LISTEN: Looking For The 49ers' New DC With Jason Aponte →

There are 321 users in the forums

49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online

49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Originally posted by DaleGribble:
Really so the only explanation for someone having a different opinion than you is that they are a hater?

I'd say it's premature to call what he's built a juggernaut without a single title to his name I guess that makes me a hater.

Harbaugh has zero titles in the majors to his name too. Only one has built an all time offense.

Feel free to explain what you think Harbaugh has done in the pros that was more impressive than Kyle though. Unlike SD you could have actual nuanced thoughts on the subject.
[ Edited by 9ers4eva on Jan 9, 2024 at 2:45 PM ]
Originally posted by JTsBiggestFan:
If Harbs was so damn good we would've found a way to make it work somehow.....

Instead we suffered losing to the Giants, came woefully prepared against Baltimore, and had Seattle kick our ass every time we weren't in Candlestick.

So for all these guys who keep saying, KYLE CAN'T WIN THE BIG ONE...........let me tell you.........Harbaugh needed 1000x more to go RIGHT to win the big one.

And maybe Harbaugh didn't have the QB......

But neither did Kyle.....

Until now.

To put this in perspective, the 9ers were 1.5 point underdogs to the Chiefs. 9ers were 4.5 point favorites vs the Ravens.
[ Edited by 9ers4eva on Jan 9, 2024 at 2:48 PM ]
Originally posted by NYniner85:
camp body
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Originally posted by DaleGribble:
Really so the only explanation for someone having a different opinion than you is that they are a hater?

I'd say it's premature to call what he's built a juggernaut without a single title to his name I guess that makes me a hater.

Harbaugh has zero titles in the majors to his name too. Only one has built an all time offense.

Feel free to explain what you think Harbaugh has done in the pros that was more impressive than Kyle though. Unlike SD you could have actual nuanced thoughts on the subject.
I never said he was more impressive,I was a Harbaugh fan and felt he got a raw deal here, but I wouldn't trade Shanahan for him at this point I just think it's premature to declare either one the so called "winner" or to label someone a hater for preferring one over the other.
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
camp body

He'll compete with Aqib Talib for a roster spot.

Originally posted by JTsBiggestFan:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
some in the Harb thread have Harb over shanny .. lol

If Harbs was so damn good we would've found a way to make it work somehow.....

Instead we suffered losing to the Giants, came woefully prepared against Baltimore, and had Seattle kick our ass every time we weren't in Candlestick.

So for all these guys who keep saying, KYLE CAN'T WIN THE BIG ONE...........let me tell you.........Harbaugh needed 1000x more to go RIGHT to win the big one.

And maybe Harbaugh didn't have the QB......

But neither did Kyle.....

Until now.
They both had the QB of their choosing,and Kyle had a 10 point lead with around 8 minutes to go and the ball vs the Chiefs that's an awfully strong position to be in and lose the game.
Originally posted by DaleGribble:
Originally posted by JTsBiggestFan:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
some in the Harb thread have Harb over shanny .. lol

If Harbs was so damn good we would've found a way to make it work somehow.....

Instead we suffered losing to the Giants, came woefully prepared against Baltimore, and had Seattle kick our ass every time we weren't in Candlestick.

So for all these guys who keep saying, KYLE CAN'T WIN THE BIG ONE...........let me tell you.........Harbaugh needed 1000x more to go RIGHT to win the big one.

And maybe Harbaugh didn't have the QB......

But neither did Kyle.....

Until now.
They both had the QB of their choosing,and Kyle had a 10 point lead with around 8 minutes to go and the ball vs the Chiefs that's an awfully strong position to be in and lose the game.
not that strong not in today's NFL
Originally posted by DaleGribble:
Originally posted by JTsBiggestFan:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
some in the Harb thread have Harb over shanny .. lol

If Harbs was so damn good we would've found a way to make it work somehow.....

Instead we suffered losing to the Giants, came woefully prepared against Baltimore, and had Seattle kick our ass every time we weren't in Candlestick.

So for all these guys who keep saying, KYLE CAN'T WIN THE BIG ONE...........let me tell you.........Harbaugh needed 1000x more to go RIGHT to win the big one.

And maybe Harbaugh didn't have the QB......

But neither did Kyle.....

Until now.
They both had the QB of their choosing,and Kyle had a 10 point lead with around 8 minutes to go and the ball vs the Chiefs that's an awfully strong position to be in and lose the game.

Huh? Jimmy was Lynch's choice and talked Kyle into it. That's been well documented. Kyle had to approve obviously but it's not like Kyle was the one who said give me Jimmy. And two years later he was already flirting with multiple other QBs.
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Originally posted by JTsBiggestFan:
If Harbs was so damn good we would've found a way to make it work somehow.....

