Originally posted by ninertico:
...back to topic.
The more I revert back to Alex in 2006 and the start of 2007, I have some assemblence of history to equate a positive outlook because of his positive progression in off season's practice. Imagine, he did enough to warrant a competition on the eve of TC 2009. On the other hand, Hill, Mr. Kick Azz, will not give up without a fight with all his being...just think about his run for a first against AZ.
Therefore, I expect a very heated competition. Cool. Seriously, because it will only bring out the best in them. IMO, most are underestimating what both these QBs can do in Raye's offense. Given what Alex has endured and given what Hill has accomplished, both will provide us with some passionate plays for sure.
IMO, I expect Alex to use his mobility and his accurate down field throwing to separate himself from Hill. Hill will win in the short routes, but Alex will do well enough to keep up with him. It is the mid-field to deep routes that will allow Alex to show off his abilities. The evidence was in these last OTAs and minis. He earned the opportunity to compete.
I am sure everyone agrees that the pre-season games mean a great deal because we will see Alex perform live since 2007 (...wow, it's really been two years) to witness his success or defeat. He has to prove he's got enough to beat Hill and it won't be easy.
Again, I believe that we win as a fan base no matter who wins. There is no denying the heart these two have. There is no denying they want the best for the team. There is no denying that we benefit from all points of view whether you vehemently want Alex or Hill.
I just prefer the conjunction and.
Nicely stated. I agree, I think the competition has made them both better, and I expect it will continue to do so--even after one of them is named the starter. Knowing that someone's there to take your place if you falter has to motivate you to play better. IMHO.
It seems, to me, that Singletary would be wise to name Hill the starter, however. No need to rush Smith out there. IMHO. Unless, of course, Smith shows so much improvement that he's the clear cut choice.
Bottom line, I intend to support whichever guy is named the starter.
Go Niners.
