Originally posted by cciowa:
lets not get to caught up in this blather. just play the game. no matter what one thinks of the rules they are there. if ck puts himself out there then he will get hit. thats football and every team tries to put a lick on the quarterback. look what we want to do with rogers. Jh is trying to get in the heads of the refs and of course as you recall with a couple of games last year when he tried to do that, it was a failure and all that came out of it was that he got outcoached and played by the rams coach
I thought that was with the Giants and Kevin Gilbride where they had the Justin Smith tay de tay and we got smacked in week 6. Its OK bro, Harbaugh has every right to get clarity on this issue. I too as a fan and as someone that loves defense and am against the coddling of the QB would like to know exactly when it is fair to treat the QB as a ballcarrier for all QBs and not just the athletic ones. I want to know if I can go for the knees of Brady, Mannings, Rodgers and Brees on a handoff like the one above or any handoff play action type play for that matter. If the QB keeps how do I know if he will run, pass or scramble to buy time to pass? I say that if the QB isn't retreating and a potential handoff has occurred then I should be able to attack him as a ballcarrier no matter if he is RG3 or Shaun Hill. Blow his a$$ up! I bet if all QBs are officiated the same with clarity there would be less of this talk for teams fearing for their own QBs health. I bet they get injured before Kap or Cam