49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
You nailed it. BP was a revelation, but they clearly lucked into him to a extent, they never thought he would be that or they wouldn't have left him on the board so long.

Meanwhile, he is now majorly injured, and may miss a lot off the offseason. Lot of interesting names out there to add a guy to throw passes this summer.

I don't see Carr and here is why, teams that need QB will line up for the best avail QB, which will be Carr. Someone with a need and cap space will give the old 3 year $120 million which we can't afford, or they will just trade for him, probably wouldn't even need to trade much, LV wants to unload that contract.. I don't see us able to afford the Carr deal. Wouldn't mind being wrong he's a stud QB / leader.

I think you're right. The plan might be to head into next season with Trey at QB and really see what the kid has. If Lance stumbles out of the gate with a 1-4 or 1-5 start, and fans are screaming for a change, Purdy will probably be ready to go at that point. But, this is assuming Trey can go more than one game and stay healthy. As Lynch pointed out yesterday, this has been an issue.

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by Franchise408:
lmao Kyle Shanahan took this team to the NFC Championship with a 3rd string QB, and it took losing the 3rd AND 4th string QB's in the same game and having literally 0 QB's to finally beat him, and people are talking about how Shanahan is the problem.

Being "the problem" and needing to be better are 2 different things

2023 will be Kyle's 7th season as head coach of the 9ers and Is yet to find a QB who's good enough to get us over the hump.

That's the biggest problem.

Originally posted by Sickaa:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by Franchise408:
lmao Kyle Shanahan took this team to the NFC Championship with a 3rd string QB, and it took losing the 3rd AND 4th string QB's in the same game and having literally 0 QB's to finally beat him, and people are talking about how Shanahan is the problem.

Being "the problem" and needing to be better are 2 different things

2023 will be Kyle's 7th season as head coach of the 9ers and Is yet to find a QB who's good enough to get us over the hump.

That's the biggest problem.

*All has joined the chat*

Originally posted by Sickaa:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by Franchise408:
lmao Kyle Shanahan took this team to the NFC Championship with a 3rd string QB, and it took losing the 3rd AND 4th string QB's in the same game and having literally 0 QB's to finally beat him, and people are talking about how Shanahan is the problem.

Being "the problem" and needing to be better are 2 different things

2023 will be Kyle's 7th season as head coach of the 9ers and Is yet to find a QB who's good enough to get us over the hump.

That's the biggest problem.

If great quarterbacks grew on trees, every team would have one. This is not an easy task, which is probably why Kyle designed his system to not need a Brady to win with. You probably still need at least a quarter back around the 10th rank range to have a serious shot at winning it all but even Nick Foles got hot at the right time in one and also who knows

Injuries happen more often because people are on PEDs: steroids, hgh, designer steroids, and whatever the heck is out there.

Look at aaron donald, dj metcalf, nick bosa. You can not achieve any of those body types by being "natural."

it's not brock's fault he has to play NFL in a roided league.

It's not kyle's fault or his scheme. he is just a coach

Some athletes you can't even tell like motherf**king that one idiot WR on the cardinals that got suspended...

Even our own DE Jordan Willis got caught doing steroids in 2021. so yeah. I blame steroids on ligaments and freak injuries.

Sometimes you can just tell by looking at them who's roided and who's not. You can grow a big ass neck like Takeo Spikes.

IS everyone roided? NO. Absolutely not. I'm just saying that's a big part of the problem people don't blame or look at. But they'd rather go straight to "Kyle's scheme"

Higher chance of Injuries for me come from:

1) PEDS + Unnatural athleticism 2) Playing field grass inconsistencies (grass vs turf) -- + that dogs**t paint they spray on the field that fcked OBJ in the superbowl

Originally posted by DrEll:

Originally posted by TD49ers:

Originally posted by DrEll:

Originally posted by 9moon:

Originally posted by dmax:

Originally posted by NYniner85:
SF goes on a 12 game winning streak and gets to the NFCC and I'm seeing some fans on Twitter talking firing Kyle or calling him out lol. Bunch of losers imo

12game win streak is great.. yippee..
I want to win once we get to the playoffs not lose like Kyle constantly does. People that love and can't admit his shortcomings are Blind fans

Dmax.. I've already posted, the Shananigans will continue to be happy each time Kyle raises up that 2nd Place Trophy..

