49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Originally posted by Young2Rice:

I was answering the other posters question "I'd like to know how a coach makes a guy not false start?" Practice timing.

As to your question, I am sure they are practicing it, but that doesn't mean it is effective. That is on shanny. When you have an entire team last in penalties that is on the coach.

Its like saying a teacher isn't responsible for 25/30 students failing the class. But if its like 4-5 students and the rest are passing it doesn't reflect poorly on the teacher.

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by Young2Rice:
I was answering the other posters question "I'd like to know how a coach makes a guy not false start?" Practice timing.

As to your question, I am sure they are practicing it, but that doesn't mean it is effective. That is on shanny. When you have an entire team last in penalties that is on the coach.

Its like saying a teacher isn't responsible for 25/30 students failing the class. But if its like 4-5 students and the rest are passing it doesn't reflect poorly on the teacher.

What if 25 of those students are simply destined to be pumping gas and bagging groceries in the future?

Of the most egregious offenders when it comes to penalties it is largely guys who have no future with this team in any capacity.

Originally posted by Young2Rice:

Shanny is in charge of the final roster so he bears responsibility there too. Can't totally absovle a head coach when the team leads the league in flags. Its not all on him but its not all the players either. He shares some responsibility.

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by Young2Rice:

Shanny is in charge of the final roster so he bears responsibility there too. Can't totally absovle a head coach when the team leads the league in flags. Its not all on him but its not all the players either. He shares some responsibility.

Its Year 1 of a rebuild. You're going to have a bunch of filler that will be replaced sooner rather than later.


If the roster gets better and Shanahan starts winning, nobody will really give a crap about the penalty situation one way or another.


The Harbaugh teams led the NFL in delay of game penalties. Plenty of people were happy to overlook that while the team was winning.

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Winning cures all...Except complaints about OCs who don't score enough points despite winning tons of games, wearing down defenses and controlling the clock.

Originally posted by Young2Rice:

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by Young2Rice:

I was answering the other posters question "I'd like to know how a coach makes a guy not false start?" Practice timing.

As to your question, I am sure they are practicing it, but that doesn't mean it is effective. That is on shanny. When you have an entire team last in penalties that is on the coach.

Its like saying a teacher isn't responsible for 25/30 students failing the class. But if its like 4-5 students and the rest are passing it doesn't reflect poorly on the teacher.

What if 25 of those students are simply destined to be pumping gas and bagging groceries in the future?

Of the most egregious offenders when it comes to penalties it is largely guys who have no future with this team in any capacity.

Shanny is in charge of the final roster so he bears responsibility there too. Can't totally absovle a head coach when the team leads the league in flags. Its not all on him but its not all the players either. He shares some responsibility.

Originally posted by jonnydel:

Originally posted by Young2Rice:

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by Young2Rice:
I was answering the other posters question "I'd like to know how a coach makes a guy not false start?" Practice timing.

As to your question, I am sure they are practicing it, but that doesn't mean it is effective. That is on shanny. When you have an entire team last in penalties that is on the coach.

Its like saying a teacher isn't responsible for 25/30 students failing the class. But if its like 4-5 students and the rest are passing it doesn't reflect poorly on the teacher.

What if 25 of those students are simply destined to be pumping gas and bagging groceries in the future?

Of the most egregious offenders when it comes to penalties it is largely guys who have no future with this team in any capacity.

Shanny is in charge of the final roster so he bears responsibility there too. Can't totally absovle a head coach when the team leads the league in flags. Its not all on him but its not all the players either. He shares some responsibility.

Sweet, so if I run a stop sign and smash in to your car I can say my drivers ed teacher was at fault. Sounds great. Because even though they taught me that a stop sign meant stop and we practiced stopping at stop signs they still bear the responsibility. So, if you wamt restitution when this happens you can see Mr Nelson

Originally posted by jonnydel:

Originally posted by Young2Rice:

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by Young2Rice:

I was answering the other posters question "I'd like to know how a coach makes a guy not false start?" Practice timing.

