49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Do you honestly think we still had a chance with Josh Johnson at QB even if Shanahan was impossibly perfect with those in game decisions you are complaining about?

Also, are you really expecting a 4th string practice squad QB to be a starting caliber player? Was it even possible to land a starting caliber that late in the season when Jimmy went down?

At that point we didn't know if Purdy would regain feeling in his arm or not. Kyle let the game get away with his decisions. We had little chance of coming back even with Brock in the 2nd half due to bad coaching

This guy is a fortune teller. What are the winning lottery numbers for this Saturday?

Would you rather be down by 4 or down by 14? Kyle killed our odds even with a competent QB in the 2nd half

Originally posted by YACBros85:

I believe they did. He was fired after the 2012 season. That was his 1st losing season since 2005. Sure. The eagles have had success over the past 5 seasons but that doesn't negate the fact that they gave up on him prematurely. Which can be argued by the fact that Reid has had just as much success if not more in that same time span.

You think Andy was just going to turn it around in that environment? Both sides needed a clean slate and they are both better off for it

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by YACBros85:
Do you honestly think we still had a chance with Josh Johnson at QB even if Shanahan was impossibly perfect with those in game decisions you are complaining about?

Also, are you really expecting a 4th string practice squad QB to be a starting caliber player? Was it even possible to land a starting caliber that late in the season when Jimmy went down?

At that point we didn't know if Purdy would regain feeling in his arm or not. Kyle let the game get away with his decisions. We had little chance of coming back even with Brock in the 2nd half due to bad coaching

This guy is a fortune teller. What are the winning lottery numbers for this Saturday?

Would you rather be down by 4 or down by 14? Kyle killed our odds if even with a competent QB in the 2nd half

sorry bud you have no idea what will happen if Purdy didn't get hurt ..

but i can play that game.. if Purdy didn't get hurt. The game is 7-7,
then we go up 14-7 at the half. and.. well you know we're a second half football team and the sky's the limit

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by YACBros85:
I believe they did. He was fired after the 2012 season. That was his 1st losing season since 2005. Sure. The eagles have had success over the past 5 seasons but that doesn't negate the fact that they gave up on him prematurely. Which can be argued by the fact that Reid has had just as much success if not more in that same time span.

You think Andy was just going to turn it around in that environment? Both sides needed a clean slate and they are both better off for it

the amount of narrative pushing in here along the KS = Reid lines is staggering it's like 50% of the posts in this thread.

I don't really get it I guess ppl like to push it cuz Reid won a ring after a long time trying so ppl say KS will do it cuz, you know, this one guy did.

this is coming from someone who is give the lifetime contract to KS

but it has zero to do with Andy Reid

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by YACBros85:
I believe they did. He was fired after the 2012 season. That was his 1st losing season since 2005. Sure. The eagles have had success over the past 5 seasons but that doesn't negate the fact that they gave up on him prematurely. Which can be argued by the fact that Reid has had just as much success if not more in that same time span.

You think Andy was just going to turn it around in that environment? Both sides needed a clean slate and they are both better off for it

the amount of narrative pushing in here along the KS = Reid lines is staggering it's like 50% of the posts in this thread.

I don't really get it I guess ppl like to push it cuz Reid won a ring after a long time trying so ppl say KS will do it cuz, you know, this one guy did.

yet you don't see any issues with any of your posts.. lol

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by YACBros85:
I believe they did. He was fired after the 2012 season. That was his 1st losing season since 2005. Sure. The eagles have had success over the past 5 seasons but that doesn't negate the fact that they gave up on him prematurely. Which can be argued by the fact that Reid has had just as much success if not more in that same time span.

You think Andy was just going to turn it around in that environment? Both sides needed a clean slate and they are both better off for it

the amount of narrative pushing in here along the KS = Reid lines is staggering it's like 50% of the posts in this thread.

I don't really get it I guess ppl like to push it cuz Reid won a ring after a long time trying so ppl say KS will do it cuz, you know, this one guy did.

yet you don't see any issues with any of your posts.. lol

MrAtt .. i got a lot to say .. we should start a Reid thread so we don't sidetrack all this KS convo

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

I believe they did. He was fired after the 2012 season. That was his 1st losing season since 2005. Sure. The eagles have had success over the past 5 seasons but that doesn't negate the fact that they gave up on him prematurely. Which can be argued by the fact that Reid has had just as much success if not more in that same time span.

You think Andy was just going to turn it around in that environment? Both sides needed a clean slate and they are both better off for it

the amount of narrative pushing in here along the KS = Reid lines is staggering it's like 50% of the posts in this thread.

