There are 238 users in the forums

Offseason All22 Film Study

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
Originally posted by thl408:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
Originally posted by ModestoNiner33:
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
yep, and he doesn't take false steps. he's always in position, so even though he isn't especially strong or big, his body is always between his defender and the hole.

How do you think he projects to the ZBS.

I think he'd (he'll ) do better in the ZBS than the power scheme we had the last 4 years. So will Staley, imo. Thomas is made for it, Davis ran it in college. Boone is a question mark, but if he struggles, Martin should be up to speed and Looney is MUCH better than general consensus, which was based on a dozen or so bad plays last year. You learn consistency through repetition, after all.

Spot on!

Without watching Kilgore in depth, I agree very much with what's said about Kilgore. He will not overpower anyone, but always has good positioning so that leverage is working for him. He seems to beat the defender to the spot, and uses leverage to hold the spot, that's sufficient to open holes in the run game. I trust WRATHman's assessment that it's his feet that allows him to do this.

Thanks, man. I had a great OL coach who always used to say, "If you can't put your man on his ass, then you work your ass into the hole." Kilgore's that guy who rarely gets a pancake, but almost always manages to work his ass into the hole. He's a tenacious technicial, imo.

Love it! So I recently came across a pic of M.Martin working out and it looks like he's slimmed down a lot. I'm wondering where his best fit would be if we do, in fact move to a ZBS. Thoughts?

To be honest, I don't think any of the interior positions are markedly different in a ZBS, from a physical perspective. There's not a lot of pulling, and the pulling that occurs rarely goes further than one man down the line. All three positions are equally likely to release to the second level, and all three positions have similar responsibilities in pass pro, though C seems to get to help out more frequently, while Gs usually have an immediate threat (that can change if either DT shifts, stunts, or slants, or if a LB blitzes). The main difference, imo, is that the Center is responsible for making calls and adjusting protection in the passing game. Coaches were pretty positive about Martin regarding that responsibility. In the run game, line calls should be made by the players combining to block a zone and echoed to everyone else, so C/G don't really have different responsibilities there.

So, I think he could do very well at both. I haven't seen him cut block, so if he stinks at that, he'd probably be better at center, since tackles and guards do the vast majority of backside cutting in a traditional zone scheme. We rarely cut on zone plays last year (Staley was the only guy I saw do it, and he did a GREAT job of providing a cutback lane), but all bets are off with this new staff. His "rookie strong" body was a liability last year, but that wouldn't be as big of a deal in a zone scheme, though better strength could help him anchor against a bull rush. I'm expecting him to be stronger this season, anyway.
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
Originally posted by thl408:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
Originally posted by ModestoNiner33:
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
yep, and he doesn't take false steps. he's always in position, so even though he isn't especially strong or big, his body is always between his defender and the hole.

How do you think he projects to the ZBS.

I think he'd (he'll ) do better in the ZBS than the power scheme we had the last 4 years. So will Staley, imo. Thomas is made for it, Davis ran it in college. Boone is a question mark, but if he struggles, Martin should be up to speed and Looney is MUCH better than general consensus, which was based on a dozen or so bad plays last year. You learn consistency through repetition, after all.

Spot on!

Without watching Kilgore in depth, I agree very much with what's said about Kilgore. He will not overpower anyone, but always has good positioning so that leverage is working for him. He seems to beat the defender to the spot, and uses leverage to hold the spot, that's sufficient to open holes in the run game. I trust WRATHman's assessment that it's his feet that allows him to do this.

Thanks, man. I had a great OL coach who always used to say, "If you can't put your man on his ass, then you work your ass into the hole." Kilgore's that guy who rarely gets a pancake, but almost always manages to work his ass into the hole. He's a tenacious technicial, imo.

Love it! So I recently came across a pic of M.Martin working out and it looks like he's slimmed down a lot. I'm wondering where his best fit would be if we do, in fact move to a ZBS. Thoughts?

To be honest, I don't think any of the interior positions are markedly different in a ZBS, from a physical perspective. There's not a lot of pulling, and the pulling that occurs rarely goes further than one man down the line. All three positions are equally likely to release to the second level, and all three positions have similar responsibilities in pass pro, though C seems to get to help out more frequently, while Gs usually have an immediate threat (that can change if either DT shifts, stunts, or slants, or if a LB blitzes). The main difference, imo, is that the Center is responsible for making calls and adjusting protection in the passing game. Coaches were pretty positive about Martin regarding that responsibility. In the run game, line calls should be made by the players combining to block a zone and echoed to everyone else, so C/G don't really have different responsibilities there.

So, I think he could do very well at both. I haven't seen him cut block, so if he stinks at that, he'd probably be better at center, since tackles and guards do the vast majority of backside cutting in a traditional zone scheme. We rarely cut on zone plays last year (Staley was the only guy I saw do it, and he did a GREAT job of providing a cutback lane), but all bets are off with this new staff. His "rookie strong" body was a liability last year, but that wouldn't be as big of a deal in a zone scheme, though better strength could help him anchor against a bull rush. I'm expecting him to be stronger this season, anyway.

Excellent breakdown. So based on the personnel today, what would be your ideal lineup?
Originally posted by NCommand:
Excellent breakdown. So based on the personnel today, what would be your ideal lineup?

If we go ZBS? gonna make some people mad here...