As to your question, I am sure they are practicing it, but that doesn't mean it is effective. That is on shanny. When you have an entire team last in penalties that is on the coach.

Its like saying a teacher isn't responsible for 25/30 students failing the class. But if its like 4-5 students and the rest are passing it doesn't reflect poorly on the teacher.

What if 25 of those students are simply destined to be pumping gas and bagging groceries in the future?

Of the most egregious offenders when it comes to penalties it is largely guys who have no future with this team in any capacity.

Shanny is in charge of the final roster so he bears responsibility there too. Can't totally absovle a head coach when the team leads the league in flags. Its not all on him but its not all the players either. He shares some responsibility.

Sweet, so if I run a stop sign and smash in to your car I can say my drivers ed teacher was at fault. Sounds great. Because even though they taught me that a stop sign meant stop and we practiced stopping at stop signs they still bear the responsibility. So, if you wamt restitution when this happens you can see Mr Nelson

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Winning cures all...Except complaints about OCs who don't score enough points despite winning tons of games, wearing down defenses and controlling the clock.

Who is that guy calling plays for nowadays anyways?


Roman was fantastic at scheming the run game, it is in the passing game where he went potato far too often. That pitch to Ted Ginn deep in 49ers territory vs the Rams still strikes me as one of the worst playcalls I've seen from an OC at any level.

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by Young2Rice:

Shanny is in charge of the final roster so he bears responsibility there too. Can't totally absovle a head coach when the team leads the league in flags. Its not all on him but its not all the players either. He shares some responsibility.

Its Year 1 of a rebuild. You're going to have a bunch of filler that will be replaced sooner rather than later.


If the roster gets better and Shanahan starts winning, nobody will really give a crap about the penalty situation one way or another.


The Harbaugh teams led the NFL in delay of game penalties. Plenty of people were happy to overlook that while the team was winning.

Originally posted by jonnydel:

Originally posted by Young2Rice:

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by Young2Rice:
I was answering the other posters question "I'd like to know how a coach makes a guy not false start?" Practice timing.

As to your question, I am sure they are practicing it, but that doesn't mean it is effective. That is on shanny. When you have an entire team last in penalties that is on the coach.

Its like saying a teacher isn't responsible for 25/30 students failing the class. But if its like 4-5 students and the rest are passing it doesn't reflect poorly on the teacher.

What if 25 of those students are simply destined to be pumping gas and bagging groceries in the future?

Of the most egregious offenders when it comes to penalties it is largely guys who have no future with this team in any capacity.

Shanny is in charge of the final roster so he bears responsibility there too. Can't totally absovle a head coach when the team leads the league in flags. Its not all on him but its not all the players either. He shares some responsibility.

Sweet, so if I run a stop sign and smash in to your car I can say my drivers ed teacher was at fault. Sounds great. Because even though they taught me that a stop sign meant stop and we practiced stopping at stop signs they still bear the responsibility. So, if you wamt restitution when this happens you can see Mr Nelson

Originally posted by SmokeCrabtrees:
Dudes nobody gives a f**k about the Harbs/Roman days. PM each other your fricken gossipers ...

Originally posted by pdizo916:

Originally posted by SmokeCrabtrees:

Dudes nobody gives a f**k about the Harbs/Roman days. PM each other your fricken gossipers ...

i remember everyone hated roman. Now he would be the best coach outside of Shanny.

Originally posted by jonnydel:

gameplanning, gameplanning and more gameplanning - there's so much involved in game-planning it's ridiculous.... Also, teaching technique, thorough understanding of the playbook and when to execute different techniques in those playcalls and against different looks from the opponent. Position coaches diagnosing plays and when one of their positions fails during a game and why they failed so that an adjustment can be made. Running drills to teach technique.

There's so much more that goes into coaching than talking to players about penalties. You can't do much to practice guys not forgetting the snap count.