David's Carr Needs a Mechanic.

Originally posted by PTulini:

QB David Carr

Haha David did threw like that in hs too. I'm rooting for Alex but it's hard not to root for David. I wanted the Niners to take him and develop Jim in 02 because it was guaranteed free tickets for me. Haha. I haven't seen or talked to the Carrs in forever so i guess now it would be tacky. :(

Originally posted by LambdaChi49:

Originally posted by PTulini:

QB David Carr

Haha David did threw like that in hs too. I'm rooting for Alex but it's hard not to root for David. I wanted the Niners to take him and develop Jim in 02 because it was guaranteed free tickets for me. Haha. I haven't seen or talked to the Carrs in forever so i guess now it would be tacky. :(

Who's Jim??

[ Edited by Kolohe on Mar 30, 2010 at 00:50:57 ]

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by LambdaChi49:

Originally posted by PTulini:

QB David Carr

Haha David did threw like that in hs too. I'm rooting for Alex but it's hard not to root for David. I wanted the Niners to take him and develop Jim in 02 because it was guaranteed free tickets for me. Haha. I haven't seen or talked to the Carrs in forever so i guess now it would be tacky. :(

Who's Jim??

im guesssing he meant him

Why the f**k are these articles saying that Carr is competing for the number one spot? f**k that! Smith is the starter.........period!

It's only Yahoo that says there is a competition, with Both Matts, and from everyone else in the organization, Smith is the starter its just the facts.

And someone said how can you not root for Carr, well actually I am, in the same way i did for JTO, Hill, and even Davis. As the backups I hope they turn out pretty good. As for now Smith is the starter. And it's not about just backing him, it's about we know who our starter is now, so lets focus on getting that offense even more intact.

Originally posted by Jersey9er:
It's only Yahoo that says there is a competition, with Both Matts, and from everyone else in the organization, Smith is the starter its just the facts.

And someone said how can you not root for Carr, well actually I am, in the same way i did for JTO, Hill, and even Davis. As the backups I hope they turn out pretty good. As for now Smith is the starter. And it's not about just backing him, it's about we know who our starter is now, so lets focus on getting that offense even more intact.

Wrong...

http://www.nfl.com/news/story?id=09000d5d81737545&template=with-video-with-comments&confirm=true

The reason everyone around the NFL sees it as a battle is because they know that Alex Smith and David Carr are pretty much the same QB. They both have done s**t so far and have fans holding onto nothing but hopes for a miracle.

[ Edited by Chief on Mar 30, 2010 at 07:40:14 ]

Originally posted by Chief:

Originally posted by Jersey9er:
It's only Yahoo that says there is a competition, with Both Matts, and from everyone else in the organization, Smith is the starter its just the facts.

And someone said how can you not root for Carr, well actually I am, in the same way i did for JTO, Hill, and even Davis. As the backups I hope they turn out pretty good. As for now Smith is the starter. And it's not about just backing him, it's about we know who our starter is now, so lets focus on getting that offense even more intact.

Wrong...

http://www.nfl.com/news/story?id=09000d5d81737545&template=with-video-with-comments&confirm=true

The reason everyone around the NFL sees it as a battle is because they know that Alex Smith and David Carr are pretty much the same QB. They both have done s**t so far and have fans holding onto nothing but hopes for a miracle.

Come on Chief... I clearly remember Sing stating that Smith is going to be our Off-Season starter...

Originally posted by Jersey9er:
It's only Yahoo that says there is a competition, with Both Matts, and from everyone else in the organization, Smith is the starter its just the facts.

And someone said how can you not root for Carr, well actually I am, in the same way i did for JTO, Hill, and even Davis. As the backups I hope they turn out pretty good. As for now Smith is the starter. And it's not about just backing him, it's about we know who our starter is now, so lets focus on getting that offense even more intact.

Why would you use a word like facts in a topic like this? I am not sure how long you have been watching the NFL, but I see non injury QB changes made all the time after a proclamation is made by the HC that so and so is definitely their guy.

You really can't use a strong word like fact. You know when it is close to a fact who the starter is? When the HC does not need to say anything...

When is the last time you heard Peyton, Brady or Bree's coaches proclaim they are definitely the starter?

Originally posted by Chief:

Originally posted by Jersey9er:
It's only Yahoo that says there is a competition, with Both Matts, and from everyone else in the organization, Smith is the starter its just the facts.

