David's Carr Needs a Mechanic.

I don't think there is a remote possibility that carr will start over smith without injury. I am glad carr is a decent QB who can win games in smith's absence. Nate Davis has a much higher ceiling than carr and smith IMHO. Maybe smith will pull a balmer? Just kidding, I have to hope alex starts to perform at a high level.

But I am glad the niners have carr on the squad.

Originally posted by fister30:
I don't think there is a remote possibility that carr will start over smith without injury. I am glad carr is a decent QB who can win games in smith's absence. Nate Davis has a much higher ceiling than carr and smith IMHO. Maybe smith will pull a balmer? Just kidding, I have to hope alex starts to perform at a high level.

But I am glad the niners have carr on the squad.

Originally posted by Born_Niner:
do anyone ever gets tired of the QB bickering that goes on this site?? ...bottom line is none of us has seen solid QB play since Garcia was shown the door

The fatal mistake of the last 10 years was not holding onto Cody Pickett! In the 90s, it was starting Young over Bono!

Originally posted by fister30:
I don't think there is a remote possibility that carr will start over smith without injury. I am glad carr is a decent QB who can win games in smith's absence. Nate Davis has a much higher ceiling than carr and smith IMHO. Maybe smith will pull a balmer? Just kidding, I have to hope alex starts to perform at a high level.

But I am glad the niners have carr on the squad.

The funny part about that is sure, Carr is a guy that can win games with Smith's absence. But with Smith IN we cannot win games. The Alexcuses keep rolling. 3rd stringers, no Gore, No Crabs....etc. Carr and Davis both looked better, regardless of who they were playing against.

Davis looked better last pre-season, in fact he has looked better everytime he has played in games, pre-season, whatever. Unfortunate that terrible ownership and coaching decisions are letting this season rest on an un-proven Smith.

The Smith supporters think that all of a sudden the regular season is going to come along and Smith will be better. What is that based on for crying out loud?? He will be facing better defenses and defensive schemes but all of a sudden the light will turn on and he will be a better QB???

Carr and Davis both perform better and all of the hate directed at them is cowardly. Nobody wants to admit that SMITH is GARBAGE. If Carr had to battle Smith in camp, no way Smith wins. Smith couldn't even beat out Shawn Hill. I just don't understand the love affair for a whack QB.

Originally posted by ninerfan818:

Originally posted by fister30:
I don't think there is a remote possibility that carr will start over smith without injury. I am glad carr is a decent QB who can win games in smith's absence. Nate Davis has a much higher ceiling than carr and smith IMHO. Maybe smith will pull a balmer? Just kidding, I have to hope alex starts to perform at a high level.

But I am glad the niners have carr on the squad.

The funny part about that is sure, Carr is a guy that can win games with Smith's absence. But with Smith IN we cannot win games. The Alexcuses keep rolling. 3rd stringers, no Gore, No Crabs....etc. Carr and Davis both looked better, regardless of who they were playing against.

Davis looked better last pre-season, in fact he has looked better everytime he has played in games, pre-season, whatever. Unfortunate that terrible ownership and coaching decisions are letting this season rest on an un-proven Smith.

The Smith supporters think that all of a sudden the regular season is going to come along and Smith will be better. What is that based on for crying out loud?? He will be facing better defenses and defensive schemes but all of a sudden the light will turn on and he will be a better QB???

Carr and Davis both perform better and all of the hate directed at them is cowardly. Nobody wants to admit that SMITH is GARBAGE. If Carr had to battle Smith in camp, no way Smith wins. Smith couldn't even beat out Shawn Hill. I just don't understand the love affair for a whack QB.

Oh yeah, because with 18 TDs in 11 games, obviously he can't play in the regular season. And with 5 wins in 10 starts, obviously he can't win! I'm not saying he's even good or anything but he did pretty good last year and he played better in the regular season than he did in the preseason last year so I'm not going to hit the panic button after one effing preseason game where the whole first string offense looked unorganized and s**tty while missing players. You said the same bulls**t about Hill last season how he's a winner and can win and blah blah blah and then now you're saying the same thing about Carr and neither of them are anyones answer at QB and neither of them are even better than Smith, especially not because of one friggin preseason game.

