Originally posted by StOnEy333:
As much as I'd love to see it, I can't see Lynch and Shanny thinking Frank belongs on this team, from a player personnel point of view. As a heart warming home coming stand point, it makes perfect sense. Not much other than that, though.
Frank is the exception and I hope Lynch and Shanny recognize that. Bill Walsh was well known for parting with vets a year early rather than a year late, but check his scouting report on what he wanted in a running back. It's almost like he was describing Frank word for word, especially the parts I bolded.
There are obvious talents necessary to play the position, but perhaps the most overlooked is durability and stamina. This player must be nearly as effective in the fourth quarter as he was in the first.
You fashion your offense as to the talents of your halfback. Typically, you are looking for the real competitor who is unmoved by the abuse he endures during a game. He is able to focus and concentrate on doing his job every play. He is going to get a lot of abuse and the unexpected is going to happen to him time and time again.
Pure running instincts become critical. You just can't play this position without instincts. There has to be an intuitive style and it differs by degree with every running back there is. Without those instincts, as we learned with Terrance Flagler after we spent a No. 1 pick on him, you can't play the position. In practice, Terrance could do everything that you wanted. But in a game, he just wasn't instinctive. So that is critical.
Now, if he can block effectively, your offense has much more dimension. As a receiver, you'd like to think he is at least an adept screen-pass receiver. And, by degree, the further down the field he can go and catch the ball, the more dimensional your offense becomes.
Even with all these abilities, the most important aspect is probably durability, without which the other talents become of diminished value. You must be able to count on this player if he is a key part of the offensive philosophy.
Size requirements vary. Some smaller runners play big, like James Brooks did at under 190 pounds. The key, along with durability, is that when they are hit they should be able to fall forward.
Despite the instincts you look for, there should be discipline to get the first four yards within the scheme and then rely on instincts to take it beyond that. Of course there are times when an instinctive back does things on his own early in a play. But when you begin to leave the designed play too often, you are not going to serve the team with consistent gains that the offense must count on.
http://www.sportsxchange.com/DS97/walsh/walsh2hb.htm
Frank's numbers are down ever since he went to Indy, but as someone who has watched every Indy game since he went there, he looks the same as he did five years ago except he's been playing with literally a bunch of backups at QB and OL. As a couple examples, Luck has missed exactly half the games Frank has been there (22/44), and Indy was down to a 4th string center today, someone the beat writers didn't even recognize because they just brought him in this week. Without TY Hilton, that offense he is on right now is every bit as bad and unimaginative as our offenses under Hostler or Raye.
No one could've predicted that Luck would get hurt as soon as Frank got there, I just hope that wherever he goes next year, he's blessed with a franchise QB and a mauling OL. It sounds kind of crazy with how badly things have gone in Indy, but it's a totally different team with Luck and Frank knows it. Their new GM spent last offseason fixing the defense. If he spends the next offseason fixing the OL, Indy could turn out to be the best spot for him.
Ultimately, I really hope we bring him back, a backfield of Jimmy G and Frankie G is meant to be.
[ Edited by znk916 on Dec 3, 2017 at 9:10 PM ]