You can hear all of them yelling " WE ALMOST WON !! WE ALMOST GOT TO THE SUPER BOWL !! "

I can't imagine any of the fans that celebrate the 12 game winning streak were watching the 49ers in the 80s 90s when a 12 win record was pretty much automatic at the start of the season.

It just goes to show how far this fan base has fallen from the glory days. GEORGE SEIFERT, who coached 2 Super Bowl teams for this franchise, was fired because he couldn't overcome Green Bay. His tenure lasted from 1989-1996. STEVE MARIUCCI, who revived this franchise post Steve Young and Jerry Rice, took this team on multiple playoff runs but was fired for not winning a SB. His tenure lasted from 1997-2002.

There was a time when our head coaches were held to a standard of excellence. Anything less than a SB and you were on the hot seat. Now, we have a coach that lost a SB and two NFC Championship games and we celebrate him like he's the messiah. Can't wait to hear next year's excuse when we come up short once again…

Great coaches dont grow trees. Franchises go decades without one So when you have a coach that is successful like Shany you cannot be hasty. Winning a SB is hard and takes some luck too. I think Shany will win one in his career, maybe more but its not a given. He has the ability in my opinion.

Yet teams like the Eagles come out of nowhere and are on the brink of winning two with a completely different coaching staff. McVay has been to two SBs already. Seems like everyone else is closer to winning one except the guy that's been coaching here for what will be his 7th year now.

just wondering what the masses will say IF he botches it again, since he's convinced we've got two QBs that can take us to the promised land…which they can't.

The 9ers are on the brink as well. We had Tart miss an easy pic, Jimmy missed a wide open Sanders and we played with a 5th stringer in the NFC championship and 3rd stringer for most of the season. The front is aggressive and truly wants to win. Shanny has lost 4 coordinators to HC jobs. He must be doing something right.

Who is your replacement?

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by Sickaa:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by Franchise408:
lmao Kyle Shanahan took this team to the NFC Championship with a 3rd string QB, and it took losing the 3rd AND 4th string QB's in the same game and having literally 0 QB's to finally beat him, and people are talking about how Shanahan is the problem.

Being "the problem" and needing to be better are 2 different things

2023 will be Kyle's 7th season as head coach of the 9ers and Is yet to find a QB who's good enough to get us over the hump.

That's the biggest problem.

*All has joined the chat*

Originally posted by Sickaa:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by Franchise408:
lmao Kyle Shanahan took this team to the NFC Championship with a 3rd string QB, and it took losing the 3rd AND 4th string QB's in the same game and having literally 0 QB's to finally beat him, and people are talking about how Shanahan is the problem.

Being "the problem" and needing to be better are 2 different things

2023 will be Kyle's 7th season as head coach of the 9ers and Is yet to find a QB who's good enough to get us over the hump.

That's the biggest problem.

Yessir. This is one reason I don't want KS near the decision making process on our QB room. Any GM floundering that long at the games most important position is long gone. Fire KS the GM. Keep KS the coach, who is one of the best on earth now at X's O's.

Originally posted by Sickaa:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by Franchise408:

lmao Kyle Shanahan took this team to the NFC Championship with a 3rd string QB, and it took losing the 3rd AND 4th string QB's in the same game and having literally 0 QB's to finally beat him, and people are talking about how Shanahan is the problem.

Being "the problem" and needing to be better are 2 different things

2023 will be Kyle's 7th season as head coach of the 9ers and Is yet to find a QB who's good enough to get us over the hump.

That's the biggest problem.

I agree, it's not the only problem but it is the biggest.

Coaches that don't find a QB generally get fired. That's just the way it is. Belichick and Reid didn't find their home until they found their QB.

Originally posted by swoosh6996:

Originally posted by Costanza:

Originally posted by 5thSFG:

Originally posted by Costanza:

Originally posted by billbird2111:

Originally posted by Costanza:
Good coach but needs to show growth or the clock is going to start ticking.

