There are 256 users in the forums

49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online

49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Originally posted by thl408:
For real. Good luck getting a competent HC to come in afterwards if Kyle is shown the door. My biggest question about him were answered when he kept the team on board after starting 0-9 and again after last season's bad start. How he kept that lockeroom committed to him after two terrible starts to the season is a minor miracle.

Yep.

Just looking at all the HCs that were hired this offseason, how many/any would you take over Shanahan right now?


The coaching talent pool looks pretty meh at the moment. I'm perfectly happy sticking with Shanahan and seeing what he can do with hopefully better talent.
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by 49erJay:
Still crazy to me how people want him gone

Now THAT would be stupid. At worst case scenario, you force him to sign an experienced veteran GM and DC. But you don't let him walk.

Agree, no matter how things go this year or next. You give Shanahan a shot with a proven quality GM.

Out of curiosity, who are some proven quality GM candidates that we could hire?
Originally posted by thl408:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by 49erJay:
Still crazy to me how people want him gone

Now THAT would be stupid. At worst case scenario, you force him to sign an experienced veteran GM and DC. But you don't let him walk.

For real. Good luck getting a competent HC to come in afterwards if Kyle is shown the door. My biggest question about him were answered when he kept the team on board after starting 0-9 and again after last season's bad start. How he kept that lockeroom committed to him after two terrible starts to the season is a minor miracle.

Yeah and he seems like the kind to grow and adapt like his very own offense.

For instance:
1. He's admitted he relied too heavily on JG to carry the team and cover up too many holes.
2. He's admitted he didn't add enough competition last year and players became complacent with locked up starting positions
3. He got rid of the ping pong table

I mean, personally, #3 alone is hard evidence he's a ground breaking talent.



My only concern was his ability to lead the whole team including being dialed in on defense with the same expectations he has for himself and his offensive unit. IIRC, a former player, Kevin Mitchell (not him...hmmm) said that was the hardest part for Kyle but he got better at it.

I think this year, hopefully he'll be freed up to address the defense more with help from Woods and an offense going into year 3.
[ Edited by NCommand on Feb 26, 2019 at 4:43 PM ]
Originally posted by thl408:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by 49erJay:
Still crazy to me how people want him gone

Now THAT would be stupid. At worst case scenario, you force him to sign an experienced veteran GM and DC. But you don't let him walk.

For real. Good luck getting a competent HC to come in afterwards if Kyle is shown the door. My biggest question about him were answered when he kept the team on board after starting 0-9 and again after last season's bad start. How he kept that lockeroom committed to him after two terrible starts to the season is a minor miracle.

I think it really helped Kyle that Jimmy came in oct..

I'm sure players seen jimmy light it up in practice and it showed the team what would be coming which gave the team some hope going Fwd.
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by thl408:
For real. Good luck getting a competent HC to come in afterwards if Kyle is shown the door. My biggest question about him were answered when he kept the team on board after starting 0-9 and again after last season's bad start. How he kept that lockeroom committed to him after two terrible starts to the season is a minor miracle.

Yep.

Just looking at all the HCs that were hired this offseason, how many/any would you take over Shanahan right now?


The coaching talent pool looks pretty meh at the moment. I'm perfectly happy sticking with Shanahan and seeing what he can do with hopefully better talent.

And less injuries
Originally posted by evil:
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by 49erJay:
Still crazy to me how people want him gone

Now THAT would be stupid. At worst case scenario, you force him to sign an experienced veteran GM and DC. But you don't let him walk.

Agree, no matter how things go this year or next. You give Shanahan a shot with a proven quality GM.

Out of curiosity, who are some proven quality GM candidates that we could hire?

Don't know but I am sure there are some with more experience/success than Lynch. Do you you think he is the most experiences and accomplished GM that the team could land?
Originally posted by zeppfan1:
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by zeppfan1:
Not really. In '85 and '86 the Giants had the upper hand with two easy victories. In '84 the Niners won handily. In '90 Roger Craig and Gary Reasons happened. Most, if not all, the regular season contests were close games. That's hardly destroying.


I think he was talking about this game.


Yeah, I know, but he made it sound as if it was domination every game.

Wow what a flashback. I "extremely" disliked the Giants back then but the loss against the Vikings the year after hurt more. Thankfully, we had '88 and '89!
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Originally posted by evil:
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by 49erJay:
Still crazy to me how people want him gone

Now THAT would be stupid. At worst case scenario, you force him to sign an experienced veteran GM and DC. But you don't let him walk.

Agree, no matter how things go this year or next. You give Shanahan a shot with a proven quality GM.

Out of curiosity, who are some proven quality GM candidates that we could hire?

Don't know but I am sure there are some with more experience/success than Lynch. Do you you think he is the most experiences and accomplished GM that the team could land?

