There are 239 users in the forums

John Lynch - 49ers GM

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by Tigerlaw:
Originally posted by Wubbie:
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by LifelongNiner:
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Lynch was just on KNBR. He was asked about possibly losing Ryans and he said that he has about 4 teams that he knows about that want to talk to him. He said he may begin interviews next week. I hope it doesn't screw up the game planning. I wish the NFL would make a rule that no interviews can take place until the playoffs are over. Period. None. Nada. It wouldn't kill teams to wait until the first week of February to begin interviews. Are those extra 3 or 4 weeks going make that much of a difference? I'm talking about all interviews, not just the coaches that are in the playoffs.

How can you ask for that when it's that same system that got us Kyle? Did our interviews screw with Atlanta's game planning?
We had to wait after the SB to interview KS

I realize that the teams can deny permission until after the playoffs but under the current system, it could put coaches in the playoffs at a disadvantage. If a team denies a coach permission it could hurt his prospects and make him want to leave. If they grant permission it could disrupt preparations for the next game.

There's no reason the league couldn't make a rule that no coaching interviews can start until the SB is over. They have rules about when free agents can be contacted. They have compensation rules. Obviously they can make rules so why don't they address this.

Oh, I definitely agree that it would just be fairer on all the playoff coaches and staffs that interviews should wait until after the season.
Another thing to point out---I think Shanahan mentioned, was it after Saleh left? or this past offseason when he lost a lot of his staff, that trying to fill out a coaching staff after a deep run in the playoffs is challenging because they're weeks/a month behind everyone else.

My only guess for why it is the way it is now, is that the offseason can move very fast for front offices and coaching staffs. They don't want a prolonged search to happen when they're going into their draft and free agency prep. They're already a bad-enough team that they had to fire their head coach and probably his entire staff is gone. If they can get their new coaching staff in as early as possible, they have a more cohesive idea about what the overall roster strategy is.

The NFL is stupid for not placing a moratorium on hires.

In a race to beat other teams and fill their coaching staffs the non playoff assistants get hired first.

This has a trickle down effect of putting less qualified HC on teams so the cycle of failure continues.

NFL always work with NCAA. NCAA candidates can't wait for the NFL playoff to be over.
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
I realize that the teams can deny permission until after the playoffs but under the current system, it could put coaches in the playoffs at a disadvantage. If a team denies a coach permission it could hurt his prospects and make him want to leave. If they grant permission it could disrupt preparations for the next game.

There's no reason the league couldn't make a rule that no coaching interviews can start until the SB is over. They have rules about when free agents can be contacted. They have compensation rules. Obviously they can make rules so why don't they address this.

I don't think it is workable at all. There is no way to prevent teams from talking to unaffiliated coaching prospects even during the regular season. Any team can talk to a free agent at any time also. The players on a roster at the end of the year just don't officially become free agents until the start of the league new year in March, but anyone who wasn't on a roster at the end of the season, or vet who is cut by their team in the offseason is fair game if I remember correctly.
Won't be shocked if he's a GM this cycle


everyone wants a piece of this team lol
Originally posted by Waterbear:
Originally posted by LifelongNiner:
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Lynch was just on KNBR. He was asked about possibly losing Ryans and he said that he has about 4 teams that he knows about that want to talk to him. He said he may begin interviews next week. I hope it doesn't screw up the game planning. I wish the NFL would make a rule that no interviews can take place until the playoffs are over. Period. None. Nada. It wouldn't kill teams to wait until the first week of February to begin interviews. Are those extra 3 or 4 weeks going make that much of a difference? I'm talking about all interviews, not just the coaches that are in the playoffs.

How can you ask for that when it's that same system that got us Kyle? Did our interviews screw with Atlanta's game planning?


LMAO.
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by LifelongNiner:
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Lynch was just on KNBR. He was asked about possibly losing Ryans and he said that he has about 4 teams that he knows about that want to talk to him. He said he may begin interviews next week. I hope it doesn't screw up the game planning. I wish the NFL would make a rule that no interviews can take place until the playoffs are over. Period. None. Nada. It wouldn't kill teams to wait until the first week of February to begin interviews. Are those extra 3 or 4 weeks going make that much of a difference? I'm talking about all interviews, not just the coaches that are in the playoffs.

How can you ask for that when it's that same system that got us Kyle? Did our interviews screw with Atlanta's game planning?
We had to wait after the SB to interview KS

We interviewed him before the Super Bowl. The Falcons were also pretty accommodating to us. We only had to wait until after the Super Bowl to officially announce the hire.
Originally posted by Hoovtrain:
Originally posted by Jcool:
Originally posted by SLCNiner:
Since Peters is turning down every interview request he gets, can we assume there's a deal in place for him if/when Lynch leaves?

not quite....


Wasn't there last year?

Yeah,I thought the Giants hired Joe Shein last year.
Originally posted by LifelongNiner:
Originally posted by Hoovtrain:
Originally posted by Jcool:
Originally posted by SLCNiner:
Since Peters is turning down every interview request he gets, can we assume there's a deal in place for him if/when Lynch leaves?

not quite....


Wasn't there last year?

Yeah,I thought the Giants hired Joe Shein last year.

They did, this tweet was from a year ago.
I believe Arizona and Tennessee are the only teams with GM openings and that Peters turned down interviews with both. I think its likely that Lynch is promoted to VP of Ops and Peters promoted to GM. If Carthon gets one of the 2 jobs the Niners will get more comp picks again.

edit... Arizona hired their GM. Now down to just Tenn
[ Edited by Ninerjohn on Jan 16, 2023 at 1:30 PM ]
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Won't be shocked if he's a GM this cycle


everyone wants a piece of this team lol

Getting a second interview

Originally posted by LifelongNiner:
Originally posted by Hoovtrain:
Originally posted by Jcool:
Originally posted by SLCNiner:
Since Peters is turning down every interview request he gets, can we assume there's a deal in place for him if/when Lynch leaves?

not quite....


Wasn't there last year?

Yeah,I thought the Giants hired Joe Shein last year.

It does say Jan. 2022 on the Tweet. The point was he does take GM interviews. Just might be real selective with who he interviews with.
[ Edited by Jcool on Jan 17, 2023 at 11:59 AM ]
Ran is going to the Titans. When do we get our third round pick for him?
Originally posted by jordanroberts88:
Ran is going to the Titans. When do we get our third round pick for him?

Two 3rds, first would be this next draft.
Originally posted by jordanroberts88:
Ran is going to the Titans. When do we get our third round pick for him?

This yr and next….if Ryans goes we get an extra 3rd for the next 3 yrs I believe.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by jordanroberts88:
Ran is going to the Titans. When do we get our third round pick for him?

This yr and next….if Ryans goes we get an extra 3rd for the next 3 yrs I believe.

Okay, so we don't lose a 3rd when two are hired in the same hiring cycle. Awesome.
Boom! draft pick mining by Kyle Shannahan....
Share 49ersWebzone