49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
It may have been a bad decision but he threw it to an area where only Aiyuk had a decent chance of getting it. The defenders were all on the other side of him. If it had been intercepted Brock would have been criticized but sometimes you need to take chances.

Was that one of those times? 1st down in the red zone on the first drive of the game when he probably picks up 5 yards from a scramble.

So you want him to be more like Jimmy G? Got it.

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Shorteous:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by ritz126:

Originally posted by Patton:
Not saying the TD throw to Aiyuk was a Great decision, but after watching it from both sides of the camera angles, it's not nearly as bad as it was made out to be imo.

From Purdy's viewpoint you can see BA break free across the back of the endzone in the direction of clear empty space, the ball cleared both defenders as far as height. The criticism can be made that the ball should have been a little higher and a little further to the open side leading BA to the open area of the field more.

If this is Brett Favre, or Mahomes or one of many other QB greats, it doesn't even get talked about except to say how great of a throw it was.

If anything, it shows his confidence in his ability and his receivers and it's a play he will learn from.

it was a great throw but not a good decision. He got a bit lucky for sure the throw was a maybe half a second late and across the body.

I see people are saying he's bashing Brock. I don't see it that way this is how players get better you wouldn't coach that throw would you?

Again, do you think it's wise to "coach players" during press conferences with the media? This is the point we're all making.

Kyle and Brock, they're cool like that. It's a general rule to not throw across the body, late, into the middle of the field. I guarantee you Brock isn't feeling slighted by Kyle's comments.

Brock has been making those throws more and more each week. Let's go back to the back shoulder throws and less across the body to the middle of the field throws.

Brock actually did the same thing on his very first drive versus MIA when he came into the game, and the pass nearly got picked off. He's a playmaker, not a game manager. It's entertaining.

Originally posted by thl408:
Brock actually did the same thing on his very first drive versus MIA when he came into the game, and the pass nearly got picked off. He's a playmaker, not a game manager. It's entertaining.

Sure its a high risk throw. Point is, why call him out in a press conference.

He was asked about the TD and he gave an honest answer. If he said it was a great read we all would be questioning that.

"Honest." "Truth." It's as if you guys think the English language is limited and there was only one way for Kyle to answer the question. Several people have already posted much more palatable responses. Kyle is simply an a*****e and rarely passes on an opportunity to humble his QB publicly. It's what he does. If Purdy keeps playing the way he is, and wins a Super Bowl (or two or three), hopefully he starts chirping back. Hell, he's already earned the right to do that and I wish he would.

Originally posted by Furlow:
So you want him to be more like Jimmy G? Got it.

This seemingly reveals the issue you have with Kyle's comment. It's not simply a matter of not 'criticizing' Purdy in a press conference, but also that you think it was a play we want. Jimmy G throws ill advised passes into traffic. That's what that play was.

Shanahan, so far in his stint with the 49ers, hasn't had a legitimate QB to work with.
Legitimate QB = proven record of consistency, above avg skill set, injury free for the most part

First couple of years, well. Then came Jimmy G., benched now. Then Lance, apparently below avg. Then the last pick in the draft.

Three NFCCGs is a pretty good achievement with what he had to work with.
End of the day, it still is about winning SBs.

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Shorteous:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by ritz126:

Originally posted by Patton:
Not saying the TD throw to Aiyuk was a Great decision, but after watching it from both sides of the camera angles, it's not nearly as bad as it was made out to be imo.

From Purdy's viewpoint you can see BA break free across the back of the endzone in the direction of clear empty space, the ball cleared both defenders as far as height. The criticism can be made that the ball should have been a little higher and a little further to the open side leading BA to the open area of the field more.

If this is Brett Favre, or Mahomes or one of many other QB greats, it doesn't even get talked about except to say how great of a throw it was.

If anything, it shows his confidence in his ability and his receivers and it's a play he will learn from.

it was a great throw but not a good decision. He got a bit lucky for sure the throw was a maybe half a second late and across the body.

I see people are saying he's bashing Brock. I don't see it that way this is how players get better you wouldn't coach that throw would you?

Again, do you think it's wise to "coach players" during press conferences with the media? This is the point we're all making.

Kyle and Brock, they're cool like that. It's a general rule to not throw across the body, late, into the middle of the field. I guarantee you Brock isn't feeling slighted by Kyle's comments.

Brock has been making those throws more and more each week. Let's go back to the back shoulder throws and less across the body to the middle of the field throws.