There may have been more experienced candidates but I can't seem to think of any unemployed successful GM's available. Unless one wants Ted Thompson, who still works for the Packers in a different capacity, and he has a mantra of BPA regardless of position and rarely dips into FA for big names. I can't see our fans liking the hire all that much. There is Scot McCloughan, but his lone draft as the GM was not good at all though some fans like him and credit him for the time Nolan held final say in the War Room. And Nolan has credited Baalke with some of those good picks.

Other experienced names : Jerry Reese, Reggie McKenzie, Phil Emery, Ruston Webster, John Idzik, Ray Farmer, Mike Tannenbaum.

Does not exactly look like there is much in way of experienced AND successful out there, otherwise they would likely have jobs. If we moved on from Lynch you are likely looking at inexperienced yet well regarded and respected personnel execs which means no guarantees they can do the job better than Lynch, Peters and Mayhew. Which was the same case when we hired JL, there were no candidates with experience and a good track record.
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by 49erJay:
Still crazy to me how people want him gone

Now THAT would be stupid. At worst case scenario, you force him to sign an experienced veteran GM and DC. But you don't let him walk.

Agree, no matter how things go this year or next. You give Shanahan a shot with a proven quality GM.

Disagree, Shanny isn't a good HC needs to go back to OC. Sooner the better for both partiew, he puts a sloppy, extremely weak, I'll prepared product on the field week in and week out. That's not on Lynch, IMO Shanny is more responsible for the dumspter fire. Not only has he allowed the defense to remain inept but he's also forced Lynch into some pretty bad draft blunders aka Williams Beathard and Pettis IMO. They were brought in together and should get be terminated together.
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by thl408:
For real. Good luck getting a competent HC to come in afterwards if Kyle is shown the door. My biggest question about him were answered when he kept the team on board after starting 0-9 and again after last season's bad start. How he kept that lockeroom committed to him after two terrible starts to the season is a minor miracle.

Yep.

Just looking at all the HCs that were hired this offseason, how many/any would you take over Shanahan right now?

The coaching talent pool looks pretty meh at the moment. I'm perfectly happy sticking with Shanahan and seeing what he can do with hopefully better talent.

And less injuries

People around here act like good coaches never overcome talent deficiencies or injuries
Originally posted by NCommand:
The Shanahan-Effect.


Originally posted by GMniner805:
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by thl408:
For real. Good luck getting a competent HC to come in afterwards if Kyle is shown the door. My biggest question about him were answered when he kept the team on board after starting 0-9 and again after last season's bad start. How he kept that lockeroom committed to him after two terrible starts to the season is a minor miracle.

Yep.

Just looking at all the HCs that were hired this offseason, how many/any would you take over Shanahan right now?

The coaching talent pool looks pretty meh at the moment. I'm perfectly happy sticking with Shanahan and seeing what he can do with hopefully better talent.

And less injuries

People around here act like good coaches never overcome talent deficiencies or injuries

did we not do that?
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 63,148
Originally posted by GMniner805:
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by thl408:
For real. Good luck getting a competent HC to come in afterwards if Kyle is shown the door. My biggest question about him were answered when he kept the team on board after starting 0-9 and again after last season's bad start. How he kept that lockeroom committed to him after two terrible starts to the season is a minor miracle.

Yep.

Just looking at all the HCs that were hired this offseason, how many/any would you take over Shanahan right now?

The coaching talent pool looks pretty meh at the moment. I'm perfectly happy sticking with Shanahan and seeing what he can do with hopefully better talent.

And less injuries

People around here act like good coaches never overcome talent deficiencies or injuries

Yah like who?
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by GMniner805:
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by thl408:
For real. Good luck getting a competent HC to come in afterwards if Kyle is shown the door. My biggest question about him were answered when he kept the team on board after starting 0-9 and again after last season's bad start. How he kept that lockeroom committed to him after two terrible starts to the season is a minor miracle.

Yep.

Just looking at all the HCs that were hired this offseason, how many/any would you take over Shanahan right now?

The coaching talent pool looks pretty meh at the moment. I'm perfectly happy sticking with Shanahan and seeing what he can do with hopefully better talent.

And less injuries

People around here act like good coaches never overcome talent deficiencies or injuries

Yah like who?

I'm curious as well.

Why don't you name a HC who lost their starting QB, 1st, 3rd and 4th string RB's, top 3 safeties and their top WR for most of the year and had more than 4 wins....

We'll be waiting.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by GMniner805:
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by thl408:
For real. Good luck getting a competent HC to come in afterwards if Kyle is shown the door. My biggest question about him were answered when he kept the team on board after starting 0-9 and again after last season's bad start. How he kept that lockeroom committed to him after two terrible starts to the season is a minor miracle.

Yep.

Just looking at all the HCs that were hired this offseason, how many/any would you take over Shanahan right now?

The coaching talent pool looks pretty meh at the moment. I'm perfectly happy sticking with Shanahan and seeing what he can do with hopefully better talent.

And less injuries

People around here act like good coaches never overcome talent deficiencies or injuries

Yah like who?

And don't say Urban Meyer again.
Search Share 49ersWebzone