Originally posted by ninerfan818:

Originally posted by fister30:
I don't think there is a remote possibility that carr will start over smith without injury. I am glad carr is a decent QB who can win games in smith's absence. Nate Davis has a much higher ceiling than carr and smith IMHO. Maybe smith will pull a balmer? Just kidding, I have to hope alex starts to perform at a high level.

But I am glad the niners have carr on the squad.

The funny part about that is sure, Carr is a guy that can win games with Smith's absence. But with Smith IN we cannot win games. The Alexcuses keep rolling. 3rd stringers, no Gore, No Crabs....etc. Carr and Davis both looked better, regardless of who they were playing against.

Davis looked better last pre-season, in fact he has looked better everytime he has played in games, pre-season, whatever. Unfortunate that terrible ownership and coaching decisions are letting this season rest on an un-proven Smith.

The Smith supporters think that all of a sudden the regular season is going to come along and Smith will be better. What is that based on for crying out loud?? He will be facing better defenses and defensive schemes but all of a sudden the light will turn on and he will be a better QB???

Carr and Davis both perform better and all of the hate directed at them is cowardly. Nobody wants to admit that SMITH is GARBAGE. If Carr had to battle Smith in camp, no way Smith wins. Smith couldn't even beat out Shawn Hill. I just don't understand the love affair for a whack QB.

Smith will be replaced as soon as the season starts, maybe by the 3rd or 4th game hopefully

Originally posted by ninerfan818:

Originally posted by fister30:
I don't think there is a remote possibility that carr will start over smith without injury. I am glad carr is a decent QB who can win games in smith's absence. Nate Davis has a much higher ceiling than carr and smith IMHO. Maybe smith will pull a balmer? Just kidding, I have to hope alex starts to perform at a high level.

But I am glad the niners have carr on the squad.

The funny part about that is sure, Carr is a guy that can win games with Smith's absence. But with Smith IN we cannot win games. The Alexcuses keep rolling. 3rd stringers, no Gore, No Crabs....etc. Carr and Davis both looked better, regardless of who they were playing against.

Davis looked better last pre-season, in fact he has looked better everytime he has played in games, pre-season, whatever. Unfortunate that terrible ownership and coaching decisions are letting this season rest on an un-proven Smith.

The Smith supporters think that all of a sudden the regular season is going to come along and Smith will be better. What is that based on for crying out loud?? He will be facing better defenses and defensive schemes but all of a sudden the light will turn on and he will be a better QB???

Carr and Davis both perform better and all of the hate directed at them is cowardly. Nobody wants to admit that SMITH is GARBAGE. If Carr had to battle Smith in camp, no way Smith wins. Smith couldn't even beat out Shawn Hill. I just don't understand the love affair for a whack QB.

Seems as if there is enough hate to go around for all the Niner QBs with a little left over for Jarrett Brown.

Originally posted by ninerfan818:

Originally posted by fister30:
I don't think there is a remote possibility that carr will start over smith without injury. I am glad carr is a decent QB who can win games in smith's absence. Nate Davis has a much higher ceiling than carr and smith IMHO. Maybe smith will pull a balmer? Just kidding, I have to hope alex starts to perform at a high level.

But I am glad the niners have carr on the squad.

The funny part about that is sure, Carr is a guy that can win games with Smith's absence. But
with Smith IN we cannot win games. The Alexcuses keep rolling. 3rd stringers, no Gore, No
Crabs....etc. Carr and Davis both looked better, regardless of who they were playing against.

Davis looked better last pre-season, in fact he has looked better everytime he has played in games, pre-season, whatever. Unfortunate that terrible ownership and coaching decisions are
letting this season rest on an un-proven Smith.

The Smith supporters think that all of a sudden the regular season is going to come along and
Smith will be better. What is that based on for crying out loud?? He will be facing better
defenses and defensive schemes but all of a sudden the light will turn on and he will be a better
QB???

Carr and Davis both perform better and all of the hate directed at them is cowardly. Nobody
wants to admit that SMITH is GARBAGE. If Carr had to battle Smith in camp, no way Smith
wins. Smith couldn't even beat out Shawn Hill. I just don't understand the love affair for a whack
QB.

