Early Black Friday Sale on 49ers Gear! Use Code CATCH30 →

There are 209 users in the forums

Hypothetical: Would You Swap Purdy For?

Shop 49ers game tickets

Hypothetical: Would You Swap Purdy For?

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
I'd be tempted to get Lamar Jackson, but I love Brock, no hate for Brock, but I like Jackson, and it would be fun to see him next to CMC in a KS run game. Jalen Hurts I am a big fan as well, he can truck ppl, and him with CMC on the RPO game would be elite. I like Fields, but Fields over Lance, not sure about over Brock. Tua with our QB injury history would be slapping the fball gods in the face, challenging them to a duel.

I think Hurts will get hurt they way he plays. He plays like a NT or FB. The amount of punishment he gives and receives will add up eventually. I don't see him lasting long term.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
I'd be tempted to get Lamar Jackson, but I love Brock, no hate for Brock, but I like Jackson, and it would be fun to see him next to CMC in a KS run game. Jalen Hurts I am a big fan as well, he can truck ppl, and him with CMC on the RPO game would be elite. I like Fields, but Fields over Lance, not sure about over Brock. Tua with our QB injury history would be slapping the fball gods in the face, challenging them to a duel.

I think Hurts will get hurt they way he plays. He plays like a NT or FB. The amount of punishment he gives and receives will add up eventually. I don't see him lasting long term.

Jalen "Hurts" it's right in the name. Sometimes these are easy
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
I'd be tempted to get Lamar Jackson, but I love Brock, no hate for Brock, but I like Jackson, and it would be fun to see him next to CMC in a KS run game. Jalen Hurts I am a big fan as well, he can truck ppl, and him with CMC on the RPO game would be elite. I like Fields, but Fields over Lance, not sure about over Brock. Tua with our QB injury history would be slapping the fball gods in the face, challenging them to a duel.

I think Hurts will get hurt they way he plays. He plays like a NT or FB. The amount of punishment he gives and receives will add up eventually. I don't see him lasting long term.

Jalen "Hurts" it's right in the name. Sometimes these are easy

Yeah I agree. It will happen eventually. You can't keep running straight into Nose Tackles even if you can squat 600 pounds. I'm surprised he stayed healthy so far but it won't hold up over time IMO.
Fields and Tua
Originally posted by Dr_Bill_Walsh:
🔘 1984 Joe Montana

No. 1980 Joe Montana, maybe.
Originally posted by billbird2111:
Originally posted by Dr_Bill_Walsh:
🔘 1984 Joe Montana

No. 1980 Joe Montana, maybe.

Hold up you wouldn't do it for 84 Joe F Montana?
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
I'd be tempted to get Lamar Jackson, but I love Brock, no hate for Brock, but I like Jackson, and it would be fun to see him next to CMC in a KS run game. Jalen Hurts I am a big fan as well, he can truck ppl, and him with CMC on the RPO game would be elite. I like Fields, but Fields over Lance, not sure about over Brock. Tua with our QB injury history would be slapping the fball gods in the face, challenging them to a duel.

I think Hurts will get hurt they way he plays. He plays like a NT or FB. The amount of punishment he gives and receives will add up eventually. I don't see him lasting long term.

The NFL is littered with "run first" QB's who did not last longer than 5-7 years. Most don't last that long. There are a few exceptions to this rule.

Fran Tarkenton, aka "Frantic Fran" or "The Mad Scrambler," was an absolute maniac. He should have blown out multiple knees during the course of his career, yet somehow they held up. Perhaps the pace of the game was slower back then? I don't know. I do know that by the time I came aware of him, he wasn't running as much. But he was also on the downside of his career.

Roger Staubach, aka "Roger the Dodger," was another big scrambler. But, like Tarkenton, he mellowed with age and became more of a pocket passer. He was able to last, much to the chagrin of 49er fans. Staubach broke our hearts on more than one occassion. One of my biggest hopes and dreams as a young man was that Bill Walsh would finally put an end to the curse of Roger Staubach. Alas, by the time the 1981 49ers rolled around, Staubach had already ridden off into the sunset.

