Originally posted by Niners99:
lol so many embarrassing takes in this thread.
Calvin Johnson just got in. These voters actually get into a room and openly debate until they settle on a class. This isn't baseball where passive aggressive beta male writers use their secret vote like a weapon. People in the room will say "We just put Calvin Johnson in, so we cant use career length against Willis." It will be hard to justify keeping him out this year with such a weak class. He was the best MLB in the game during his career.
Willis quit in his prime on a good team and was exceptional at everything but never the best at any one thing and he quite after 7 years rather healthy. Johnson quite as his career was on a downward trajectory because of long term injuries sustained while exclusively playing on one of the worst teams in the NFL and he managed to set several all time records doing so, he also played 9 seasons.
Willis quitting as a healthy athlete with a short career is going to get held against him.