I don't really get it I guess ppl like to push it cuz Reid won a ring after a long time trying so ppl say KS will do it cuz, you know, this one guy did.

Yeah they seem to forget that getting fired was part of the process for Reid. There's no guarantee he or Philly have a ring right now if they didn't part ways

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by YACBros85:
Do you honestly think we still had a chance with Josh Johnson at QB even if Shanahan was impossibly perfect with those in game decisions you are complaining about?

Also, are you really expecting a 4th string practice squad QB to be a starting caliber player? Was it even possible to land a starting caliber that late in the season when Jimmy went down?

At that point we didn't know if Purdy would regain feeling in his arm or not. Kyle let the game get away with his decisions. We had little chance of coming back even with Brock in the 2nd half due to bad coaching

This guy is a fortune teller. What are the winning lottery numbers for this Saturday?

Would you rather be down by 4 or down by 14? Kyle killed our odds if even with a competent QB in the 2nd half

First of all, Josh Johnson lost a shotgun snap which lead to a Philly TD and put them up by 14. 2nd, the defense gave up 7 first downs due to penalty which extended multiple eagle TD drives. You really blaming those things on Kyle?

If Brock Purdy would have stepped up into the pocket on the play which ended with him injured, we are talking a completely different ball game. One of Brock's biggest knocks going into the playoffs was him not stepping up into the pocket. It came back and bit him and the team in the ass.

if you are angry and feel like you need to take it out on someone. You should take it out on those garbage eagles fans that need a huge slice of humble pie.

The truth is, you can look at EVERY HC in the league every week and tell the t.v. screen how you would have made a better decision. You could watch the SB this week and do the same thing with both of those coaches and 1 is still going to walk away with a ring at the end of the game.

Sometimes unfortunate things happen. We have had a slew of them over the past 5 seasons and yet we have been a competitive playoff team for a majority of them. So until Shanahan has more than 2 consecutive losing seasons, he isn't going anywhere.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by YACBros85:
I believe they did. He was fired after the 2012 season. That was his 1st losing season since 2005. Sure. The eagles have had success over the past 5 seasons but that doesn't negate the fact that they gave up on him prematurely. Which can be argued by the fact that Reid has had just as much success if not more in that same time span.

You think Andy was just going to turn it around in that environment? Both sides needed a clean slate and they are both better off for it

the amount of narrative pushing in here along the KS = Reid lines is staggering it's like 50% of the posts in this thread.

I don't really get it I guess ppl like to push it cuz Reid won a ring after a long time trying so ppl say KS will do it cuz, you know, this one guy did.

yet you don't see any issues with any of your posts.. lol

MrAtt .. i got a lot to say .. we should start a Reid thread so we don't sidetrack all this KS convo

didn't you start this nonsense

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
2nd place trophies means they had a shot at first place ..can't say that about the rest of the league who watches

so again..you want a coach who cant win the big game, its ok to be second best when the aim is to win it all.
thats what you are saying?

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by YACBros85:
I believe they did. He was fired after the 2012 season. That was his 1st losing season since 2005. Sure. The eagles have had success over the past 5 seasons but that doesn't negate the fact that they gave up on him prematurely. Which can be argued by the fact that Reid has had just as much success if not more in that same time span.

You think Andy was just going to turn it around in that environment? Both sides needed a clean slate and they are both better off for it

the amount of narrative pushing in here along the KS = Reid lines is staggering it's like 50% of the posts in this thread.

I don't really get it I guess ppl like to push it cuz Reid won a ring after a long time trying so ppl say KS will do it cuz, you know, this one guy did.

yet you don't see any issues with any of your posts.. lol

MrAtt .. i got a lot to say .. we should start a Reid thread so we don't sidetrack all this KS convo

didn't you start this nonsense

No sir! I responded to the posts flying around in here.. which was a mistake

like Shaggy says.. it wasn't me

Originally posted by dmax:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
2nd place trophies means they had a shot at first place ..can't say that about the rest of the league who watches

so again..you want a coach who cant win the big game, its ok to be second best when the aim is to win it all.
thats what you are saying?

Do you have a shot to win when you are in last place ?

Originally posted by dmax:
so again..you want a coach who cant win the big game, its ok to be second best when the aim is to win it all.
thats what you are saying?

Sounds like the arguments against Peyton, Lebron and the like. Never gonna win the big one.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Sounds like the arguments against Peyton, Lebron and the like. Never gonna win the big one.

its facts..2 super bowl trips ..2 losses . Where is the lie?