Originally posted by Oscar:
Originally posted by TheFunkyChicken:
Originally posted by SonocoNinerFan:
I think it's been pointed out in previous posts, but these basic renderings have been clipped from a 14 month old City of Santa Clara zoning variance application and IN NO WAY are presented in a form to sway public opinion on the final design.
Even if that's true it worries me that they're not at least trying to generate a little excitement by releasing some concept drawings that actually look good.
I'm not overly jazzed about the design either. But like some other people, I could care less what it looks like as long as:
1) It gets freaking built
2) The sight lines are great
[i]3) The design the stadium with acoustics in mind. Home field advantage is critical and any advantage you can get is worth it. [/i]
4) There is plenty of parking
Other than these things, I can quibble about my appreciation for the exterior design. It really doesn't matter.
Also, if these are just renderings, they might as well put some out that creates a little buzz. I agree that if the designs are just "placeholders" they they are approaching this project all wrong.
You make a very important point. Whereas the design gives great sightlines of the field from every seat, Im not so sure the open arena architecture takes advantage of honing in the crowd noise, something that the designers of Quest Field made sure of instilling in their stadium. All that noise from SC Stadium will not drown out the opposition; instead, it will escape into the beautiful breeze that all the fans can "enjoy" in our new stadium. Also, you're assuming that the 68K+ seats will sell out............I doubt it, considering that Candlestick looks barren at times during the season.
Point being, Santa Clara was always at a disadvantage because there's really nothing there that will attract the "casual" fan to come to the games. If we cant fill Candlestick, what makes you think that SC will be any different ? On top of that, we have a wide arena stadium that will allow all crowd noise to escape.
Bad idea, if you ask me...............
[ Edited by ZRF80 on May 31, 2009 at 11:10:22 ]