There are 302 users in the forums

49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online

49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Originally posted by Cisco0623:
Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Originally posted by Cisco0623:
Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Love it when a fan base lives up to their derogatory Nick name.

You aren't at all upset about giving a guy they traded 3 first rounders for a pinkslip after 5 games played?

I understand the draft is a crapshoot. Ultimately a players success is in their control. No coach no scheme can make a player good. Lance was staring at wide open receivers and not throwing the f**king ball. Dude just sucks we drafted a bust. I wanted Fields. Much the same when McGlinchey was drafted I wanted Alexander. I don't care if picks get wasted as long as we are competitive. You want to see me upset just wait til we draft another kicker/punter.

See my previous post just before this one. Don't mind the trade. They just never really gave him a chance which is my issue. so it's like wtf.

Lance's chance was 2022. It's not Lance's fault he got injured, but that was his chance. Purdy closed the door on his chance being extended into 2023.
Originally posted by Cisco0623:
Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Originally posted by Cisco0623:
Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Love it when a fan base lives up to their derogatory Nick name.

You aren't at all upset about giving a guy they traded 3 first rounders for a pinkslip after 5 games played?

I understand the draft is a crapshoot. Ultimately a players success is in their control. No coach no scheme can make a player good. Lance was staring at wide open receivers and not throwing the f**king ball. Dude just sucks we drafted a bust. I wanted Fields. Much the same when McGlinchey was drafted I wanted Alexander. I don't care if picks get wasted as long as we are competitive. You want to see me upset just wait til we draft another kicker/punter.

See my previous post just before this one. Don't mind the trade. They just never really gave him a chance which is my issue. so it's like wtf.

I said he should start week 1 his rookie year to get the learning curve out of the way. I didn't want to hear in year 2 all the excuses he hadn't played in 2+ years. This was a horrible draft pick from day 1 and I'll be relieved when he's gone. People really think he's gonna ascend to greatness haven't paid attention to almost all our early draft picks being busts.
Originally posted by Cisco0623:
See my previous post just before this one. Don't mind the trade. They just never really gave him a chance which is my issue. so it's like wtf.

but they did. 2022 was his opportunity. they gave him the team. it's unfortunate he got injured and missed the time that the team set aside for his development

injuries have derailed his development more than the team.
[ Edited by boast on Aug 23, 2023 at 1:10 PM ]
Originally posted by captveg:
Originally posted by harkenthegoldenyears:
Originally posted by Ensatsu:
Originally posted by boast:
Kyle's going nowhere. Jed loves him. three NFCCG and a SB appearance. made Jed money. seems like some here dont understand the business of football.

Scenario A: Purdy wins Superbowl, then all is good.

Scenario B: Purdy flops / gets injured. Sam will come in and do his Sam thing. Kyle comes into Jed's office a year or two later and says, we need to draft another quarterback because Purdy isn't the guy. You're going to trust him on Quarterback evaluation again?

And what happens if Trey Lance is succeeding elsewhere? Even more damnable.

What happens if Purdy puts up Pro Bowl numbers, looks amazing, but the 49ers defense gives up 40 points to the Chiefs and the 49ers lose the Super Bowl 40-39?

There are plenty of scenarios where Purdy confirms he was the right choice but the 49ers don't win the Super Bowl. It's not 100% black/white.

I hear you but as the Head coach it all falls on him. And because he's labeled some offensive genius the qb is more on him even if it's not fair. So that job comes with unforgiving pressure. I respect that.
Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Originally posted by Cisco0623:
Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Originally posted by Cisco0623:
Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Love it when a fan base lives up to their derogatory Nick name.

You aren't at all upset about giving a guy they traded 3 first rounders for a pinkslip after 5 games played?

I understand the draft is a crapshoot. Ultimately a players success is in their control. No coach no scheme can make a player good. Lance was staring at wide open receivers and not throwing the f**king ball. Dude just sucks we drafted a bust. I wanted Fields. Much the same when McGlinchey was drafted I wanted Alexander. I don't care if picks get wasted as long as we are competitive. You want to see me upset just wait til we draft another kicker/punter.

See my previous post just before this one. Don't mind the trade. They just never really gave him a chance which is my issue. so it's like wtf.

I said he should start week 1 his rookie year to get the learning curve out of the way. I didn't want to hear in year 2 all the excuses he hadn't played in 2+ years. This was a horrible draft pick from day 1 and I'll be relieved when he's gone. People really think he's gonna ascend to greatness haven't paid attention to almost all our early draft picks being busts.

You are right about that. I was fine with him sitting, but in hindsight they should have played him day 1. It's obvious Kyle doesn't have the patience to develop a qb in that manner. I figured if he'd be the backup that was showing they are still developing him etc but yeah... that's an obvious no now.
Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Originally posted by Cisco0623:
Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Love it when a fan base lives up to their derogatory Nick name.