Cowardly? What a funny chap you are, to be sure.

As to the rest, it's all been said. Curiously, the professionals, those whose jobs depend on it, don't seem to agree with you.

Originally posted by English:

Originally posted by ninerfan818:

Originally posted by fister30:
I don't think there is a remote possibility that carr will start over smith without injury. I am glad carr is a decent QB who can win games in smith's absence. Nate Davis has a much higher ceiling than carr and smith IMHO. Maybe smith will pull a balmer? Just kidding, I have to hope alex starts to perform at a high level.

But I am glad the niners have carr on the squad.

The funny part about that is sure, Carr is a guy that can win games with Smith's absence. But
with Smith IN we cannot win games. The Alexcuses keep rolling. 3rd stringers, no Gore, No
Crabs....etc. Carr and Davis both looked better, regardless of who they were playing against.

Davis looked better last pre-season, in fact he has looked better everytime he has played in games, pre-season, whatever. Unfortunate that terrible ownership and coaching decisions are
letting this season rest on an un-proven Smith.

The Smith supporters think that all of a sudden the regular season is going to come along and
Smith will be better. What is that based on for crying out loud?? He will be facing better
defenses and defensive schemes but all of a sudden the light will turn on and he will be a better
QB???

Carr and Davis both perform better and all of the hate directed at them is cowardly. Nobody
wants to admit that SMITH is GARBAGE. If Carr had to battle Smith in camp, no way Smith
wins. Smith couldn't even beat out Shawn Hill. I just don't understand the love affair for a whack
QB.

Cowardly? What a funny chap you are, to be sure.

As to the rest, it's all been said. Curiously, the professionals, those whose jobs depend on it, don't seem to agree with you.

Professionals??? Most of them think he's not a good QB..

Originally posted by fly15:

Originally posted by English:

Originally posted by ninerfan818:

Originally posted by fister30:
I don't think there is a remote possibility that carr will start over smith without injury. I am glad carr is a decent QB who can win games in smith's absence. Nate Davis has a much higher ceiling than carr and smith IMHO. Maybe smith will pull a balmer? Just kidding, I have to hope alex starts to perform at a high level.

But I am glad the niners have carr on the squad.

The funny part about that is sure, Carr is a guy that can win games with Smith's absence. But
with Smith IN we cannot win games. The Alexcuses keep rolling. 3rd stringers, no Gore, No
Crabs....etc. Carr and Davis both looked better, regardless of who they were playing against.

Davis looked better last pre-season, in fact he has looked better everytime he has played in games, pre-season, whatever. Unfortunate that terrible ownership and coaching decisions are
letting this season rest on an un-proven Smith.

The Smith supporters think that all of a sudden the regular season is going to come along and
Smith will be better. What is that based on for crying out loud?? He will be facing better
defenses and defensive schemes but all of a sudden the light will turn on and he will be a better
QB???

Carr and Davis both perform better and all of the hate directed at them is cowardly. Nobody
wants to admit that SMITH is GARBAGE. If Carr had to battle Smith in camp, no way Smith
wins. Smith couldn't even beat out Shawn Hill. I just don't understand the love affair for a whack
QB.

Cowardly? What a funny chap you are, to be sure.

As to the rest, it's all been said. Curiously, the professionals, those whose jobs depend on it, don't seem to agree with you.

Professionals??? Most of them think he's not a good QB..

Originally posted by fly15:

Originally posted by English:

Originally posted by ninerfan818:

Originally posted by fister30:
I don't think there is a remote possibility that carr will start over smith without injury. I am glad carr is a decent QB who can win games in smith's absence. Nate Davis has a much higher ceiling than carr and smith IMHO. Maybe smith will pull a balmer? Just kidding, I have to hope alex starts to perform at a high level.

But I am glad the niners have carr on the squad.

The funny part about that is sure, Carr is a guy that can win games with Smith's absence. But
with Smith IN we cannot win games. The Alexcuses keep rolling. 3rd stringers, no Gore, No
Crabs....etc. Carr and Davis both looked better, regardless of who they were playing against.

