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by GLT49ers:
I would take Brady in an instant

Zero chance Brady in 2024 is better than Purdy in 2024.

Exactly what Shanny thought back in 2020 when comparing him to Jimmy. Oops….

Lol

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Originally posted by DrEll:

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by GLT49ers:
I would take Brady in an instant

Zero chance Brady in 2024 is better than Purdy in 2024.

Exactly what Shanny thought back in 2020 when comparing him to Jimmy. Oops….

Lol

LOL its true, but dude is so old one hit could kill him. Not worth the risk imo.

I dont think we'd do that to Purdy even though I'd give it a shot. There's only two teams that make sense. Vikings and Raiders, the other 3 would be Browns, Dolphins, and maybe us

Originally posted by Since07:
I dont think we'd do that to Purdy even though I'd give it a shot. There's only two teams that make sense. Vikings and Raiders, the other 3 would be Browns, Dolphins, and maybe us

Raiders as some sort of owner, QB, offensive coordinator combo platter

Originally posted by DrEll:
Exactly what Shanny thought back in 2020 when comparing him to Jimmy. Oops….

You don't think there's a difference between 42 and 46 years old?

Originally posted by DrEll:
Exactly what Shanny thought back in 2020 when comparing him to Jimmy. Oops….

Did Jimmy have a ProBowl year in 2019 that I don't remember?

would love to see him come back and have a life altering head injury or worse...

Originally posted by jimmy3233:
would love to see him come back and have a life altering head injury or worse...

That seems pretty odd eh?

Originally posted by illinois9er:

Originally posted by jimmy3233:
would love to see him come back and have a life altering head injury or worse...

That seems pretty odd eh?

yea wtf