Joe Montana Legacy Secured

Originally posted by NinerGM:

Originally posted by PatrickWillisHOF:

People still think Montana is better than Brady????

Brady is going to his EIGHTH super bowl. That is four more than Montana. Absolutely insane...

Different ERA of football. And if there's one thing I've learned about this debate for ALL QBs throughout the history of the NFL, comparing achievements from different eras when the game was different is pointless. Just can't compare eras with "numbers".

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by jcs:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
At lasting longer due to the rule changes

This has already been addressed plenty of times.

Montana getting injured on plays that are legal today doesn't mean he would've been playing for 15+ years with today's rules.

Brady has taken bigger shots from bigger players and continued to play. And Brady's durability is in large part due to his own training and ability to move in the pocket and adjust protection so he doesn't get hit as much.

The idea that Joe would miraculously stay healthy with these new rules is silly and flawed.

Not to mention Brady played several years before the rules were changed to really favor offenses. And there's the fact players can still hit someone illegally and injure them with the new rules. It's not like those rules being in place physically make it impossible for QBs to get hit a certain way.

+ Show all quotes lol, TB has never taken a hit as bad Montana received during normal games

Sad that you discredit the rules having any effect when the rules were placed to protect QB and WRs

Brady missed a year because of a hit.

no way

Originally posted by tohara3:

amazing when you think of it like that

Originally posted by maximusdecimus:
Put brady in montana era. He doesn't last 4 seasons.

Put joe's niners in the patriots division the last 12 years with todays rules. Do the niners lose a super bowl?

Jerry Rice in todays NFL? Joe with todays rules? UNSTOPPABLE.

Originally posted by maximusdecimus:
Watch how Montaná was treated. It's called YOU TUBE.

Originally posted by okdkid:
Why are we still debating this?

It's okay to love Joe Montana and still know Brady is the GOAT. It doesn't make you less of a Niners fan. The arguments against Brady are just stupid at this point. How many freaking Super Bowl appearances (and wins) will it take? 10? 15? Just admit that there is nothing Brady can do to overcome your fan bias and leave it be.

Originally posted by JimA49ers:
Seems as there were teams back then were also tougher, and feared. Steel Curtain, Purple People Eaters, Orange Crush, etc. No teams have that now, and it seems it's anyone's league. Point being, Montana played in a much tougher era.