Brock actually did the same thing on his very first drive versus MIA when he came into the game, and the pass nearly got picked off. He's a playmaker, not a game manager. It's entertaining.

Originally posted by thl408:
Brock actually did the same thing on his very first drive versus MIA when he came into the game, and the pass nearly got picked off. He's a playmaker, not a game manager. It's entertaining.

Sure its a high risk throw. Point is, why call him out in a press conference.

He was asked about the TD and he gave an honest answer. If he said it was a great read we all would be questioning that.

"Honest." "Truth." It's as if you guys think the English language is limited and there was only one way for Kyle to answer the question. Several people have already posted much more palatable responses. Kyle is simply an a*****e and rarely passes on an opportunity to humble his QB publicly. It's what he does. If Purdy keeps playing the way he is, and wins a Super Bowl (or two or three), hopefully he starts chirping back. Hell, he's already earned the right to do that and I wish he would.

Sorry that's some soft ass s**t if you can't handle your coach saying a pass which was clearly a bad idea was a bad idea. I mean Brock is tough enough to handle it I'd suggest his fanboys to get there also

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Shorteous:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by ritz126:

Originally posted by Patton:
Not saying the TD throw to Aiyuk was a Great decision, but after watching it from both sides of the camera angles, it's not nearly as bad as it was made out to be imo.

From Purdy's viewpoint you can see BA break free across the back of the endzone in the direction of clear empty space, the ball cleared both defenders as far as height. The criticism can be made that the ball should have been a little higher and a little further to the open side leading BA to the open area of the field more.

If this is Brett Favre, or Mahomes or one of many other QB greats, it doesn't even get talked about except to say how great of a throw it was.

If anything, it shows his confidence in his ability and his receivers and it's a play he will learn from.

it was a great throw but not a good decision. He got a bit lucky for sure the throw was a maybe half a second late and across the body.

I see people are saying he's bashing Brock. I don't see it that way this is how players get better you wouldn't coach that throw would you?

Again, do you think it's wise to "coach players" during press conferences with the media? This is the point we're all making.

Kyle and Brock, they're cool like that. It's a general rule to not throw across the body, late, into the middle of the field. I guarantee you Brock isn't feeling slighted by Kyle's comments.

Brock has been making those throws more and more each week. Let's go back to the back shoulder throws and less across the body to the middle of the field throws.

Brock actually did the same thing on his very first drive versus MIA when he came into the game, and the pass nearly got picked off. He's a playmaker, not a game manager. It's entertaining.

Originally posted by thl408:
Brock actually did the same thing on his very first drive versus MIA when he came into the game, and the pass nearly got picked off. He's a playmaker, not a game manager. It's entertaining.

Sure its a high risk throw. Point is, why call him out in a press conference.

He was asked about the TD and he gave an honest answer. If he said it was a great read we all would be questioning that.

"Honest." "Truth." It's as if you guys think the English language is limited and there was only one way for Kyle to answer the question. Several people have already posted much more palatable responses. Kyle is simply an a*****e and rarely passes on an opportunity to humble his QB publicly. It's what he does. If Purdy keeps playing the way he is, and wins a Super Bowl (or two or three), hopefully he starts chirping back. Hell, he's already earned the right to do that and I wish he would.

Sorry that's some soft ass s**t if you can't handle your coach saying a pass which was clearly a bad idea was a bad idea. I mean Brock is tough enough to handle it I'd suggest his fanboys to get there also

in that same shanny interview he said brock knows it and acknowledged it and it why they can joke about it now

this is really nothing but a "hater" trying to stir things up about shanny

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by Furlow:
So you want him to be more like Jimmy G? Got it.

This seemingly reveals the issue you have with Kyle's comment. It's not simply a matter of not 'criticizing' Purdy in a press conference, but also that you think it was a play we want. Jimmy G throws ill advised passes into traffic. That's what that play was.

There is absolutely nothing about that play that is like Jimmy G lol. The ability to escape and then willingness and ability to throw it to a spot where his WR could make a play, and back across the middle of the field. Please tell me when we have ever seen Jimmy attempt a throw like that, let alone convert it. And Purdy seems to do it once a game. Hell he did it on the TD to Juice, which no one seems to have a problem with (I get he was wide open, but it was still "across his body").

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Shorteous:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by ritz126:

Originally posted by Patton:
Not saying the TD throw to Aiyuk was a Great decision, but after watching it from both sides of the camera angles, it's not nearly as bad as it was made out to be imo.

