Joe Montana Legacy Secured

Montana doesnt lose superbowls and doesnt throw picks in superbowls. Still the GOAT. Same reason LeBron will never be Jordan

if you have to undergo a surgical operation, which surgeon would you choose?
One that in 4 operations, the patient is healed every time, or else a surgeon who in 8 operations, 3 times the patient died

Originally posted by babarvaart:

Originally posted by Janitor:

Where do those percentages come from?

Montana played 10 full seasons, Brady has played 16 full seasons.

4/10 = 40%
5/16 = 31%

We did the math before. Winning four and losing zero is much more rare than winning five and losing three. Much more.

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:

Originally posted by babarvaart:

Originally posted by Janitor:
Where do those percentages come from?

Montana played 10 full seasons, Brady has played 16 full seasons.

4/10 = 40%
5/16 = 31%

We did the math before. Winning four and losing zero is much more rare than winning five and losing three. Much more.

Actually winning 5 has only been done 1 time. 1 time only in all history by 1 very special person only. LOL.....

Originally posted by Magic16:

if you have to undergo a surgical operation, which surgeon would you choose?
One that in 4 operations, the patient is healed every time, or else a surgeon who in 8 operations, 3 times the patient died

Haha. Clever

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:

Originally posted by babarvaart:

Originally posted by Janitor:

Where do those percentages come from?

Montana played 10 full seasons, Brady has played 16 full seasons.

4/10 = 40%
5/16 = 31%

We did the math before. Winning four and losing zero is much more rare than winning five and losing three. Much more.

Actually winning 5 has only been done 1 time. 1 time only in all history by 1 very special person only. LOL.....

Lol. Have you taken a probability and statistics course lately? LOL

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Actually winning 5 has only been done 1 time. 1 time only in all history by 1 very special person only. LOL.....

Charles Haley.

Originally posted by LVJay:
#OneShot #OneKill #OneChance to win the big game... you go with the guy who doesn't choke #SuperBowlGoatMontana...Joe would never turn the ball over in the biggest game, he proved that to the world #FACT

Joe never went into the big game with inferior teams. You can't say Joe doesn't lose/doesn't turn the ball over in the big game when he has done so earlier in the playoffs where he can't get to the big game.

Yes the Superbowl is the biggest game of the year but if you don't win your playoff games earlier you don't get to play in the Superbowl!

If anything you can make the case that the NFC was much stronger so him getting to the SB allowed him to play against inferior teams.

And if you want to say Montana played better in Superbowls that's fine but don't say Brady choked because that's ridiculous.

Brady had 2:21 with 1 timeout to score a TD. Holding him responsible for that fumble and saying he choked when the Pats never punted and he led them to 4 straight TD drives before that drive is sheer stupidity.

Originally posted by Magic16:
if you have to undergo a surgical operation, which surgeon would you choose?
One that in 4 operations, the patient is healed every time, or else a surgeon who in 8 operations, 3 times the patient died

Great analogy...if we forget that you don't just get scheduled for the Superbowl like you do for an operation.

You have to get there. It would like if the first doctor had his patient die 4 times in pre-op due to a misdiagnosis.

I'd take my odds with the second surgeon in that case. Can't have a chance at a successful surgery if you're dying before you get onto the operating table.

Originally posted by Mankster:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Actually winning 5 has only been done 1 time. 1 time only in all history by 1 very special person only. LOL.....

Charles Haley.

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by LVJay:

#OneShot #OneKill #OneChance to win the big game... you go with the guy who doesn't choke #SuperBowlGoatMontana...Joe would never turn the ball over in the biggest game, he proved that to the world #FACT

Joe never went into the big game with inferior teams. You can't say Joe doesn't lose/doesn't turn the ball over in the big game when he has done so earlier in the playoffs where he can't get to the big game.

Yes the Superbowl is the biggest game of the year but if you don't win your playoff games earlier you don't get to play in the Superbowl!

If anything you can make the case that the NFC was much stronger so him getting to the SB allowed him to play against inferior teams.

And if you want to say Montana played better in Superbowls that's fine but don't say Brady choked because that's ridiculous.

Brady had 2:21 with 1 timeout to score a TD. Holding him responsible for that fumble and saying he choked when the Pats never punted and he led them to 4 straight TD drives before that drive is sheer stupidity.

He had all the time in the world to drive down the field and instead he coughed up the ball.
That is a fact. Don't get mad about it.

True for the super bowl. But otto graham took the browns to 9 straight championship games. Won 7. Playing without a facemask. Or uggs.

Originally posted by Mankster:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Actually winning 5 has only been done 1 time. 1 time only in all history by 1 very special person only. LOL.....

Charles Haley.

Haley > Brady

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:

True for the super bowl. But otto graham took the browns to 9 straight championship games. Won 7. Playing without a facemask. Or uggs.

LOL@Uggs

Graham > Brady

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by Magic16:

if you have to undergo a surgical operation, which surgeon would you choose?
One that in 4 operations, the patient is healed every time, or else a surgeon who in 8 operations, 3 times the patient died

Great analogy...if we forget that you don't just get scheduled for the Superbowl like you do for an operation.

You have to get there. It would like if the first doctor had his patient die 4 times in pre-op due to a misdiagnosis.

I'd take my odds with the second surgeon in that case. Can't have a chance at a successful surgery if you're dying before you get onto the operating table.

Well if you are going to bring that up you may want to bring up the 8 pre op deaths the 2nd surgeon had coupled with the 3 surgery deaths he had