Staley, Martin, Kilgore, Thomas, Davis

My reasoning is that Boone hasn't shown yet that he can maintain competetive pad level while working laterally, so he could be a liability on run plays. Based solely on his college footage at LT, I think Thomas is the stronger pass blocker than Martin, so he gets the side that would feature a 3-technique more freguently, and he can occassionally help Davis from the inside, which would allow Davis to set further outside, where he often gets beat.
Originally posted by TheRathman44:
This is why I think Jaelen Strong is a perfect fit for this offense. He bails his QB out a TON.

DGB.....
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Excellent breakdown. So based on the personnel today, what would be your ideal lineup?

If we go ZBS? gonna make some people mad here...

Staley, Martin, Kilgore, Thomas, Davis

My reasoning is that Boone hasn't shown yet that he can maintain competetive pad level while working laterally, so he could be a liability on run plays. Based solely on his college footage at LT, I think Thomas is the stronger pass blocker than Martin, so he gets the side that would feature a 3-technique more freguently, and he can occassionally help Davis from the inside, which would allow Davis to set further outside, where he often gets beat.

Outstanding. I had called for Staley to move to RT as he ages but if we go ZBS, like you said, he's the man on the backside of many of these runs who can cut block like a mad man and leave gaping holes there for Hyde/Hunter/Bush. So it's not as critical he moves with age. And we all know Davis is strong on that strong side. This makes sense. Boone is best served as a T in my mind anyhow.
Originally posted by defenderDX:
Originally posted by TheRathman44:
This is why I think Jaelen Strong is a perfect fit for this offense. He bails his QB out a TON.

DGB.....

That too!
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by defenderDX:
Originally posted by TheRathman44:
This is why I think Jaelen Strong is a perfect fit for this offense. He bails his QB out a TON.

DGB.....

That too!

I'm a total homer for that dude right now lol. But we'll see!
  • ptw1
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 347
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Excellent breakdown. So based on the personnel today, what would be your ideal lineup?

If we go ZBS? gonna make some people mad here...

Staley, Martin, Kilgore, Thomas, Davis

My reasoning is that Boone hasn't shown yet that he can maintain competetive pad level while working laterally, so he could be a liability on run plays. Based solely on his college footage at LT, I think Thomas is the stronger pass blocker than Martin, so he gets the side that would feature a 3-technique more freguently, and he can occassionally help Davis from the inside, which would allow Davis to set further outside, where he often gets beat.

wow, interesting. I wonder if they are going to a ZBS if they would trade Boone before/during the draft. I'm sure some, if not most, teams look at him as a Tackle which would def increase his trade value.
Originally posted by defenderDX:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by defenderDX:
Originally posted by TheRathman44:
This is why I think Jaelen Strong is a perfect fit for this offense. He bails his QB out a TON.

DGB.....

That too!

I'm a total homer for that dude right now lol. But we'll see!

So is CK!
Originally posted by ptw1:
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Excellent breakdown. So based on the personnel today, what would be your ideal lineup?

If we go ZBS? gonna make some people mad here...

Staley, Martin, Kilgore, Thomas, Davis

My reasoning is that Boone hasn't shown yet that he can maintain competetive pad level while working laterally, so he could be a liability on run plays. Based solely on his college footage at LT, I think Thomas is the stronger pass blocker than Martin, so he gets the side that would feature a 3-technique more freguently, and he can occassionally help Davis from the inside, which would allow Davis to set further outside, where he often gets beat.

wow, interesting. I wonder if they are going to a ZBS if they would trade Boone before/during the draft. I'm sure some, if not most, teams look at him as a Tackle which would def increase his trade value.

I'd keep him as a VAST improvement over JMart as the swing tackle. Yeah, he'll be pissed off, but that guy's on my permanent sh!t list after last year, so he can suck it.
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by defenderDX:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by defenderDX:
Originally posted by TheRathman44:
This is why I think Jaelen Strong is a perfect fit for this offense. He bails his QB out a TON.

DGB.....

That too!

I'm a total homer for that dude right now lol. But we'll see!

So is CK!

Is there actual news about this? I know the've been working out together in AZ, but I haven't heard any comments from Kap about the guys he's been woring with (should have serious insight on Strong, DGB, and White, though).
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by defenderDX:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by defenderDX:
Originally posted by TheRathman44:
This is why I think Jaelen Strong is a perfect fit for this offense. He bails his QB out a TON.

DGB.....

That too!

I'm a total homer for that dude right now lol. But we'll see!

So is CK!

Is there actual news about this? I know the've been working out together in AZ, but I haven't heard any comments from Kap about the guys he's been woring with (should have serious insight on Strong, DGB, and White, though).

IIRC, the video he posted of he and DGB working out said something to the fact of, "Sign this guy." Or it alluded to the idea that CK really liked him. I can't speak to the others. Of course he really liked Lockette too. LOL
Originally posted by NCommand:
IIRC, the video he posted of he and DGB working out said something to the fact of, "Sign this guy." Or it alluded to the idea that CK really liked him. I can't speak to the others. Of course he really liked Lockette too. LOL

ugh. Good perspective.
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
Originally posted by NCommand:
IIRC, the video he posted of he and DGB working out said something to the fact of, "Sign this guy." Or it alluded to the idea that CK really liked him. I can't speak to the others. Of course he really liked Lockette too. LOL

ugh. Good perspective.

TBF, I'm sure Lockette would have done just fine with us if we utilized him esp. with the chemistry he and CK had together. But...that's another topic.
General question about Bowman/Willis:
what were the roles of both of them most of the time? I could swear that Bowman was more of a coverage guy whereas Willis was looking to stop the run in the first place????
Share 49ersWebzone