Joe Montana Legacy Secured

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by 9moon:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by 9moon:
how ever do you want it.. . how ever do you need it..

just vision the two and pick who you would rather have..

but in case you need it, here, you currently have JACKSONVILLE JAGUARS as your team right now.. and you need a QB...

WHO WOULD U RATHER HAVE.. JOE OR TOM..

Out of those 2 I'll take Joe cause I have homerism and biast. But if I could take any QB I would take Dan Marino.

U really think Dan Marino is the best of all time?

Yes. I think championships are overvalued when ranking 1 player on a 53 man team sport. It's the most important position but playoffs is about the best team.

Dan had insane talent, but I'd argue that John Elway was better. His talent also took his team further. I'd argue that it isn't always about being the best team in the playoffs. So many things go into that. Either way, Dan Marino deserves to be a part of the argument, but I'd still put Joe Montana on top. I've always been impressed by guys who didn't win the DNA lottery, but were able to elevate themselves beyond what you think they could be.

Originally posted by JimA49ers:

Originally posted by PatrickWillisHOF:
Tom Brady playoff records
Most wins
Most touchdowns
Most passing yards
Most completions
Most conference championships

He has as many rings as Montana. Brady is the best ever.

You forgot some:

Most court appearances.
Most rules named after themselves.
Most penalties called against opponents defense because of crying to the refs.
Most games actually won by the kicker, than actual QB performance.
Most superbowls won by boneheaded decision of opponents coaching staff.

Most QB suspensions!

Any of you actually been to the HOF? Brady already has jersey's and rings there, lol. He ain't mad atcha.

if there was ever a Mount Rushmore of QB, below are the ones I would really place up there..

JOE MONTANA - Super Bowl explains it all about him.. Ken Anderson was the more ready.. Dan Marino and his record setting year... Boomer was the League MVP.. Broncos and their #1 defense.. AND all bow-down to JOE after the game..

JOHN ELWAY - the 2 year he won the Super Bowl were the years he didn't need to carry his team.. Never was there a QB who carried a mediocare team and took them to those Super Bowls all by himself.

DAN MARINO - he was responsible in revolutionizing the passing game. His early success (2nd year) is the main reason why younger QBs coming out of college had to win early or be a bust.

TOM BRADY - most sees him as the closest to Joe. who can argue that he's the Ultimate Winner !!

Originally posted by SoCold:
Any of you actually been to the HOF? Brady already has jersey's and rings there, lol. He ain't mad atcha.

Originally posted by 9moon:
if there was ever a Mount Rushmore of QB, below are the ones I would really place up there..

JOE MONTANA - Super Bowl explains it all about him.. Ken Anderson was the more ready.. Dan Marino and his record setting year... Boomer was the League MVP.. Broncos and their #1 defense.. AND all bow-down to JOE after the game..

JOHN ELWAY - the 2 year he won the Super Bowl were the years he didn't need to carry his team.. Never was there a QB who carried a mediocare team and took them to those Super Bowls all by himself. Terell Davis was the reason they won, not Elway

DAN MARINO - he was responsible in revolutionizing the passing game. His early success (2nd year) is the main reason why younger QBs coming out of college had to win early or be a bust.

TOM BRADY - most sees him as the closest to Joe. who can argue that he's the Ultimate Winner !! You are comparing Gold to Fools Gold

FIFY

uhmmmm.... was I not clear when I posted, THE TWO YEARS ELWAY WON THE SUPER BOWL, WAS THE YEARS HE DID NOT CARRY THE TEAM...

Originally posted by 9moon:

uhmmmm.... was I not clear when I posted, THE TWO YEARS ELWAY WON THE SUPER BOWL, WAS THE YEARS HE DID NOT CARRY THE TEAM...

I would take Peyton Manning over Elway. Elways was good but the way Manning changed the game with LoS changes needs to be recognized. But then imagine the vandalism on mannings giant forehead

https://youtu.be/-32QWdccW4E
Came across this awesome video last night. Brady is the only one close and due to all the cheating allegations he'll never be as great as Joe cool.

Montana will forever be undefeated in super bowl.
Brady will not.
End of discussion.

Originally posted by 16to804ever:

Montana will forever be undefeated in super bowl.
Brady will not.
End of discussion.

Just like people trying to compare lebron to mj.
No discussion.

Different eras, different rules, apples and oranges.

Brady is the best ever.

Brady > Montana

Its time for evey Niner fan to accept it

Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Brady > Montana

Its time for evey Niner fan to accept it

Could be true. Maybe not. Different Eras with different rules.

I think it is safe to say Patriots > 49ers Organization long term.. Kraft = DeBartolo. Kraft >>>>>>>> Yorks. (In case you weren't aware)