There are 118 users in the forums

Joe Montana Legacy Secured

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by Niners99:
"Bird is da greatest of all time. Ted Williams is da greatest of all time. Tauwmm Brady is da greatest of all time. Babby Ohhh is da greatest of all time."

Screw Boston and all their titles. They pouted for decades about the Red Sox and Patriots, even after multiple Celtics dynasties. Then they have this last 15 year run. The babies got their bottle.

I grew up in NYC, Boston fans were considered aliens from another planet.
Originally posted by VaBeachNiner:
Lol the Boston sports talk radio guy criticizing Montana. Michael Felger is the same Boston douchebag reporter that criticized Al Horford for leaving the Celtics for 1 day to be with his wife and the birth of their 2nd child.

f**k that guy.

Obnoxious dork. Talk about no class.
  • LVJay
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 27,847


Eats c*ck

Originally posted by LVJay:
Ok, I'm still waiting... where are the "240 pound DL" guys you always mention about? So far I just see a bunch of Linebackers (LB) averaging 235 lb.

It's another attempt to circle jerk us into oblivion L0L

you mean DEs. there were many DEs who were 240 range. yours truly fred dean was 230lb. he was 6ft 3 too.
Originally posted by Niners99:
Boston sports fans and media lost their credibility a long time ago. They declare all their greats "the best", even before its a legit argument.

This radio host calling Montana "classless" for saying you cant pick a GOAT with all the different era's, is an idiot.

Funny how they never acknowledge that if on two plays, the Seahawks run on 2nd & goal, and Devonte Freeman picks up that block, Tom Brady has 3 rings and 2 SB mvp's.

You can debate whether Brady was gifted a Falcons collapse, but there is ZERO debate that Seattle handed over his 4th ring on a silver platter.

The way Brady won his titles and SB MVP's just doesn't sit right with me. I cant call him the greatest. Great player, seems like a great guy. Hes just not Joe. He made mistakes in the biggest moments. Joe didnt. He lost the biggest game, twice. Joe didn't. He needed his kicker to finish the job 3 times. Joe slaughtered Marino and Elway. He led the drive against Cincy. Brady lucked into a ring when Seattle choked. Brady played a garbage 2.5 quarters and rallied back on a Falcons choke job.

The Patriots SB MVP in 2001 was Adam Vinatieri. Their SB MVP in 2014 was Malcom Butler. Their SB MVP in 2016 was James White. Sorry, but just defaulting MVP to the QB doesn't make him the best ever.

History will only look at results, but Brady and Montana werent the same caliber of SB performer. Its just the truth.


Originally posted by Niners99:
"Bird is da greatest of all time. Ted Williams is da greatest of all time. Tauwmm Brady is da greatest of all time. Babby Ohhh is da greatest of all time."

Screw Boston and all their titles. They pouted for decades about the Red Sox and Patriots, even after multiple Celtics dynasties. Then they have this last 15 year run. The babies got their bottle.

no sane person would ever call bird the greatest. i don't ever recall boston fans saying bird is the greatest. but many of them will say bill russell was the greatest. and russell does have a legitimate argument.

but MJ is the GOAT for me. not even debatable.

honestly, you guys were exactly like the boston fans. come on man. i endured you guys for all my life. dynasty bring out the worst in all of us. all of the major dynasty had some really really awful fan base. only the spurs have respectful fan base. maybe because they are small timers, not big cities like boston
Originally posted by Niners99:
Boston sports fans and media lost their credibility a long time ago. They declare all their greats "the best", even before its a legit argument.

This radio host calling Montana "classless" for saying you cant pick a GOAT with all the different era's, is an idiot.

Funny how they never acknowledge that if on two plays, the Seahawks run on 2nd & goal, and Devonte Freeman picks up that block, Tom Brady has 3 rings and 2 SB mvp's.

You can debate whether Brady was gifted a Falcons collapse, but there is ZERO debate that Seattle handed over his 4th ring on a silver platter.

The way Brady won his titles and SB MVP's just doesn't sit right with me. I cant call him the greatest. Great player, seems like a great guy. Hes just not Joe. He made mistakes in the biggest moments. Joe didnt. He lost the biggest game, twice. Joe didn't. He needed his kicker to finish the job 3 times. Joe slaughtered Marino and Elway. He led the drive against Cincy. Brady lucked into a ring when Seattle choked. Brady played a garbage 2.5 quarters and rallied back on a Falcons choke job.

The Patriots SB MVP in 2001 was Adam Vinatieri. Their SB MVP in 2014 was Malcom Butler. Their SB MVP in 2016 was James White. Sorry, but just defaulting MVP to the QB doesn't make him the best ever.