From Purdy's viewpoint you can see BA break free across the back of the endzone in the direction of clear empty space, the ball cleared both defenders as far as height. The criticism can be made that the ball should have been a little higher and a little further to the open side leading BA to the open area of the field more.

If this is Brett Favre, or Mahomes or one of many other QB greats, it doesn't even get talked about except to say how great of a throw it was.

If anything, it shows his confidence in his ability and his receivers and it's a play he will learn from.

it was a great throw but not a good decision. He got a bit lucky for sure the throw was a maybe half a second late and across the body.

I see people are saying he's bashing Brock. I don't see it that way this is how players get better you wouldn't coach that throw would you?

Again, do you think it's wise to "coach players" during press conferences with the media? This is the point we're all making.

Kyle and Brock, they're cool like that. It's a general rule to not throw across the body, late, into the middle of the field. I guarantee you Brock isn't feeling slighted by Kyle's comments.

Brock has been making those throws more and more each week. Let's go back to the back shoulder throws and less across the body to the middle of the field throws.

Brock actually did the same thing on his very first drive versus MIA when he came into the game, and the pass nearly got picked off. He's a playmaker, not a game manager. It's entertaining.

Originally posted by thl408:
Brock actually did the same thing on his very first drive versus MIA when he came into the game, and the pass nearly got picked off. He's a playmaker, not a game manager. It's entertaining.

Sure its a high risk throw. Point is, why call him out in a press conference.

He was asked about the TD and he gave an honest answer. If he said it was a great read we all would be questioning that.

"Honest." "Truth." It's as if you guys think the English language is limited and there was only one way for Kyle to answer the question. Several people have already posted much more palatable responses. Kyle is simply an a*****e and rarely passes on an opportunity to humble his QB publicly. It's what he does. If Purdy keeps playing the way he is, and wins a Super Bowl (or two or three), hopefully he starts chirping back. Hell, he's already earned the right to do that and I wish he would.

Sorry that's some soft ass s**t if you can't handle your coach saying a pass which was clearly a bad idea was a bad idea. I mean Brock is tough enough to handle it I'd suggest his fanboys to get there also

Again, this is such an intellectually lazy argument. So are you then being soft for not being able to handle criticism of Kyle? Of course not because that's a ridiculous argument, and honestly something that women do to each other. Do better.

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Shorteous:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by ritz126:

Originally posted by Patton:
Not saying the TD throw to Aiyuk was a Great decision, but after watching it from both sides of the camera angles, it's not nearly as bad as it was made out to be imo.

From Purdy's viewpoint you can see BA break free across the back of the endzone in the direction of clear empty space, the ball cleared both defenders as far as height. The criticism can be made that the ball should have been a little higher and a little further to the open side leading BA to the open area of the field more.

If this is Brett Favre, or Mahomes or one of many other QB greats, it doesn't even get talked about except to say how great of a throw it was.

If anything, it shows his confidence in his ability and his receivers and it's a play he will learn from.

it was a great throw but not a good decision. He got a bit lucky for sure the throw was a maybe half a second late and across the body.

I see people are saying he's bashing Brock. I don't see it that way this is how players get better you wouldn't coach that throw would you?

Again, do you think it's wise to "coach players" during press conferences with the media? This is the point we're all making.

Kyle and Brock, they're cool like that. It's a general rule to not throw across the body, late, into the middle of the field. I guarantee you Brock isn't feeling slighted by Kyle's comments.

Brock has been making those throws more and more each week. Let's go back to the back shoulder throws and less across the body to the middle of the field throws.

Brock actually did the same thing on his very first drive versus MIA when he came into the game, and the pass nearly got picked off. He's a playmaker, not a game manager. It's entertaining.

Originally posted by thl408:
Brock actually did the same thing on his very first drive versus MIA when he came into the game, and the pass nearly got picked off. He's a playmaker, not a game manager. It's entertaining.

Sure its a high risk throw. Point is, why call him out in a press conference.

He was asked about the TD and he gave an honest answer. If he said it was a great read we all would be questioning that.

"Honest." "Truth." It's as if you guys think the English language is limited and there was only one way for Kyle to answer the question. Several people have already posted much more palatable responses. Kyle is simply an a*****e and rarely passes on an opportunity to humble his QB publicly. It's what he does. If Purdy keeps playing the way he is, and wins a Super Bowl (or two or three), hopefully he starts chirping back. Hell, he's already earned the right to do that and I wish he would.

