Originally posted by thl408:
Originally posted by Adusoron:
Thl408, I noticed that in your clips above that Reid was the lurking safety or intermediate safety and Bethea was the deep single high safety. Is this a coincidence from a small sample size or does this happen a lot? Given that Reid is the FS and runs a high 4.4 you would think he's the single high safety, not Bethea.
They interchanged quite often when talking about which of the two played as the single high safety in cover1, as well as who stayed in the deep middle when in a cover3 shell. If I had to put a number on it, I'd say 60% of the time it was Bethea playing as the deep safety - so it's really close and I wouldn't be surprised if I was wrong with that guess and it was actually flipped.
I agree that Reid is the more athletic of the two, and it seems to make more sense to have Reid play the single high, but Bethea can manage as the deep safety because I feel he does two things that make up for his lesser speed. He is very good at play recognition and pursuit angles. This results in running in straight lines and very little wasted steps. All the veteran savvy allows him to get away with being a bit on the slow side when talking about pure athleticism.
Your estimation is pretty spot on. I addressed that same question a while back during the 2013 season with Reid and Whitner. A lot of it has to do with where the opposing team lines up the strength of the formation. Our safeties don't really switch sides of the field. Fangio liked to have mirror players across the board so that if there were shifts in the defense guys weren't running over each other trying to switch sides - they could always stay face up and square to the LOS as the offensive shifted and motioned. So, if the TE was on the side of the S that safety, really, became the SS. It wasn't as much a matter of the coaches calling for one player to be the deep safety more than another, it was more how the offensive formation determined it. Either way, they both play very well in either spot.
[ Edited by jonnydel on Apr 1, 2015 at 12:37 PM ]