You aren't at all upset about giving a guy they traded 3 first rounders for a pinkslip after 5 games played?

I understand the draft is a crapshoot. Ultimately a players success is in their control. No coach no scheme can make a player good. Lance was staring at wide open receivers and not throwing the f**king ball. Dude just sucks we drafted a bust. I wanted Fields. Much the same when McGlinchey was drafted I wanted Alexander. I don't care if picks get wasted as long as we are competitive. You want to see me upset just wait til we draft another kicker/punter.

That's exactly why you don't give up 3 first round picks for someone as RAW as Lance.

Thankfully we have Brock, otherwise things would look a little more concerning right now.
Well, so much for QBs requiring several years to master Kyle's playbook. Once Trey is gone, our entire QB room will have 1 total year of experience with it.
Originally posted by evil:
Originally posted by TheGoldenNugget:
He also went to 4 straight championship games...you think this locker room is okay with picking Sam f**king Darnold? This is how you start to question the direction of the FO and head coaching decisions as a player.

Kyle has been to 3 in the last 4 years.

Yes and on his next team he may be humble just like Andy Reid. Darnold over Lance I don't get it. Give it time KS 10.
Lol what an idiot wasted 3 firsts and a third.
Originally posted by Sickaa:
Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Originally posted by Cisco0623:
Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Love it when a fan base lives up to their derogatory Nick name.

You aren't at all upset about giving a guy they traded 3 first rounders for a pinkslip after 5 games played?

I understand the draft is a crapshoot. Ultimately a players success is in their control. No coach no scheme can make a player good. Lance was staring at wide open receivers and not throwing the f**king ball. Dude just sucks we drafted a bust. I wanted Fields. Much the same when McGlinchey was drafted I wanted Alexander. I don't care if picks get wasted as long as we are competitive. You want to see me upset just wait til we draft another kicker/punter.

That's exactly why you don't give up 3 first round picks for someone as RAW as Lance.

Thankfully we have Brock, otherwise things would look a little more concerning right now.

Yeah I liked the move up to 3 cause it was clear QB was our weak link. I just didn't understand taking the blue meat raw QB prospect. Justin Fields with this roster would be a f**king nightmare for every DC in the NFL.
Originally posted by bassmanr:
Yes and on his next team he may be humble just like Andy Reid. Darnold over Lance I don't get it. Give it time KS 10.

So you don't like winning ? Because all the winning in these last 4 years was on the back of Kyle's coaching and the team he helped build.

I'm not advocating for firing a HC because he took one big swing and appears to have unfortunately missed on but one QB when you consider everything Kyle has built and accomplished here to date.
Originally posted by evil:
Originally posted by bassmanr:
Yes and on his next team he may be humble just like Andy Reid. Darnold over Lance I don't get it. Give it time KS 10.

So you don't like winning ? Because all the winning in these last 4 years was on the back of Kyle's coaching and the team he helped build.

I'm not advocating for firing a HC because he took one big swing and appears to have unfortunately missed on but one QB when you consider everything Kyle has built and accomplished here to date.

He is not winning he's finishing 3rd or 4th. He got one 2nd place. He's KS10 for a reason...EGO
If they are getting ready to trade him...wrong move Kyle you impatient b*****d
Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Originally posted by Sickaa:
Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Originally posted by Cisco0623:
Originally posted by Hysterikal:
Love it when a fan base lives up to their derogatory Nick name.

You aren't at all upset about giving a guy they traded 3 first rounders for a pinkslip after 5 games played?

I understand the draft is a crapshoot. Ultimately a players success is in their control. No coach no scheme can make a player good. Lance was staring at wide open receivers and not throwing the f**king ball. Dude just sucks we drafted a bust. I wanted Fields. Much the same when McGlinchey was drafted I wanted Alexander. I don't care if picks get wasted as long as we are competitive. You want to see me upset just wait til we draft another kicker/punter.

That's exactly why you don't give up 3 first round picks for someone as RAW as Lance.

Thankfully we have Brock, otherwise things would look a little more concerning right now.

Yeah I liked the move up to 3 cause it was clear QB was our weak link. I just didn't understand taking the blue meat raw QB prospect. Justin Fields with this roster would be a f**king nightmare for every DC in the NFL.

That's why I always question Kyle. Didn't even give mahomes the time of day and passed on fields as well
Originally posted by bassmanr:
He is not winning he's finishing 3rd or 4th. He got one 2nd place. He's KS10 for a reason...EGO

3 NFCCG in the last 4 years tells me he has been winning.
Share 49ersWebzone