Davis looked better last pre-season, in fact he has looked better everytime he has played in games, pre-season, whatever. Unfortunate that terrible ownership and coaching decisions are
letting this season rest on an un-proven Smith.

The Smith supporters think that all of a sudden the regular season is going to come along and
Smith will be better. What is that based on for crying out loud?? He will be facing better
defenses and defensive schemes but all of a sudden the light will turn on and he will be a better
QB???

Carr and Davis both perform better and all of the hate directed at them is cowardly. Nobody
wants to admit that SMITH is GARBAGE. If Carr had to battle Smith in camp, no way Smith
wins. Smith couldn't even beat out Shawn Hill. I just don't understand the love affair for a whack
QB.

Cowardly? What a funny chap you are, to be sure.

As to the rest, it's all been said. Curiously, the professionals, those whose jobs depend on it, don't seem to agree with you.

Professionals??? Most of them think he's not a good QB..[ohlord]

Because i know it hurts to hear for some...but he isn't...ouch.

Originally posted by ninerfan818:

Originally posted by fly15:

Originally posted by English:

Originally posted by ninerfan818:

Originally posted by fister30:
I don't think there is a remote possibility that carr will start over smith without injury. I am glad carr is a decent QB who can win games in smith's absence. Nate Davis has a much higher ceiling than carr and smith IMHO. Maybe smith will pull a balmer? Just kidding, I have to hope alex starts to perform at a high level.

But I am glad the niners have carr on the squad.

The funny part about that is sure, Carr is a guy that can win games with Smith's absence. But
with Smith IN we cannot win games. The Alexcuses keep rolling. 3rd stringers, no Gore, No
Crabs....etc. Carr and Davis both looked better, regardless of who they were playing against.

Davis looked better last pre-season, in fact he has looked better everytime he has played in games, pre-season, whatever. Unfortunate that terrible ownership and coaching decisions are
letting this season rest on an un-proven Smith.

The Smith supporters think that all of a sudden the regular season is going to come along and
Smith will be better. What is that based on for crying out loud?? He will be facing better
defenses and defensive schemes but all of a sudden the light will turn on and he will be a better
QB???

Carr and Davis both perform better and all of the hate directed at them is cowardly. Nobody
wants to admit that SMITH is GARBAGE. If Carr had to battle Smith in camp, no way Smith
wins. Smith couldn't even beat out Shawn Hill. I just don't understand the love affair for a whack
QB.

Cowardly? What a funny chap you are, to be sure.

As to the rest, it's all been said. Curiously, the professionals, those whose jobs depend on it, don't seem to agree with you.

Professionals??? Most of them think he's not a good QB..[ohlord]

Because i know it hurts to hear for some...but he isn't...ouch.

Originally posted by fly15:

Originally posted by English:

Originally posted by ninerfan818:

Originally posted by fister30:
I don't think there is a remote possibility that carr will start over smith without injury. I am glad carr is a decent QB who can win games in smith's absence. Nate Davis has a much higher ceiling than carr and smith IMHO. Maybe smith will pull a balmer? Just kidding, I have to hope alex starts to perform at a high level.

But I am glad the niners have carr on the squad.

The funny part about that is sure, Carr is a guy that can win games with Smith's absence. But
with Smith IN we cannot win games. The Alexcuses keep rolling. 3rd stringers, no Gore, No
Crabs....etc. Carr and Davis both looked better, regardless of who they were playing against.

Davis looked better last pre-season, in fact he has looked better everytime he has played in games, pre-season, whatever. Unfortunate that terrible ownership and coaching decisions are
letting this season rest on an un-proven Smith.

The Smith supporters think that all of a sudden the regular season is going to come along and
Smith will be better. What is that based on for crying out loud?? He will be facing better
defenses and defensive schemes but all of a sudden the light will turn on and he will be a better
QB???

Carr and Davis both perform better and all of the hate directed at them is cowardly. Nobody
wants to admit that SMITH is GARBAGE. If Carr had to battle Smith in camp, no way Smith
wins. Smith couldn't even beat out Shawn Hill. I just don't understand the love affair for a whack
QB.

Cowardly? What a funny chap you are, to be sure.

As to the rest, it's all been said. Curiously, the professionals, those whose jobs depend on it, don't seem to agree with you.