Sorry that's some soft ass s**t if you can't handle your coach saying a pass which was clearly a bad idea was a bad idea. I mean Brock is tough enough to handle it I'd suggest his fanboys to get there also

Again, this is such an intellectually lazy argument. So are you then being soft for not being able to handle criticism of Kyle? Of course not because that's a ridiculous argument, and honestly something that women do to each other. Do better.

Right lol calling Kyle an a*****e cause you can't take constructive criticism hitting the public

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Shorteous:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by ritz126:

Originally posted by Patton:
Not saying the TD throw to Aiyuk was a Great decision, but after watching it from both sides of the camera angles, it's not nearly as bad as it was made out to be imo.

From Purdy's viewpoint you can see BA break free across the back of the endzone in the direction of clear empty space, the ball cleared both defenders as far as height. The criticism can be made that the ball should have been a little higher and a little further to the open side leading BA to the open area of the field more.

If this is Brett Favre, or Mahomes or one of many other QB greats, it doesn't even get talked about except to say how great of a throw it was.

If anything, it shows his confidence in his ability and his receivers and it's a play he will learn from.

it was a great throw but not a good decision. He got a bit lucky for sure the throw was a maybe half a second late and across the body.

I see people are saying he's bashing Brock. I don't see it that way this is how players get better you wouldn't coach that throw would you?

Again, do you think it's wise to "coach players" during press conferences with the media? This is the point we're all making.

Kyle and Brock, they're cool like that. It's a general rule to not throw across the body, late, into the middle of the field. I guarantee you Brock isn't feeling slighted by Kyle's comments.

Brock has been making those throws more and more each week. Let's go back to the back shoulder throws and less across the body to the middle of the field throws.

Brock actually did the same thing on his very first drive versus MIA when he came into the game, and the pass nearly got picked off. He's a playmaker, not a game manager. It's entertaining.

Originally posted by thl408:
Brock actually did the same thing on his very first drive versus MIA when he came into the game, and the pass nearly got picked off. He's a playmaker, not a game manager. It's entertaining.

Sure its a high risk throw. Point is, why call him out in a press conference.

He was asked about the TD and he gave an honest answer. If he said it was a great read we all would be questioning that.

"Honest." "Truth." It's as if you guys think the English language is limited and there was only one way for Kyle to answer the question. Several people have already posted much more palatable responses. Kyle is simply an a*****e and rarely passes on an opportunity to humble his QB publicly. It's what he does. If Purdy keeps playing the way he is, and wins a Super Bowl (or two or three), hopefully he starts chirping back. Hell, he's already earned the right to do that and I wish he would.

Sorry that's some soft ass s**t if you can't handle your coach saying a pass which was clearly a bad idea was a bad idea. I mean Brock is tough enough to handle it I'd suggest his fanboys to get there also

in that same shanny interview he said brock knows it and acknowledged it and it why they can joke about it now

this is really nothing but a "hater" trying to stir things up about shanny

False. I don't hate Kyle at all. In fact I was first in line to eat crow about Kyle's offense holding Jimmy back once we saw what Purdy was able to do. I love Kyle as an X's and O's coach, and even as a motivator of men. It's his view of QB's and how he wants them to play like robots; even in the face of a mountain of evidence that his system works better when the QB pushes the envelope and makes plays outside of that structure. Sometimes you just have to let your players make plays, and then congratulate them for it. That is NOT Kyle's style nor is he good at positively recognizing it when that happens.

Originally posted by Furlow:
Again, this is such an intellectually lazy argument. So are you then being soft for not being able to handle criticism of Kyle? Of course not because that's a ridiculous argument, and honestly something that women do to each other. Do better.

It's a balancing act. If you listen to Parcells, he coached LT, and LT would be supposed to drop in coverage, and he would go sack the QB instead. Parcells would get on him. Then next time, he would sack the QB again, only this time ball out, TD Giants. At a certain point, you say okay, let's let him do what he does out there. If it's working you can keep doing it, KS isn't gonna do anything about it. Favre used to drive playcallers crazy also.

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Shorteous:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by ritz126:

Originally posted by Patton:
Not saying the TD throw to Aiyuk was a Great decision, but after watching it from both sides of the camera angles, it's not nearly as bad as it was made out to be imo.

From Purdy's viewpoint you can see BA break free across the back of the endzone in the direction of clear empty space, the ball cleared both defenders as far as height. The criticism can be made that the ball should have been a little higher and a little further to the open side leading BA to the open area of the field more.

If this is Brett Favre, or Mahomes or one of many other QB greats, it doesn't even get talked about except to say how great of a throw it was.