And someone said how can you not root for Carr, well actually I am, in the same way i did for JTO, Hill, and even Davis. As the backups I hope they turn out pretty good. As for now Smith is the starter. And it's not about just backing him, it's about we know who our starter is now, so lets focus on getting that offense even more intact.

Wrong...

http://www.nfl.com/news/story?id=09000d5d81737545&template=with-video-with-comments&confirm=true

The reason everyone around the NFL sees it as a battle is because they know that Alex Smith and David Carr are pretty much the same QB. They both have done s**t so far and have fans holding onto nothing but hopes for a miracle.

Originally posted by Chief:

Originally posted by Jersey9er:
It's only Yahoo that says there is a competition, with Both Matts, and from everyone else in the organization, Smith is the starter its just the facts.

And someone said how can you not root for Carr, well actually I am, in the same way i did for JTO, Hill, and even Davis. As the backups I hope they turn out pretty good. As for now Smith is the starter. And it's not about just backing him, it's about we know who our starter is now, so lets focus on getting that offense even more intact.

Wrong...

http://www.nfl.com/news/story?id=09000d5d81737545&template=with-video-with-comments&confirm=true

The reason everyone around the NFL sees it as a battle is because they know that Alex Smith and David Carr are pretty much the same QB. They both have done s**t so far and have fans holding onto nothing but hopes for a miracle.

No YOU are WRONG!

i cant tell you why right now but ill get back to you.....

Originally posted by danimal:

Originally posted by Jersey9er:
It's only Yahoo that says there is a competition, with Both Matts, and from everyone else in the organization, Smith is the starter its just the facts.

And someone said how can you not root for Carr, well actually I am, in the same way i did for JTO, Hill, and even Davis. As the backups I hope they turn out pretty good. As for now Smith is the starter. And it's not about just backing him, it's about we know who our starter is now, so lets focus on getting that offense even more intact.

Why would you use a word like facts in a topic like this? I am not sure how long you have been watching the NFL, but I see non injury QB changes made all the time after a proclamation is made by the HC that so and so is definitely their guy.

You really can't use a strong word like fact. You know when it is close to a fact who the starter is? When the HC does not need to say anything...

When is the last time you heard Peyton, Brady or Bree's coaches proclaim they are definitely the starter?

Why would one use a word like "facts"? Because one's concept of "best player at the position" is a bit retarded, maybe? I donno . . . you tell me.

And even if Smith, eventually proves to be:
Two years ago JTO was the starter. That was a FACT.
Last year Shaun Hill was the starter. That was a FACT.
So how did that work out?

What is it about people that they so buy into a player's status on the team that they go all queer at the prospect that he may not be the best solution?

Also, maybe the reason that Yahoo! and others talk about there being a competition, is because Singletary actually has said as much?

Carr came to the Niners because he believes that he has the best shot at being a starter here. He's not intending to lie down and accept being a back up. Good on him! I hope that he makes it. It only means that the team will get better play out of that position than it has had for an eternity.

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by LambdaChi49:

Originally posted by PTulini:

QB David Carr

Haha David did threw like that in hs too. I'm rooting for Alex but it's hard not to root for David. I wanted the Niners to take him and develop Jim in 02 because it was guaranteed free tickets for me. Haha. I haven't seen or talked to the Carrs in forever so i guess now it would be tacky. :(

Who's Jim??

Jim Dandy

Originally posted by Tman:

Originally posted by Chief:

Originally posted by Jersey9er:
It's only Yahoo that says there is a competition, with Both Matts, and from everyone else in the organization, Smith is the starter its just the facts.

And someone said how can you not root for Carr, well actually I am, in the same way i did for JTO, Hill, and even Davis. As the backups I hope they turn out pretty good. As for now Smith is the starter. And it's not about just backing him, it's about we know who our starter is now, so lets focus on getting that offense even more intact.

Wrong...

http://www.nfl.com/news/story?id=09000d5d81737545&template=with-video-with-comments&confirm=true

The reason everyone around the NFL sees it as a battle is because they know that Alex Smith and David Carr are pretty much the same QB. They both have done s**t so far and have fans holding onto nothing but hopes for a miracle.

No YOU are WRONG!

i cant tell you why right now but ill get back to you.....

lol, awesome... I really do hope you are right.

it JUST now occurred to me that we have TWO #1 draft busts on our QB roster. That's pretty f**king sad.

Tim K's twitter

"Another thing I noticed: David Carr is throwing spirals that still end up looking like Shaun Hill's quackers--several yards behind WRs".

"Carr isn't the answer. If Alex Smith can't blow away Carr in the training camp competition, that would be very bad news for the 49ers".