Originally posted by the_dynasty:
amen to this. a big part of a reason why our D has been able to do this was sure tackling and elite talent at linebacker, as well as dline+olbs could put pressure with 3/4 man rush
like you've said, that defense challenged the qbs to put together sustainable drives by doing short passes. a qb with high iq could pick this d apart, like peyton did last year. however with non-elite or average qbs, that D was really hard to play against because we'd drop 7-8 in coverage and also generate pass pressure. the inability of teams to run on us made most of them one-dimensional, and then ability to drop 7 or 8 in coverage made them one-dimensional by taking away big plays.
it was the definition of bend not break. sometimes teams would put together big drives only to waste a down on running the ball and another short pass on third down would be short, or a short pass would be sniffed out by good tackling cbs like rogers or our stud lbs and brought down before the sticks.
the thing is, I liked it, but I actually think it doesnt work without elite talent. a huge chunk of that D goes out of the window if run-stopping is mediocre. no longer can we drop a ton of players in coverage without paying for it. I like wilhoite, but hes no match for 2011 or even 2012 sideline to sideline willis.
fangio is a good D coordinator, but he kinda worked off having elite talent in the front 7 and focusing on fundamentals. I think this year mangini is a better fit simply because there will be more variety and our defense, while still talented, is nowhere near as talented than under fangio
this gameplan for sunday stunk though. playing soft zone with cbs who are supposed to press, without actually pressing...and disguising ourselves out of the game
hopefully we learn from our mistakes
We shall see if Mangini is better than Fangio come Sunday. Arizona always found a way to attack 49ers D under Fangio.