If anything, it shows his confidence in his ability and his receivers and it's a play he will learn from.

it was a great throw but not a good decision. He got a bit lucky for sure the throw was a maybe half a second late and across the body.

I see people are saying he's bashing Brock. I don't see it that way this is how players get better you wouldn't coach that throw would you?

Again, do you think it's wise to "coach players" during press conferences with the media? This is the point we're all making.

Kyle and Brock, they're cool like that. It's a general rule to not throw across the body, late, into the middle of the field. I guarantee you Brock isn't feeling slighted by Kyle's comments.

Brock has been making those throws more and more each week. Let's go back to the back shoulder throws and less across the body to the middle of the field throws.

Brock actually did the same thing on his very first drive versus MIA when he came into the game, and the pass nearly got picked off. He's a playmaker, not a game manager. It's entertaining.

Originally posted by thl408:
Brock actually did the same thing on his very first drive versus MIA when he came into the game, and the pass nearly got picked off. He's a playmaker, not a game manager. It's entertaining.

Sure its a high risk throw. Point is, why call him out in a press conference.

He was asked about the TD and he gave an honest answer. If he said it was a great read we all would be questioning that.

"Honest." "Truth." It's as if you guys think the English language is limited and there was only one way for Kyle to answer the question. Several people have already posted much more palatable responses. Kyle is simply an a*****e and rarely passes on an opportunity to humble his QB publicly. It's what he does. If Purdy keeps playing the way he is, and wins a Super Bowl (or two or three), hopefully he starts chirping back. Hell, he's already earned the right to do that and I wish he would.

Sorry that's some soft ass s**t if you can't handle your coach saying a pass which was clearly a bad idea was a bad idea. I mean Brock is tough enough to handle it I'd suggest his fanboys to get there also

Again, this is such an intellectually lazy argument. So are you then being soft for not being able to handle criticism of Kyle? Of course not because that's a ridiculous argument, and honestly something that women do to each other. Do better.

Right lol calling Kyle an a*****e cause you can't take constructive criticism hitting the public

Calling a coach an a*****e for insulting his QB is vastly different than accusing another poster of being "soft" for their opinion of said remark. This is a forum to discuss the 49ers team, players, and coaches. So opinions on them are what should be discussed. Not sure why this is so difficult to understand.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by Furlow:
Again, this is such an intellectually lazy argument. So are you then being soft for not being able to handle criticism of Kyle? Of course not because that's a ridiculous argument, and honestly something that women do to each other. Do better.

It's a balancing act. If you listen to Parcells, he coached LT, and LT would be supposed to drop in coverage, and he would go sack the QB instead. Parcells would get on him. Then next time, he would sack the QB again, only this time ball out, TD Giants. At a certain point, you say okay, let's let him do what he does out there. If it's working you can keep doing it, KS isn't gonna do anything about it. Favre used to drive playcallers crazy also.

So after 17 starts and playing at a top 2-3 QB level, and saving Kyle's job for whiffing on Trey, wouldn't you think Purdy has earned the bolded?

Edit: I agree 100% that it's a balancing act. I do think that Kyle is a good match for Purdy, as he will keep him somewhat in check and not go full YOLO all the time. My only gripe is doing so publicly in the manner that he did.

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Shorteous:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by ritz126:

Originally posted by Patton:
Not saying the TD throw to Aiyuk was a Great decision, but after watching it from both sides of the camera angles, it's not nearly as bad as it was made out to be imo.

From Purdy's viewpoint you can see BA break free across the back of the endzone in the direction of clear empty space, the ball cleared both defenders as far as height. The criticism can be made that the ball should have been a little higher and a little further to the open side leading BA to the open area of the field more.

If this is Brett Favre, or Mahomes or one of many other QB greats, it doesn't even get talked about except to say how great of a throw it was.

If anything, it shows his confidence in his ability and his receivers and it's a play he will learn from.

it was a great throw but not a good decision. He got a bit lucky for sure the throw was a maybe half a second late and across the body.

I see people are saying he's bashing Brock. I don't see it that way this is how players get better you wouldn't coach that throw would you?

Again, do you think it's wise to "coach players" during press conferences with the media? This is the point we're all making.

Kyle and Brock, they're cool like that. It's a general rule to not throw across the body, late, into the middle of the field. I guarantee you Brock isn't feeling slighted by Kyle's comments.

Brock has been making those throws more and more each week. Let's go back to the back shoulder throws and less across the body to the middle of the field throws.

Brock actually did the same thing on his very first drive versus MIA when he came into the game, and the pass nearly got picked off. He's a playmaker, not a game manager. It's entertaining.