Instead we suffered losing to the Giants, came woefully prepared against Baltimore, and had Seattle kick our ass every time we weren't in Candlestick.

So for all these guys who keep saying, KYLE CAN'T WIN THE BIG ONE...........let me tell you.........Harbaugh needed 1000x more to go RIGHT to win the big one.

And maybe Harbaugh didn't have the QB......

But neither did Kyle.....

Until now.

To put this in perspective, the 9ers were 1.5 point underdogs to the Chiefs. 9ers were 4.5 point favorites vs the Ravens.
So your saying because the betting line favored the Chiefs the loss to the Ravens was worse even though the 49ers blew a 10 point lead with possession of the ball and 8 minutes to go vs the Chiefs?
Originally posted by DaleGribble:
So your saying because the betting line favored the Chiefs the loss to the Ravens was worse even though the 49ers blew a 10 point lead with possession of the ball and 8 minutes to go vs the Chiefs?

Personally think the Ravens loss was worse. Chiefs were down 10 plus in every postseason game they played (won every game by 10 plus which I believe was unprecedented). It was only a matter of time with that offense.

That said, judging Harbaugh or Shanahan with this as a focal point misses the mark for me.
Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:
Originally posted by DaleGribble:
Originally posted by JTsBiggestFan:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
some in the Harb thread have Harb over shanny .. lol

If Harbs was so damn good we would've found a way to make it work somehow.....

Instead we suffered losing to the Giants, came woefully prepared against Baltimore, and had Seattle kick our ass every time we weren't in Candlestick.

So for all these guys who keep saying, KYLE CAN'T WIN THE BIG ONE...........let me tell you.........Harbaugh needed 1000x more to go RIGHT to win the big one.

And maybe Harbaugh didn't have the QB......

But neither did Kyle.....

Until now.
They both had the QB of their choosing,and Kyle had a 10 point lead with around 8 minutes to go and the ball vs the Chiefs that's an awfully strong position to be in and lose the game.

Huh? Jimmy was Lynch's choice and talked Kyle into it. That's been well documented. Kyle had to approve obviously but it's not like Kyle was the one who said give me Jimmy. And two years later he was already flirting with multiple other QBs.
The fact that he had to approve the trade made it his decision and equates to him saying give me Jimmy regardless of how he came to that decision.
Originally posted by DaleGribble:
Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:
Originally posted by DaleGribble:
Originally posted by JTsBiggestFan:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
some in the Harb thread have Harb over shanny .. lol

If Harbs was so damn good we would've found a way to make it work somehow.....

Instead we suffered losing to the Giants, came woefully prepared against Baltimore, and had Seattle kick our ass every time we weren't in Candlestick.

So for all these guys who keep saying, KYLE CAN'T WIN THE BIG ONE...........let me tell you.........Harbaugh needed 1000x more to go RIGHT to win the big one.

And maybe Harbaugh didn't have the QB......

But neither did Kyle.....

Until now.
They both had the QB of their choosing,and Kyle had a 10 point lead with around 8 minutes to go and the ball vs the Chiefs that's an awfully strong position to be in and lose the game.

Huh? Jimmy was Lynch's choice and talked Kyle into it. That's been well documented. Kyle had to approve obviously but it's not like Kyle was the one who said give me Jimmy. And two years later he was already flirting with multiple other QBs.
The fact that he had to approve the trade made it his decision and equates to him saying give me Jimmy regardless of how he came to that decision.
that is not the same as "choosing their QBs"
Originally posted by DaleGribble:
Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:
Originally posted by DaleGribble:
Originally posted by JTsBiggestFan:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
some in the Harb thread have Harb over shanny .. lol

If Harbs was so damn good we would've found a way to make it work somehow.....

Instead we suffered losing to the Giants, came woefully prepared against Baltimore, and had Seattle kick our ass every time we weren't in Candlestick.

So for all these guys who keep saying, KYLE CAN'T WIN THE BIG ONE...........let me tell you.........Harbaugh needed 1000x more to go RIGHT to win the big one.

And maybe Harbaugh didn't have the QB......

But neither did Kyle.....

Until now.
They both had the QB of their choosing,and Kyle had a 10 point lead with around 8 minutes to go and the ball vs the Chiefs that's an awfully strong position to be in and lose the game.

Huh? Jimmy was Lynch's choice and talked Kyle into it. That's been well documented. Kyle had to approve obviously but it's not like Kyle was the one who said give me Jimmy. And two years later he was already flirting with multiple other QBs.
The fact that he had to approve the trade made it his decision and equates to him saying give me Jimmy regardless of how he came to that decision.

Lol ok.
Search Share 49ersWebzone