History will only look at results, but Brady and Montana werent the same caliber of SB performer. Its just the truth.

history will remember 7SB apperances and 5SB wins. nobody is perfect. if Joe was perfect then he should've been 23-0 in the playoffs. but he did lose games even with the loaded talent he had around him. it's unrealistic for anyone to be 7-0 in the SBs in the non salary cap era.
[ Edited by natediaz on Feb 16, 2017 at 4:34 PM ]
Originally posted by RishikeshA:
I grew up in NYC, Boston fans were considered aliens from another planet.

IMO late 90's yankees fans were the worst of them all.

worst fans ranking in my life time

1. yankees fans in 90s
2. cowboys fans in 90s
3. pats fans in 10s
4. niners fans in 90s
5. steelers fans in general

i don't think seattle sports in general don't breed worst kinds. don't mistake us from being loud 12th man. we are like the happiest bunch.
[ Edited by natediaz on Feb 16, 2017 at 4:47 PM ]
Stop with the loaded teams. They werent all loaded.
Originally posted by VaBeachNiner:
Lol the Boston sports talk radio guy criticizing Montana. Michael Felger is the same Boston douchebag reporter that criticized Al Horford for leaving the Celtics for 1 day to be with his wife and the birth of their 2nd child.

f**k that guy.

That guy thinks Montana has no class? Brady said himself Joe is in a league of his own. It's like comparing apples and oranges. That sports talk host needs to f**k the f**king hell off. Such a giant douche.
Originally posted by natediaz:
Originally posted by Niners99:
Boston sports fans and media lost their credibility a long time ago. They declare all their greats "the best", even before its a legit argument.

This radio host calling Montana "classless" for saying you cant pick a GOAT with all the different era's, is an idiot.

Funny how they never acknowledge that if on two plays, the Seahawks run on 2nd & goal, and Devonte Freeman picks up that block, Tom Brady has 3 rings and 2 SB mvp's.

You can debate whether Brady was gifted a Falcons collapse, but there is ZERO debate that Seattle handed over his 4th ring on a silver platter.

The way Brady won his titles and SB MVP's just doesn't sit right with me. I cant call him the greatest. Great player, seems like a great guy. Hes just not Joe. He made mistakes in the biggest moments. Joe didnt. He lost the biggest game, twice. Joe didn't. He needed his kicker to finish the job 3 times. Joe slaughtered Marino and Elway. He led the drive against Cincy. Brady lucked into a ring when Seattle choked. Brady played a garbage 2.5 quarters and rallied back on a Falcons choke job.

The Patriots SB MVP in 2001 was Adam Vinatieri. Their SB MVP in 2014 was Malcom Butler. Their SB MVP in 2016 was James White. Sorry, but just defaulting MVP to the QB doesn't make him the best ever.

History will only look at results, but Brady and Montana werent the same caliber of SB performer. Its just the truth.


Originally posted by Niners99:
"Bird is da greatest of all time. Ted Williams is da greatest of all time. Tauwmm Brady is da greatest of all time. Babby Ohhh is da greatest of all time."

Screw Boston and all their titles. They pouted for decades about the Red Sox and Patriots, even after multiple Celtics dynasties. Then they have this last 15 year run. The babies got their bottle.

no sane person would ever call bird the greatest. i don't ever recall boston fans saying bird is the greatest. but many of them will say bill russell was the greatest. and russell does have a legitimate argument.

but MJ is the GOAT for me. not even debatable.

honestly, you guys were exactly like the boston fans. come on man. i endured you guys for all my life. dynasty bring out the worst in all of us. all of the major dynasty had some really really awful fan base. only the spurs have respectful fan base. maybe because they are small timers, not big cities like boston

What would we do without this Seahawks fan telling us how bad of a fanbase we are?
First he tells us how he is just here to help us realize that Joe isn't that great and now this, we are so lucky to have Nate looking out for us.
Originally posted by ninerjok:
Originally posted by VaBeachNiner:
Lol the Boston sports talk radio guy criticizing Montana. Michael Felger is the same Boston douchebag reporter that criticized Al Horford for leaving the Celtics for 1 day to be with his wife and the birth of their 2nd child.

f**k that guy.

That guy thinks Montana has no class? Brady said himself Joe is in a league of his own. It's like comparing apples and oranges. That sports talk host needs to f**k the f**king hell off. Such a giant douche.

He is the worst. he also spread runors ont he air that Heidi Watney having an affair with Varitek. A sexist attack on a femal member of the media and he was trying to harm Varitek's marriage. He should have gotten his *** beat twice for that one.
Originally posted by natediaz:
Originally posted by RishikeshA:
I grew up in NYC, Boston fans were considered aliens from another planet.

