49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Originally posted by NinerPrideinNJ:
Great coaches don't need to "get" a franchise QB. They make one.

wtf lol The NFL ain't a damn bakery.

Originally posted by JaggedJ:

Originally posted by jersey49er:

Look the way I see it is Kyle tried to add to the offense and have Jimmy tear up a weak Seattle secondary, abs Jimmy didn't perform, he's not the answer, Kyle is great bc he schemes plays to feed off other plays that work and when it's rolling it's unstoppable but when it's not it looks ugly

That's my issue with Jimmy. Plays feeding off plays doesn't really work when your QB is erattic. Jimmy from day one has been erratic.

Injury has exaggerated that, not caused it.

Agree completely, now you get an accurate QB with nice pocket presence who lets it fly not like jimmy and his conservative ways and this offense is on point every week. And Kyle doesn't have to scheme around the thought of erratic play

Originally posted by NinerPrideinNJ:
Great coaches don't need to "get" a franchise QB. They make one.

Brady, Montana... a great coach brings out the best. Instead Shanahan had made Garoppolo look worse.

He's a micromanager with an ego. As much of what makes him a good coach is also what holds him and the team back.

He fully looked awful today and his play calling was a joke

One of the most outlandish things I've seen posted on here. Bill Walsh didn't "make" Joe Montana, he recognized his talent and his ability and unleashed it but he was far from infallible. Walsh was also the guy who drafted Gio Carmazzi and recommended that he Colts pass on Peyton Manning and instead take Brian Griese in the 2nd round.

Sometimes lightning strikes and everything falls into place. Pete Carroll didn't "make" Russell Wilson and Andy Reid didn't "make" Pat Mahomes, you just got the right passer with the right coach and it worked out.

Unless you're getting Matt Ryan, you're stuck with Jimmy. There's no one else.

Originally posted by goldlame2013:

Unless you're getting Matt Ryan, you're stuck with Jimmy. There's no one else.

NFL Draft.

Originally posted by goldlame2013:
Unless you're getting Matt Ryan, you're stuck with Jimmy. There's no one else.

He can definitely throw a better deep ball.

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by NinerPrideinNJ:

Great coaches don't need to "get" a franchise QB. They make one.

Brady, Montana... a great coach brings out the best. Instead Shanahan had made Garoppolo look worse.

He's a micromanager with an ego. As much of what makes him a good coach is also what holds him and the team back.

He fully looked awful today and his play calling was a joke

If great coaches can just make franchise QBs then why would the Bill's worry about resigning their QBs (Brady, Montana)

Uhhhh cuz they re-sign them after they've developed them and been successful.

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by NinerPrideinNJ:

Great coaches don't need to "get" a franchise QB. They make one.

Brady, Montana... a great coach brings out the best. Instead Shanahan had made Garoppolo look worse.

He's a micromanager with an ego. As much of what makes him a good coach is also what holds him and the team back.

He fully looked awful today and his play calling was a joke

One of the most outlandish things I've seen posted on here. Bill Walsh didn't "make" Joe Montana, he recognized his talent and his ability and unleashed it but he was far from infallible. Walsh was also the guy who drafted Gio Carmazzi and recommended that he Colts pass on Peyton Manning and instead take Brian Griese in the 2nd round.

Sometimes lightning strikes and everything falls into place. Pete Carroll didn't "make" Russell Wilson and Andy Reid didn't "make" Pat Mahomes, you just got the right passer with the right coach and it worked out.

That's partially what I'm saying. It's two way. Is Brady the player he is without Belichick?

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:


He can definitely throw a better deep ball.

Kirk Cousins with decent pass protection https://t.co/iUrsQ4Hdih pic.twitter.com/ilJK7MqR9E

— Vikings fan, I guess (@SkolChants) November 1, 2020

I still believe we eventually see this dude in red and gold lol.

(Not my wish)

Originally posted by NinerPrideinNJ:
That's partially what I'm saying. It's two way. Is Brady the player he is without Belichick?

Do you have any proof that he wouldn't be? Both Brady and Montana had the drive and insane competitiveness to be great, they wound up with coaches who channeled that and pushed them but if head coaches could just make QB's, why couldn't Mike Holmgren make another Brett Favre, why couldn't Mike Shanahan make another John Elway? Why couldn't Andy Reid figure out a proper replacement for Donovan McNabb until years later when he wound up in KC and Mahomes dropped into his lap?

Originally posted by FranchisePoster:

Originally posted by LVJay:

Originally posted by FranchisePoster:

Originally posted by FranchisePoster:

Originally posted by 9moon:
Kyle is nothing but a very solid C student..

He does well with homework and class work, but when it comes to the Final Exam, he gets nothing but C and Ds..

Lol Moon how was that crack party last night?

Wasn't a personal attack on you Moon. Just a joke my friend.

Moon is cool, bruh, he don't sweat small stuff like that... and maybe he's still at that party but took a quick break to post that comment

I know Moon is cool, but I got a 25% warning lol

Ah wow sorry to hear that...

Originally posted by Ensatsu:

Originally posted by LVJay:
It seems that Kyle outsmarts himself some times... maybe second guessing while preparing during the week and giving way too much credit to the opposing HC (Carroll in this match up), hence dialing up trick plays that might work in college

I was literally laughing on my couch when I saw the wildcat. It's not even disappointment with me anymore. Just laughter. I knew this was an L as soon as I saw that.

Originally posted by Goatie:
A coach needs to keep it simple when the A team is on the benches or on IR. Sure do some trick stuff now and then but call basic bread and butter plays to keep moving the sticks forward.

If JG plays Thursday and plays well enough to win, It's going to be hard to not think there's a pattern...Shanny just pulls him when a game we're losing seems out of reach and preserves JG for the next game. I don't trust JG and 2020 anymore #CovidChangedTheGame

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

One of the most outlandish things I've seen posted on here. Bill Walsh didn't "make" Joe Montana, he recognized his talent and his ability and unleashed it but he was far from infallible. Walsh was also the guy who drafted Gio Carmazzi and recommended that he Colts pass on Peyton Manning and instead take Brian Griese in the 2nd round.

Sometimes lightning strikes and everything falls into place. Pete Carroll didn't "make" Russell Wilson and Andy Reid didn't "make" Pat Mahomes, you just got the right passer with the right coach and it worked out.

So what you're saying is Shanahan is an awful evaluator of QB talent?

Originally posted by Seansf49:
So what you're saying is Shanahan is an awful evaluator of QB talent?

So awful that he went with a QB that played well enough for the team to get to the SB last year?

The 49ers always play and coach scared against Seattle. The coaches game plan was super Vanilla. Where's the creator of last week's run game? What about the game plan we ran out against the vikings and Green Bay last year in the playoffs? Why does Kyle always overthink it in pivotal games? You only trust jimmy to throw short last week and it worked to keep the ball and sustain drives. This week, we play the QB who's having the best season of any player and you pull out a deeper drop and throwing the ball down the field into trouble. Jimmy hasn't shown he's capable of any throws down the field and our offensive line can't pass block on 7 step drops. Our coaches totally blew this game.