I am hoping that Lamar Jackson can make the transition into a pocket passer. His best days as a running QB are behind him.
Originally posted by billbird2111:
The NFL is littered with "run first" QB's who did not last longer than 5-7 years. Most don't last that long. There are a few exceptions to this rule.

Fran Tarkenton, aka "Frantic Fran" or "The Mad Scrambler," was an absolute maniac. He should have blown out multiple knees during the course of his career, yet somehow they held up. Perhaps the pace of the game was slower back then? I don't know. I do know that by the time I came aware of him, he wasn't running as much. But he was also on the downside of his career.

Roger Staubach, aka "Roger the Dodger," was another big scrambler. But, like Tarkenton, he mellowed with age and became more of a pocket passer. He was able to last, much to the chagrin of 49er fans. Staubach broke our hearts on more than one occassion. One of my biggest hopes and dreams as a young man was that Bill Walsh would finally put an end to the curse of Roger Staubach. Alas, by the time the 1981 49ers rolled around, Staubach had already ridden off into the sunset.

I am hoping that Lamar Jackson can make the transition into a pocket passer. His best days as a running QB are behind him.

They got Lamar some receivers now, he hasn't had much his whole career imo. They also moved on from Roman. Should be interesting.
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Originally posted by billbird2111:
Originally posted by Dr_Bill_Walsh:
🔘 1984 Joe Montana

No. 1980 Joe Montana, maybe.

Hold up you wouldn't do it for 84 Joe F Montana?

No, I would opt for more years of play out of Joe Montana, the greatest ever to play the game. That's the reasoning behind the choice of 1980 Montana to 1984 Montana.
Originally posted by billbird2111:
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Originally posted by billbird2111:
Originally posted by Dr_Bill_Walsh:
🔘 1984 Joe Montana

No. 1980 Joe Montana, maybe.

Hold up you wouldn't do it for 84 Joe F Montana?

No, I would opt for more years of play out of Joe Montana, the greatest ever to play the game. That's the reasoning behind the choice of 1980 Montana to 1984 Montana.

Gotcha lol
I would only swap Purdy for the following QB's at their current ages:

Mahomes
Burrow
Allen
Herbert
Lawrence

Everyone else (Lamar, Rodgers, Hurts, Stafford, Kyler, Watson, Wilson) I either feel are too old or not a good fit for our system.
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by btthepunk:
Brandon Allen ain't that good man.


He was referring to Kyle Allen of course. QB for the Bills.

I definitely don't want Kyle Allen over Brock. Not a chance.

I don't even know whether Kyle Allen is better than our QB3 Brandon Allen.
[ Edited by libertyforever on Aug 28, 2023 at 6:31 PM ]
Originally posted by libertyforever:
I definitely don't want Kyle Allen over Brock. Not a chance.

I don't even know whether Kyle Allen is better than our QB3 Brandon Allen.

I was playing off the joke. Buffalo has two QB's named Allen. The one that was referenced was Josh. He's alright.
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by libertyforever:
I definitely don't want Kyle Allen over Brock. Not a chance.

I don't even know whether Kyle Allen is better than our QB3 Brandon Allen.

I was playing off the joke. Buffalo has two QB's named Allen. The one that was referenced was Josh. He's alright.

Yep, Josh is alright.
Realistically, swapping Purdy out with any top QB means that we will also have to trade out a couple player on our roster to fit that QB under our cap. It would more than likely mean Purdy + Deebo + Warner or whoever to fit that QB under our cap, unless that QB was still on their rookie contract as well (Burrow/Lawrence). So it's hard to say at this point. If Purdy remains playing like a top 5 QB this year, then you could argue he's more valuable at his contract level than any QB in the league.
Share 49ersWebzone