IMO late 90's yankees fans were the worst of them all.

worst fans ranking in my life time

1. yankees fans in 90s
2. cowboys fans in 90s
3. pats fans in 10s
4. niners fans in 90s
5. steelers fans in general

i don't think seattle sports in general don't breed worst kinds. don't mistake us from being loud 12th man. we are like the happiest bunch.

You lost all credibility by saying Seahawks fans aren't obnoxious. They have been the biggest chest thumping, classless winners in all of sports that I can remember.

The fans have taken on the personality of Richard Sherman and his cockiness. We're talking about fans who threw popcorn on Bowman as he was being carted off with his leg injury, and then joked all over social media saying "NaVorro Bowleg".
Originally posted by natediaz:
history will remember 7SB apperances and 5SB wins. nobody is perfect. if Joe was perfect then he should've been 23-0 in the playoffs. but he did lose games even with the loaded talent he had around him. it's unrealistic for anyone to be 7-0 in the SBs in the non salary cap era.

Compare the 9 years since they won their first SB:

Montana '81 - '90: 4-0
Brady '01 - '10 - 3-1

Playoff One and dones:

Montana - 3
Brady - 2

Why do I stop at 9 years? Because that was when Montana last started for the 49ers.

If you follow football, you would know why that is.

If not, let's just say that nobody survives losing a job to injury for 2 full seasons.....esp. when you have a big talent to replace you.

It took Brady more than 5 super bowls to break all of Montana's Super Bowl records, and postseason passing records.

Essentially, Brady was a similar caliber player that outlasted Montana. Credit to him, can't take that away from him.

But it's an essential fact that needs to be brought up because nobody was touting Brady as better than Montana back in '07 (maybe if the pats BEAT the giants they could have had the talk).

2008 misses 15 games.
2009 one and done brutal home loss against Baltimore, 33-14?
2010 one and done home loss against the Sanchez led Jets, about a month after blowing them out

2011 you could argue that the Ravens choked....didn't the guy drop a surefire TD at the end? I forgot the exact details but the Pats escaped winning, and Brady admitted he played like crap in that game.

Then proceed to lose another SB to the Giants. Maybe Welker is to blame for the pass....but still. I think if you are the UNDENIABLE BEST EVER QB OF ALL TIME YOU BEAT THE S***** WILDCARD GIANTS AT LEAST ONCE?? TOO MUCH TO ASK??

Sorry, I couldn't say that quietly.

2012 outgunned/stomped by Baltimore. Seems like elite Ds can have Patriots # in the playoffs.
2013 nice job of leading nobodies far enough to get spanked in the championship game. This was a vintage Peyton Manning effort....
2014 nice job of winning this game. I won't go into the whole Lynch thing because of the Kearse catch.
2015 Donkeys D smashed him. He lost to the worst ever Peyton Manning . Almost embarrassing.
2016 No need to repeat what others said. Great clutchness, but this game should have been a 31-28 final ...an L any way you look at it. There will be no game like this in Montana's memory to compare.

Montana in '93 and '94 at an older PHYSICAL/BATTERED age than Brady is now did some really cool things. Unfortunately for KC, Buffalo was the AFC team of the '90s.

FOH with the automatic Brady > Montana.
  • Homer
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 998
Originally posted by natediaz:
IMO late 90's yankees fans were the worst of them all.

worst fans ranking in my life time

1. yankees fans in 90s
2. cowboys fans in 90s
3. pats fans in 10s
4. niners fans in 90s
5. steelers fans in general

i don't think seattle sports in general don't breed worst kinds. don't mistake us from being loud 12th man. we are like the happiest bunch.

where do you live? I'm a warriors fan and think we belong on the list. I think dubs and Seahawks are the worst in recent times. I mean, pats? Really?
Originally posted by Homer:
Originally posted by natediaz:
IMO late 90's yankees fans were the worst of them all.

worst fans ranking in my life time

1. yankees fans in 90s
2. cowboys fans in 90s
3. pats fans in 10s
4. niners fans in 90s
5. steelers fans in general

i don't think seattle sports in general don't breed worst kinds. don't mistake us from being loud 12th man. we are like the happiest bunch.

where do you live? I'm a warriors fan and think we belong on the list. I think dubs and Seahawks are the worst in recent times. I mean, pats? Really?

Warrior fans showed up in droves for years while the team was totally hopeless. The arena in Oakland never looked like Levis these past two years. The fans have been knowledgeable and engaged for years. How long have you been a fan?
Search Share 49ersWebzone