Originally posted by thl408:
Brock actually did the same thing on his very first drive versus MIA when he came into the game, and the pass nearly got picked off. He's a playmaker, not a game manager. It's entertaining.

Sure its a high risk throw. Point is, why call him out in a press conference.

He was asked about the TD and he gave an honest answer. If he said it was a great read we all would be questioning that.

"Honest." "Truth." It's as if you guys think the English language is limited and there was only one way for Kyle to answer the question. Several people have already posted much more palatable responses. Kyle is simply an a*****e and rarely passes on an opportunity to humble his QB publicly. It's what he does. If Purdy keeps playing the way he is, and wins a Super Bowl (or two or three), hopefully he starts chirping back. Hell, he's already earned the right to do that and I wish he would.

Sorry that's some soft ass s**t if you can't handle your coach saying a pass which was clearly a bad idea was a bad idea. I mean Brock is tough enough to handle it I'd suggest his fanboys to get there also

Again, this is such an intellectually lazy argument. So are you then being soft for not being able to handle criticism of Kyle? Of course not because that's a ridiculous argument, and honestly something that women do to each other. Do better.

Right lol calling Kyle an a*****e cause you can't take constructive criticism hitting the public

Calling a coach an a*****e for insulting his QB is vastly different than accusing another poster of being "soft" for their opinion of said remark. This is a forum to discuss the 49ers team, players, and coaches. So opinions on them are what should be discussed. Not sure why this is so difficult to understand.

Where was the insult towards Purdy?

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Shorteous:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by ritz126:

Originally posted by Patton:
Not saying the TD throw to Aiyuk was a Great decision, but after watching it from both sides of the camera angles, it's not nearly as bad as it was made out to be imo.

From Purdy's viewpoint you can see BA break free across the back of the endzone in the direction of clear empty space, the ball cleared both defenders as far as height. The criticism can be made that the ball should have been a little higher and a little further to the open side leading BA to the open area of the field more.

If this is Brett Favre, or Mahomes or one of many other QB greats, it doesn't even get talked about except to say how great of a throw it was.

If anything, it shows his confidence in his ability and his receivers and it's a play he will learn from.

it was a great throw but not a good decision. He got a bit lucky for sure the throw was a maybe half a second late and across the body.

I see people are saying he's bashing Brock. I don't see it that way this is how players get better you wouldn't coach that throw would you?

Again, do you think it's wise to "coach players" during press conferences with the media? This is the point we're all making.

Kyle and Brock, they're cool like that. It's a general rule to not throw across the body, late, into the middle of the field. I guarantee you Brock isn't feeling slighted by Kyle's comments.

Brock has been making those throws more and more each week. Let's go back to the back shoulder throws and less across the body to the middle of the field throws.

Brock actually did the same thing on his very first drive versus MIA when he came into the game, and the pass nearly got picked off. He's a playmaker, not a game manager. It's entertaining.

Originally posted by thl408:
Brock actually did the same thing on his very first drive versus MIA when he came into the game, and the pass nearly got picked off. He's a playmaker, not a game manager. It's entertaining.

Sure its a high risk throw. Point is, why call him out in a press conference.

He was asked about the TD and he gave an honest answer. If he said it was a great read we all would be questioning that.

"Honest." "Truth." It's as if you guys think the English language is limited and there was only one way for Kyle to answer the question. Several people have already posted much more palatable responses. Kyle is simply an a*****e and rarely passes on an opportunity to humble his QB publicly. It's what he does. If Purdy keeps playing the way he is, and wins a Super Bowl (or two or three), hopefully he starts chirping back. Hell, he's already earned the right to do that and I wish he would.

Sorry that's some soft ass s**t if you can't handle your coach saying a pass which was clearly a bad idea was a bad idea. I mean Brock is tough enough to handle it I'd suggest his fanboys to get there also

Again, this is such an intellectually lazy argument. So are you then being soft for not being able to handle criticism of Kyle? Of course not because that's a ridiculous argument, and honestly something that women do to each other. Do better.

Right lol calling Kyle an a*****e cause you can't take constructive criticism hitting the public

Calling a coach an a*****e for insulting his QB is vastly different than accusing another poster of being "soft" for their opinion of said remark. This is a forum to discuss the 49ers team, players, and coaches. So opinions on them are what should be discussed. Not sure why this is so difficult to understand.

Where was the insult towards Purdy?

"One of his worst decisions since he's been here" is an insult. Lol wtf. Especially on a highlight reel TD.