I think you need a new clock.

I don't think Jed has him on the clock…yet.

Coaches that go to the NFCCG two years in a row don't get anything but accolades. Some of the s**t said in these forums is outright asinine

Kyle Shanahan 2022: coach of the year candidate for taking a 3rd string qb to the NFCCG.

Also kyle shanahan 2022: on the hot seat

Dude, Jed previously fired a guy that went to 3 straight NFC title games. So, um yeah, it happens lol.

It's not going to happen again. Jed learned his lesson the first time there.

We've reached the point where Jed is far more mature about his HC than many of the posters here who used to blame Jed for everything. It's hilarious.

Originally posted by captveg:
We've reached the point where Jed is far more mature about his HC than many of the posters here who used to blame Jed for everything. It's hilarious.

Jed grew up, some of the perpetual adolescents in the fanbase have not.

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
I agree, it's not the only problem but it is the biggest.

Coaches that don't find a QB generally get fired. That's just the way it is. Belichick and Reid didn't find their home until they found their QB.

100%

I should have said "Health" and "QB" are key to getting us over the hump.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by Sickaa:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by Franchise408:
lmao Kyle Shanahan took this team to the NFC Championship with a 3rd string QB, and it took losing the 3rd AND 4th string QB's in the same game and having literally 0 QB's to finally beat him, and people are talking about how Shanahan is the problem.

Being "the problem" and needing to be better are 2 different things

2023 will be Kyle's 7th season as head coach of the 9ers and Is yet to find a QB who's good enough to get us over the hump.

That's the biggest problem.

Yessir. This is one reason I don't want KS near the decision making process on our QB room. Any GM floundering that long at the games most important position is long gone. Fire KS the GM. Keep KS the coach, who is one of the best on earth now at X's O's.

This is one take I can get with. Let Kyle tell the personnel guys the traits he wants, but no way do I let him pick the guy. Too many whiffs. With that said, I feel closer with this team, due to both QBs, than I did after 2019 or 2021.

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by Sickaa:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by Franchise408:
lmao Kyle Shanahan took this team to the NFC Championship with a 3rd string QB, and it took losing the 3rd AND 4th string QB's in the same game and having literally 0 QB's to finally beat him, and people are talking about how Shanahan is the problem.

Being "the problem" and needing to be better are 2 different things

2023 will be Kyle's 7th season as head coach of the 9ers and Is yet to find a QB who's good enough to get us over the hump.

That's the biggest problem.

I agree, it's not the only problem but it is the biggest.

Coaches that don't find a QB generally get fired. That's just the way it is. Belichick and Reid didn't find their home until they found their QB.

But he did. And the QB got hurt (Purdy). Also, coaches that don't WIN get fired. Usually the QB and coach thing go hand in hand. But Kyle has managed to win in spite of not having a top 5 or 10 QB (Brock might be one, but I need to see it over a full season).

The Eagles, the NFCs best couldn't win a single game when their 1st QB went out. If they had to ride with Minshew for say 12 games, does that suddenly mean Sirianni should get the axe?

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Yessir. This is one reason I don't want KS near the decision making process on our QB room. Any GM floundering that long at the games most important position is long gone. Fire KS the GM. Keep KS the coach, who is one of the best on earth now at X's O's.

So you agree the team missed badly on their first big ticket QB investment

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by Sickaa:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by Franchise408:
lmao Kyle Shanahan took this team to the NFC Championship with a 3rd string QB, and it took losing the 3rd AND 4th string QB's in the same game and having literally 0 QB's to finally beat him, and people are talking about how Shanahan is the problem.

Being "the problem" and needing to be better are 2 different things

2023 will be Kyle's 7th season as head coach of the 9ers and Is yet to find a QB who's good enough to get us over the hump.

That's the biggest problem.

*All has joined the chat*

Awesome.

So if we're just missing the QB and the HC has had 6 years to acquire that QB with no restrictions, that's gotta be one helluva dilemma in your brain.