Professionals??? Most of them think he's not a good QB..

That's why they keep picking him as starter is it? I am not talking about the hangers-on who blog. I am talking about the coaches. You think Singletary would choose him to start if he really was the worst of the three? And put his own career in jeopardy?

Originally posted by English:

Originally posted by fly15:

Originally posted by English:

Originally posted by ninerfan818:

Originally posted by fister30:
I don't think there is a remote possibility that carr will start over smith without injury. I am glad carr is a decent QB who can win games in smith's absence. Nate Davis has a much higher ceiling than carr and smith IMHO. Maybe smith will pull a balmer? Just kidding, I have to hope alex starts to perform at a high level.

But I am glad the niners have carr on the squad.

The funny part about that is sure, Carr is a guy that can win games with Smith's absence. But
with Smith IN we cannot win games. The Alexcuses keep rolling. 3rd stringers, no Gore, No
Crabs....etc. Carr and Davis both looked better, regardless of who they were playing against.

Davis looked better last pre-season, in fact he has looked better everytime he has played in games, pre-season, whatever. Unfortunate that terrible ownership and coaching decisions are
letting this season rest on an un-proven Smith.

The Smith supporters think that all of a sudden the regular season is going to come along and
Smith will be better. What is that based on for crying out loud?? He will be facing better
defenses and defensive schemes but all of a sudden the light will turn on and he will be a better
QB???

Carr and Davis both perform better and all of the hate directed at them is cowardly. Nobody
wants to admit that SMITH is GARBAGE. If Carr had to battle Smith in camp, no way Smith
wins. Smith couldn't even beat out Shawn Hill. I just don't understand the love affair for a whack
QB.

Cowardly? What a funny chap you are, to be sure.

As to the rest, it's all been said. Curiously, the professionals, those whose jobs depend on it, don't seem to agree with you.

Professionals??? Most of them think he's not a good QB..

That's why they keep picking him as starter is it? I am not talking about the hangers-on who blog. I am talking about the coaches. You think Singletary would choose him to start if he really was the worst of the three? And put his own career in jeopardy?

By the way, this is the D. Carr Caravan, right??

Originally posted by fly15:

Originally posted by English:

Originally posted by fly15:

Originally posted by English:

Originally posted by ninerfan818:

Originally posted by fister30:
I don't think there is a remote possibility that carr will start over smith without injury. I am glad carr is a decent QB who can win games in smith's absence. Nate Davis has a much higher ceiling than carr and smith IMHO. Maybe smith will pull a balmer? Just kidding, I have to hope alex starts to perform at a high level.

But I am glad the niners have carr on the squad.

The funny part about that is sure, Carr is a guy that can win games with Smith's absence. But
with Smith IN we cannot win games. The Alexcuses keep rolling. 3rd stringers, no Gore, No
Crabs....etc. Carr and Davis both looked better, regardless of who they were playing against.

Davis looked better last pre-season, in fact he has looked better everytime he has played in games, pre-season, whatever. Unfortunate that terrible ownership and coaching decisions are
letting this season rest on an un-proven Smith.

The Smith supporters think that all of a sudden the regular season is going to come along and
Smith will be better. What is that based on for crying out loud?? He will be facing better
defenses and defensive schemes but all of a sudden the light will turn on and he will be a better
QB???

Carr and Davis both perform better and all of the hate directed at them is cowardly. Nobody
wants to admit that SMITH is GARBAGE. If Carr had to battle Smith in camp, no way Smith
wins. Smith couldn't even beat out Shawn Hill. I just don't understand the love affair for a whack
QB.

Cowardly? What a funny chap you are, to be sure.

As to the rest, it's all been said. Curiously, the professionals, those whose jobs depend on it, don't seem to agree with
you.

Professionals??? Most of them think he's not a good QB..

That's why they keep picking him as starter is it? I am not talking about the hangers-on who blog. I am talking about the coaches. You think Singletary would choose him to start if he really was the worst of the three? And put his own career in jeopardy?

By the way, this is the D. Carr Caravan, right??

Funnily, I thought this was the 49ers web zone. Apparently not.

I am out of here. You carry on b***hing