LISTEN: 49ers Midseason Mailbag →

There are 259 users in the forums

Justin Fields and his Steelers

Shop 49ers game tickets
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Did the players who vote on this clear that with the 49erwebzone forum? Cause I keep reading how bad he is on here.
Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Did the players who vote on this clear that with the 49erwebzone forum? Cause I keep reading how bad he is on here.

If only the players actually vote on this stuff
Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:
Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Did the players who vote on this clear that with the 49erwebzone forum? Cause I keep reading how bad he is on here.

If only the players actually vote on this stuff

If only you did a simple google search
He is a very good running back
so Fields > Lance now or no ?
Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:
so Fields > Lance now or no ?

Still way too early. Everyone knew Trey was probally going to take 3 years anyways. Kyle and John need to hope it's much longer than that.
[ Edited by JTB1974 on Aug 29, 2023 at 1:19 AM ]
Originally posted by JTB1974:
Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:
so Fields > Lance now or no ?

Still way too early. Everyone knew Trey was probally going to take 3 years anyways. Kyle and John need to hope it's much longer than that.

Fields has pretty much been the most talented QB at every level he has played at. He was always better then Lance and it wasn't that close IMO. The fact he wasn't a top 5 pick is teams over thinking things. Baring a major injury, Fields is going to be a really good QB for a long time and should of been the pick at #3.
Originally posted by Jcool:
Fields has pretty much been the most talented QB at every level he has played at. He was always better then Lance and it wasn't that close IMO. The fact he wasn't a top 5 pick is teams over thinking things. Baring a major injury, Fields is going to be a really good QB for a long time and should of been the pick at #3.

Most talented RB is what you should be saying. He still hasn't developed as a passer. Still holds onto the ball too long, Still not comfortable throwing from the pocket. Always looking to bail early. He barely had over 2200 yards passing last season, barely completed 60% of his passes. Had 17 TD passes and 11 picks. 85.2 rating which is less than average I believe for a starting QB. But everyone makes excuses for him because he plays for the Bears. His team won 4 games last season and he had so many chances to lead game-winning drives but failed almost every time. But yes as a runner he is elite. But that can only get you so far.
Originally posted by Jcool:
Fields has pretty much been the most talented QB at every level he has played at. He was always better then Lance and it wasn't that close IMO. The fact he wasn't a top 5 pick is teams over thinking things. Baring a major injury, Fields is going to be a really good QB for a long time and should of been the pick at #3.

Justin Fields Preseason 2023 Week 3 Analysis
Originally posted by JTB1974:
Originally posted by Jcool:
Fields has pretty much been the most talented QB at every level he has played at. He was always better then Lance and it wasn't that close IMO. The fact he wasn't a top 5 pick is teams over thinking things. Baring a major injury, Fields is going to be a really good QB for a long time and should of been the pick at #3.

Most talented RB is what you should be saying. He still hasn't developed as a passer. Still holds onto the ball too long, Still not comfortable throwing from the pocket. Always looking to bail early. He barely had over 2200 yards passing last season, barely completed 60% of his passes. Had 17 TD passes and 11 picks. 85.2 rating which is less than average I believe for a starting QB. But everyone makes excuses for him because he plays for the Bears. His team won 4 games last season and he had so many chances to lead game-winning drives but failed almost every time. But yes as a runner he is elite. But that can only get you so far.

I've seen this fan base pull out excuse after excuse for their own 49er QB but a different QB doesn't get that kinda treatment. Fields had a brand new coach and offense last year but we are gonna act like this website doesn't excuse Alex Smith when he had the same s**t happen to him?
Do people still think this guy is any good
💩
Originally posted by ninerfan4life:
Do people still think this guy is any good

Never did. He's terrible. Truth be told if it wasn't for Trey Sermon he wouldn't have been much in college either. I've never understood the love.
Bears hiring Matt Eberflus over Brian Daboll would be like if the 49ers passed on Shanahan for Tom Cable.
Share 49ersWebzone